When do you think Plutarch figured out Coins character? How do you imagine their dynamic? What do you think of their ship( I personally don't like it as a romantic pairing)
Great question, anon! I've asked myself the same thing.
I think that from the start it was too glittery to be all gold for Plutarch. After probably digging around sources, he finds District 13. He wished for an army, an army shows up. He learns Coin is their leader -- could he have established an in-person meeting? I wonder how. Whenever the first talk happened, I think Plutarch figured her out. He must have asked himself "what's her goal here?". She shows up, willing to give him access to her army, accepting his funding, willing to overthrow Snow, never lost a kid for the games and marketing herself as the next best alternative out of what, kindness of pure heart?
Plutarch saw right through it, he just had to go with it because she was still the best chance at getting Snow out and basically, well, I suppose how to stop Coin was for later, if it all went according to plan. He was gambling when he made the alliance and he knew it was a gamble, anything would have been a gamble.
So from the get going I think their dynamic is a 3D chess match Machiavelli would have paid 100€ to watch. While he's measuring each of his steps, she's trying to figure out what are Plutarch's intentions here. From her perspective, what is this guy after? People to fight for his cause so once Snow is out, Plutarch could be president? But she wants to be president and she needs his money and Capitol expertise. I think the plan was to get rid of Plutarch after the presidential speech, after the new games are decided. I think there's a visual reason why he's not on the stage next to her during the speech. From his side, he figured out her unsaid plan, correctly guesses he may end up murdered at some point, acts submissive so not to threat her.
I don't like it as a romantic ship either because I think it makes it very uncomfortable from Coin's perspective. She has a tribal response to Capitolites and she would all of a sudden have the most intimate act with the wealthiest Capitolite in living history? Maybe she could wrap her head around the fact it would be for manipulation but how is that needed? She leads the 13 army, she has Plutarch in her hand consequently. She's essential to the cause. Wouldn't fucking open a possibility to Plutarch feel like he's more powerful than he is, from Coin's point of view? Too close, too risky. I definitely see her with a 13 fuckboy because that's just easier. No risk of oversharing caught off guard, can take her mind off completely and doesn't give him the satisfaction, keeps him at bay, cautious. That would be the most intelligent strategy.
I see how abstractally there's the "keep your enemies closer" yada yada but in practical terms how does that work? I just think for a fandom that already has a major issue with sex positivity (well, with sex as a fact), I have no intention of adding to that with writing sex = manipulation. For personal reasons, I feel very uncomfortable with the idea of using sex to manipulate one another and fucking someone who hates you. I leave that to Caesar Flickerman and Claudius Templesmith. I can see flirting, sure, but that's calculated and enough for what both are trying to achieve. I also think Plutarch got too far and dedicated his entire life to this one goal not to be sexually manipulated and/or abused.
Thank you for your questions, anon! Always feel free to reply/send more 🐝