Iâm slightly disturbed by the present notion going around that, if an author is problematic, you can no longer read and/or enjoy their work
or, more specifically, that you must instantly drop it and never speak of it again, no questions asked
mostly because if you try to only read books by the most ideologically perfect people, youâre going to rapidly run out of things to read. for one, anything written before likeâŚ1960 is out. for another, that one shining individual whose work alone youâre willing to read doesnât exist.
every adult has done problematic things. the only difference is the scale and nature of the mistakes made
sure, voting with your wallet is a thing. Iâd definitely be willing to buy a book by a currently-living author who isnât always kind to their fans, and not by one who committed sexual assault. but thereâs nuance to the simple act of reading or liking a book, separate from giving the author money, and it must be approached as such
what did the author do that you donât like? how much of it comes out in their work? in what ways? what aspects of their work have value to you? is there enough value in it for you to continue liking it, even if you donât condone the way the author behaves? will you continue recommending it to others? is the negative behavior confirmed to your satisfaction? can you, personally, reconcile disliking the author with liking their work? (because in the end, itâs a matter of personal choice and conscience)
saying âthis author did/does bad things, so anyone who reads or likes their work must also be badâ is an appealing way to absolve yourself of the need for critical thinking. and guess what? thatâs an important part of life
itâs easy to say âthis is cancelled because the author sucksâ for works you donât care about. but someday, it will be something you love under the microscope. count on it. youâll have to grapple with these questions, and it wonât be easy
people need to develop the skills to deal with complex topics in a thoughtful manner, and I worry that theyâre being encouraged not to