hey vertigo, i hope you're feeling better today 🫶
one question: what do you understand by shauna's phrase to jackie before cremating her? ("i don't even know where you end and i begin") i've seen several different interpretations and i was wondering what you would think of it
honestly i've always found it to be a fairly self-contained profession. shauna spent so long living in jackie's shadow—wearing the things she told her to wear, liking the things she wanted her to like, even going as far as to sleep with her boyfriend in what i perceive as both an effort to emulate her and feel closer to her—that she began to lose sight of her own sense of identity. because if you strip her of her relationship with jackie and all the things she does to please her, what does she have left?
it's pretty obvious that their friendship was incredibly co-dependent. they went everywhere and did everything together. i think jackie was content with this; she never even questioned that shauna would follow her to rutgers. never even entertained that shauna might want to do something else just for herself. meanwhile, shauna was sitting on a deap-seated resentment that only festered the longer she ignored it. if that resentment was thoroughly dissected, however, you'd probably find that it was directed more towards herself. shauna is intelligent. she has free will and the capacity to make her own choices in life, so why does she keep making the ones she knows jackie will approve of at the expense of her own happiness and comfort?
in any other context, a line like this would read as affectionate or even romantic, but shauna spits it at jackie like acid. it's an accusation. in her mind, jackie is the mastermind behind shauna's discontent. she has wrapped shauna around her little finger. she has fastened a leash to her throat and she yanks her every this way and that. in my opinion, jackie's awareness of shauna's unhappiness was not as all-encompassing as shauna believed it was. she was a lonely teenage girl, bored of her life and bored of her relationship, and shauna was the only person she truly loved. she wanted to keep her close because she was scared of losing her.
it is possible that jackie was consciously trying to shape shauna into her mirror's image. not because she really wanted to change her, but because she wanted shauna to be accepted in the same spaces, to be able to follow her into the same rooms; because she wanted, desperately, for the two of them to make sense together, in spite of their glaring differences. in all likelihood, jackie saw these differences as a threat to their relationship. she was also likely threatened by how clever and capable shauna was. to encourage that side of her, to nurture her independence, might mean that shauna would outgrow her. that she would someday see herself as too good for someone like jackie.
whether the plane had crashed or not, i think it was only a matter of time before shauna snapped under the weight of it all. she always wanted more for herself. she didn't want to be jackie's friend, she just wanted to be shauna. she wanted to be seen. and i think she wanted jackie to see her most of all. see her, acknowledge her, accept her, and love her without trying to change her. the heartbreaking thing is that, in my opinion, jackie always saw shauna. she saw more in her than shauna probably saw in herself, but she was insecure and deathly afraid of not being good enough for her, so (intentionally or otherwise) she made sure that shauna would always feel the same way. she clipped her wings because she loved her too much to let her go.