No. 5~ Argumentertainment
Since the dawn of that thing that is inside our skulls, full of blood and stuff, making us do most all the things we do (everyone please pause to admire the psychology degree on the wall behind me), we humans have really not gotten along all that well. We've gotten along pretty well, considering the 200,000 years or so we've all been putzing around the rock beneath us in our modern state. We're all still here. We're definitely not in bad shape. Look at this!
Really, that's not too shabby. We're of the least concern, according to ourselves, on a list we made. Certainly if that changes, we really need to start being concerned. Moving up on that list is like all of humankind passing by the first stage, Accepting that we have a problem. But we're not there yet.
That is not to say that we are incapable of pointing out terrible character flaws in our society.
What I am going to do here is bring you through a complaint arc that will end in an epiphany. If you get to the point where you're impatient and cranky with my complaining, and you want me to stop complaining, well, the X is right up there in the right hand corner of your screen. Yes, I'm aware that Macs don't have anything to click up there in that corner. That's called a subtle slam on how impatient and cranky Windows users can get, and face it, you all just got totally slapped.
So here's a thing I have never really liked. Reality television. I guess we could say that Survivor started the whole thing. Since I am not an expert, I am going to guesstimate that Survivor, Big Brother, those early shows were the point at which reality programming saw a massive boom in popularity. So we're talking, what, 11 years now?
For a long time, I hated it. I could not stand it. It wasn't just the fact that everyone was obsessed with it. People have been obsessed with things before, and I have not always agreed. People have been crazy about country music for decades and decades and I have always been crazy about immediately changing the station to anything else. Big F'in deal. What was so infuriating about reality TV was how I felt like I was one of like three people people who didn't like it. When Survivor aired, the next day, I would have not known that Survivor had aired, and so I wouldn't have known that the gay guy won an ugly Pontiac SUV, and I was a PARIAH. "What? You didn't watch it? Get out." True conversation. Can't believe my English teacher said that to me.
Time passed. Fewer and fewer scripts were written. People were hooked on these things. I soon realized another thing about it. Shows which I felt like were the lowest common denominator of intelligence level, and appealed to the lowest common denominator of humans, were beloved by people whom I saw as equals. What was I missing? I'm not any more worldly than these people. I'm certainly not any better than them. I share fart jokes with these guys and laugh about really really dumb cartoons, but when it comes to talking about yesterday's Viva La Bam, Jesus Christ, I find nothing funny about that guy skateboarding into a Lamborghini and fracturing his eyeballs. What is wrong with me?
Show after show got made. Some premiered to bigger viewing numbers than the Pope's funeral. Survivor: Compton. The Hills 90210. Real World Road Rules Alaskan Pipeline Challenge. So I Think I Can Drive Drunk. My Mom Got Me Pregnant. I Didn't Know I Was Asian. I was beginning to fear for the very fabric of American society.
But recently, I had had a few beers, and I turned on the History Channel (I have fun when I drink, you guys), and the show Pawn Stars was on. This unassuming program is about a few guys who run a pawn shop, into which people come with their crap, to find out it's ancient Egyptian crap and is worth six hundred million dollars. I watched a many-hour marathon. The History Channel routinely plays marathons of their own shows because let's face it, there are only so many Hitler documentaries out there.
Soon thereafter, I wondered, aloud, to no one in particular, why I watched that show for so long. No one is going to think I'm cool for watching Pawn Stars. Besides the sexually-charged-yet-extremely-lazy pun in the title, it's the least cool-sounding show I've ever heard of. But here's what I realized: It has information. Full of it! The guys get these things from people, and they bring in experts, and the experts give you a little blurb about how, like, members of the Gambino crime family were Sicilian but there were Russian associates, though they were not true mafia members because you have to be Sicilian to be a made man. It's informative. And I know, it is NOT REAL. None of this really happens off the cuff, but at least I feel like I've learned a little something.
Herein lies the revelation. The shows I truly loathe, the Jersey Shores, the Real Housewives of Who Cares Where, the 16 and Pregnants, the Teen Moms, the Keeping Up With The Kardashians, the Big Rich Texases, these shows have damn near one dimension. This dimension, this crutch, is people arguing.
I've watched my fair share of these shows and, far and away, the one thing people do more than anything on these shows is argue. No one likes each other! They hate each other to the core! They all want to tear each others lips off and use them to plug their own ears so they don't need to hear anything but their own muffled voice inside their own giant ego heads.
It's not the so-called scriptlessness; humans can be funny on their own. Not everyone can be, certainly not MTV reality stars; but some people are just funny. Take a look at improv comedians. And it's not the format. Though, as a friend reminded me, multiple camera angles in a candid shot means the shot had to be staged. It's not all of the obvious flaws that are kinda annoying about reality TV. It's the entire premise of these shows that gets me. The whole thing is fake, except for how much these people hate each other.
So here are two things that distance me from the average fan of situational reality.
a. I have no sick interest in watching people be miserable. Uncomfortable situations are not funny to me. Meet The Parents is a shit salad of a movie franchise. The Office stopped being funny when The Office relied primarily on awkward pauses. When people are just bickering over nothing, wherein I might see "terrible" and "not interesting," others seem to find what I now call Argumentertainment. Dear Oxford English Dictionary.
b. It's fake! A lot of people think it's 100% real. People got MAD, SO MAD! when it was suggested that The Hills was scripted. The Hills, where Heidi Montag got $600,000 of silicon put into her to make her look like a blow-up sex doll glued to two Hindenburg zeppelins. But even when they are told it's fake, it's still somehow real to them, dammit.
You know what it is? Reality TV is professional wrestling in the everyday world. The next time you watch a show and in the back of your head, you want to think it's real, think of this instead: