Story Pile: th3 wh0l3 3l3ph4nt â Megatokyo In Full
In 2011, the novel Fifty Shades of Grey was published and over the next two years became a bestselling novel in the erotic thriller genre. Telling the story of nobody cares and it doesnât matter as they not gunna check, the book was successful on an unexpected scale, prompting critical reviews and then an examination of the success itself. Fifty Shades of Grey put its author, one EL James, into the Forbesâ list of highest-earning authors, and resulted in a highly publicised, successful movie trilogy. As of date, itâs made over one and a half billion dollars.
The examinations of Fifty Shades of Grey involved bringing to light its origin as a Twilight alternate-universe fanfiction on a fanfiction forum, published weekly from 2009-2011. It is one of the most successful examples of a new web creator, where someone made their own transformative fanfiction, it gathered an audience, that audience then were enough to propel the form into the attention of conventional publishing, and that publishing drew in and solidified that existing audience, then used its greater access to propel the work to higher and higher stages of what we typically call âsuccess,â because people paid money for it, and money is what we use to fill our souls in a capitalist system.
This success seems completely decoupled from critical reception, which was, it seems, overwhelmingly negative. I have yet to find someone wholeheartedly speaking well of any of EL Jamesâ actual work as a writer, now that the fanfiction version has been deleted off the forums it was being posted on. The world we live in now is one where it isnât hard at all to find people willing to present a new, interesting examination of Fifty Shades of Grey, having read it all, that has to establish that whatever else it has going on, the book series is quite bad. Criticising it, though, automatically brings with it the possibility of being seen as anti-smut, or anti-woman, or anti-Twilight (which is a good thing to be), and there is therefore a typical critical perspective that in order to engage with Fifty Shades of Grey, one cannot merely watch a scene and respond to it, or hear the idea and react to that, but instead, one must completely examine the text, read the books, the notes, and the movies, and then, armed with references and citations, explain what they already knew, at the start, that this book is as bad as they thought it was, and in fact, it was worse.
This is a huge task! Itâs not enough to react sensibly to a thing you know, then, the impetus is that you have to understand it deeply and thoroughly. One must eat the entire elephant.
This isnât about Fifty Shades of Grey.
I want to introduce you to my elephant.
Spoiler Warning, and Content Warning, and Size Warning. Iâm going to spoil the entire plot of Megatokyo in this article. Iâm also going to talk about ideas like racism and misogyny and transmisogyny in a largely PG-rated webcomic. Finally, at the point where Iâm writing this paragraph, this text is sitting around 15,000 words. Iâm going to do what I can to make it more approachable, but this is not a breezy little read. Thereâs also a Table of Contents below this point, and each section has a âback to table of contentsâ link for your convenience in reading. If youâd like to watch this article as a video instead, itâs available on Youtube, here.