"Cloud Music: Almost there"
At Pulse, we listen to a lot of music throughout the day. Most of it comes from Pandora. The ability to pick great Pandora radio stations was actually one of the requirements of working at Pulse that caught my eye when I applied. We're always looking for new office DJs. Especially ones with iOS, Android and Web skills. ;)
Streaming radio is great for music discovery, but what if I want to play songs I own/know? Normally, you'd fire up [insert mp3 app] and listen to your collection, while when away from the computer you're limited to the songs you synchronized to your device.
I personally feel like local storage is a thing of the past. We now have cheap cloud storage with redundancy and fast mobile communication technologies(3G/4G). I haven't seen the point of storing my music locally for a while, let alone plugging my device to sync new tracks. Companies are claiming the we're entering a Post-PC era, but that's certainly not the case until you lose the USB cable. Let's face it, they're giants trying to please the record industry who care most about their bottom line. There's more money to be made by selling individual track/albums and upselling storage on machines and devices.
Despite the licensing challenges with the record companies, there are a number of streaming music services that are great alternatives to the iTunes monopoly. I will discuss some of the services that I've used and their pros and cons. There are clearly some services that I've left out, but they should resemble the ones discussed. Let me know if you feel they're important and I'll make sure to check them out.
Probably the least likely service on the list to be fully legal, but by far my most used. I've been a long time user of Grooveshark and i even signed up for their Grooveshark Anywhere subscription before the price went up. The $30/year is a small price to pay for a streaming music library. Not only that , but it's a small price to pay for my innocence/ignorance in court when we find out none of it was legal.
FREE (Unlimited web access)
$9/month (Unlimited access on mobile, desktop and web)
Playlist (Making, Following, Discovery)
HTML 5 player (flash needed for streaming/DRM)
iPhone(jailbreak), Android, Blackberry, WebOS, Nokia apps
Relatively intuitive user interface
Actual web app rather than website with track links
No library access on mobile, only playlists and searches
Duplicate songs in searches, albums
Some songs are of terrible audio quality (can be flagged)
Not the best recommendation engine (Pandora still is king)
OK so tagging is awful, but this can easily be fixed with a little crowd-sourcing effort. Why couldn't the community edit ID3 tags? If users care about their music, then there should be no foul play. If there is then users can flag the person that edited the track. Seems simple right?
Store your personal music and Amazon MP3 collection in the cloud and stream it from the web and Android device. Great in theory and it works well, yet it suffers from the initial friction of having to upload your library. Would you like to wait while you upload 20GB? I like this product because of what it represents (Amazon's middle finger to the record industry). Amazon is simply offering storage for tracks you already own or are purchasing. The only thing that's changed is the easy access to the music.
1 Amazon Album Purchase (20GB)
$1/GB/yr (20/50/100/200/500/1000 GB)
Expensive storage cost (Google offers 20GB for $5/yr)
Easy upload tool with iTunes integration
Great audio quality (varies based on your uploads)
[Update]Expensive storage cost (Google offers 20GB for $5/yr)
With a lower storage price and more native client features (tag editing, music suggestion, radio) this could be the "cloud player" we've been looking for.
MOG has been creating some buzz lately. It wasn't always a music streaming service. It started out as a music social network. Due to its roots, the site has lots of content around the music including in-house editorial. Most notably it streams high quality 320kbps tracks!
Favorites (kind of like a library)
Featured Albums, Tracks, Playlists
Mobile clients (iOS, Android)
Social Music discovery (Pandora-like voting, and more)
Lots of content around the music
Pretty good recommendations
Too many transition effects
Awkward 'add to favorite' and playlist workflow
Incomplete Chrome app (Can't create playlists or favorite)
The price is steep for the experience and service offered in comparison to competitors. Not sure if the complementary content (artwork, blogs, etc.) is a great selling point. The overall experience needs to change from a website to more of an app. At the moment it feels very Last.fm-ish.
Rdio is a service very similar to MOG with mobile clients and priced similarly($3.99, $9.99/month).
8tracks allows users to create playlists of 8 tracks. The site has a great social community and now offers a mobile client. (Free, $50/yr)
Zune Pass is the famous music service from Microsoft which adopts the American all-you-can-eat mentality. $14.99 gets you unlimited streaming/downloading to PC, Xbox, Windows Phone 7 and Zune. Bonus, you get to keep 10 tracks each month DRM-free.
I'm always up for discovering new music services that fit my needs, so drop me a line in the comments about services you like. You can follow my music listening at the following: