Ok, I know itâs been three years and maybe thereâs no point in discoursing about this but...
I just saw a post by someone who talked about Megâs devotion to Cas in such beautiful terms I was hovering over that like button untilâŚ. they said âI donât personally believe he reciprocated her feelings.â With all due respect, THAT IS NOT UP FOR DEBATE. I feel like there is so much meta and discourse about non-canon ships that some people forget canon ships are not subject to your opinion about whether or not theyâre real.
Megstiel is canon. It just IS. Ask Rachel. Ask Misha. Ask the writers. Or just, you know, WATCH THE SHOW. Some of the non-canon ships do get subtext moments that tease at relationships that arenât in the text, sometimes intentionally put there for fans, and thatâs cool. Thereâs nothing wrong with those ships or the people who like them. But the difference is, those moments are the writers ALLOWING us to ship Sam and Dean, or Dean and Cas, or Sam and Gabriel, or whoever. Itâs a wink that gives permission, not a blatant intent. Weâre SUPPOSED to see romance between Cas and Meg. Itâs not âimplied.â Itâs just THERE.
Cas and Meg have sexual tension from the moment they meet - not in subtext, but in the TEXT. (And if youâre about to argue that âDean literally saw sparks fly when he met Cas, and nothing like that happened with Cas and Meg,â you clearly have never heard Johnny Cash sing Ring of Fire.) Throughout their interactions in seasons 5 and 6, Meg openly flirted with Cas at every opportunity and blatantly indicated attraction. Meanwhile, Cas was observably flustered whenever he was around her. They kissed. Contrary to popular belief, Cas DID indicate that he was interested in having sex with Meg. Watch the scene again - he was not misunderstanding the suggestion. He was guiltily deflecting it.
In season 7, he becomes insane, she becomes his caretaker, and he developed a canonically established crush on her. Again, this was not something that could maybe sort of be hinted at by subtle details if you squint. This was confirmed by the writers, by the actors, and by the actual dialogue of the show. Crazy!Cas had a crush on Meg. Period. During that time, SHE seemed to brush off HIS advances, possibly because she knew he was not of sound mind, but her actions in caring for him demonstrate a degree of emotional investment even though Meg probably wouldnât admit it.
The final episode they share begins with a recap of EVERY ROMANTIC MOMENT THEY SHARED, from staring at each other and mutual heavy breathing in the infamous Ring of Fire to kissing in Crowleyâs dungeon to multiple instances of her using her pet name for him. We donât get flashbacks like this when thereâs going to be a subtext moment. The âTHENâ for Goodbye Stranger was pretty much a neon sign saying HEY LOOK REMEMBER ALL THE TIMES ROMANTIC/SEXUAL STUFF HAPPENED BETWEEN CAS AND MEG? BECAUSE THIS EPISODE IS DEFINITELY GOING TO BE ABOUT THAT. And then it proceeded to show him tenderly caring for her, admitting he had feelings for her, reminiscing fondly about kissing her, and ultimately agreeing - with a certain degree of that long-standing flusteredness - that yes, they really should finally have sex once they survive this battle.
Even the one time Meg is undeniably mentioned in canon after her death, itâs because Cas-in-human-disguise has named himself using her pet name for him. And even this is set up in flashbacks with Meg making flirty eyes at Cas while calling him Clarence. WE ARE SUPPOSED TO SEE THIS.
Look, Iâm not saying my ship is better than yours just because itâs canon. We Megstiel shippers do the same things shippers of non-canon ships do sometimes - we create elaborate theories based on background details to support headcanons that Meg and Cas totally did consummate their relationship offscreen before she died, or that heâs still in love with her and makes decisions to this day that are based on that love, or that Meg somehow survived and they will find each other again, or secretly already have. Thereâs no canon support for most of this. Itâs all in the realm of fanfiction. But we do it because it comforts us, and in that way we are just like non-canon shippers.
But none of that changes the fact that Megstiel is canon. You donât get to say you donât believe Cas loved Meg back, because Cas himself told you he did. You can NOT LIKE a canon ship. Some people didnât like Dean with Lisa. A lot of people didnât like Sam with Amelia. You can dislike a canon pairing, either because it got in the way of something you wanted, or you just werenât a fan of one of the characters, or you didnât think they were good for each other, or any number of things. But NOT LIKING IT DOESNâT MEAN IT DIDNâT HAPPEN.
And Cas and Meg, whether you like it or not, happened.