Pre-fic fic: Fan fiction before fanfiction
Even though the definition of fanfiction as we know it today has only really been a thing since the mid 1960âs, people have been writing what we might consider fanfiction since before the printing press was invented. Danteâs Divine Comedy, which details the authorâs idea of what Hell is like (you could call it Bible fanfic if you really wanted to), was published shortly before his death in 1321, as opposed to the roughly 1439 creation date of Gutenbergâs first press.Â
Good olâ Willy Shakespeare also wrote a form of fanfiction, but his was a little different. Back in his day, it was incredibly common for playwrights to pull from multiple sources to create their works, including common plotlines and the ideas/inventions of their coworkers and contemporaries. In Shakespeareâs case, historians believe those sources were people like his theatre company The Kingâs Men and the Ur-Hamlet, which has unfortunately been lost to time. He was able to produce works like this because it was the common practice, and because you made your money putting on the most entertaining plays, not by selling copies of your own intellectual property. Shakespeare may have written more collaboratively than most people believe, but he received the credit because he did most of the actual writing work anyhow (Jamison, 2013).
Did you know that Miguel Cervantes didnât write the first sequel to Don Quixote? That honor goes to Alonso Fernandez de Avellaneda (a pseudonym), who wrote and published his own sequel to the beloved novel in 1614. Itâs unclear as to whether or not this specific instance was the reason, but Cervantes was upset enough about some fan writers to mention it in the dedication to his official sequel (Jamison, 2013), which you can read about here.
Next up is the 1700s and 1800s! Not only did some prominent authors prompt fanfiction of their works due to what some saw as questionable literary choices, some even wrote their own fic. Samuel Richardson corresponded with several fans who were upset at his (at the time) potential writing choices in his book Clarissa, but he was not happy with those of whom wrote their own versions of his works. Middlemarch penner George Eliot wrote fanfiction as a child, similar to the Bronte siblings and Jane Austen. Some authors even published fic after they had become celebrated authors, as is the case with William Makepeace Thackeroy. After he wrote Vanity Fair, Thackeroy wrote his own version of Sir Walter Scottâs Ivanhoe in order to pair the bookâs hero with the character Rebecca romantically (Jamison, 2013).
At last, we come to the first formal fandom: Sherlock Holmes. The man of mystery himself has been captivating readers by the thousands since Sir Arthur Conan Doyle started publishing the shorter Holmes stories in The Strand in 1891. Doyle didnât always want this to be the case, however. After a good 5 or 6 years of writing Holmes and Watson (or as many fans believed, publishing the writings of Watson on his adventures with Holmes), Doyle was tired of coming up with new mysteries to be solved, and worried that he would only be remembered for the characters that he deemed his playthings, less serious than his other endeavors. In order to remedy this, Doyle sent Holmes off of Reichenbach Falls in 1893 and thought he had washed his hands of the whole thing. He was wrong.Â
People legitimately held funeral marches in the streets for Holmes, complete with black armbands. Newspapers reported on the death as well, as fans worldwide mourned the loss of the great detective. Doyle eventually resurrected Holmes a few years later after publishing a few prequel stories, but the damage had been done, and people began writing parodies and pastiches to fill the deerstalker-shaped hole in their hearts and minds.Â
Everyone from J.M. Barrie to A. A. Milne wrote a Sherlock pastiche, but some caused confusion as to whether or not they were lost official works of Doyle/Watson himself. One such work was written in 1911 by Arthur Whitaker and was sent to Doyle with a request to collaborate. Doyle told Whitaker that his story was pretty good, and that he should try to get it published after changing the character names, of course (Jamison 2013).
Prior to the 1960âs, the term fan fiction mainly referred to amateur science fiction written by sci-fi fans that was published in zines. However, it also referred to fiction written about science fiction fans by other fans, as is the case with the Fables of Irish Fandom, written by John Berry during the mid 1950s and â60s about his group of fandom friends in Belfast. This Belfast Group consisted of science fiction fans John Berry, Walter and Madeline Willis, Bob and Sadie Shaw, James White, and George Charters. Walter Willis and James White had created the fanzines Slant and Hyphen in response to the lack of letter columns (a major way fans communicated before the internet) in the British versions of science fiction magazines. Berry became a part of this group when his job as a police officer brought him to Belfast and he sent a letter to Willis after hearing about a science fiction fan group in the city. Berry was invited to meet Willis, then later the rest of the group. Berry chronicled fictionalized versions of his experiences, which became the Fables of Irish Fandom. All of the group members make appearances as played-up versions of themselves in sensationalized slice-of-life narratives that were published in Irish fanzines from 1954-1965 (Sawyer 2013). They were reprinted by Ken Cheslin during 1998-9, and you can read all of them here in PDF form!
Finally, we come to look at Wide Sargasso Sea, Jean Rhysâ 1966 novel that made waves in the literary world by recontextualizing the narrative of Bertha Mason, Rochesterâs mad wife in the attic from Charlotte BrontĂŤâs timeless classic Jane Eyre. In WSS, Berthaâs true name is Antoinette Cosway, and she is a white Creole woman born into a former slave-holding family post Emancipation. The book gives Antoinette/Bertha a life and personality beyond the âcrazy secret attic wifeâ persona she was given in Jane Eyre, and changes Rochester from the victim of Berthaâs madness to one of the main causes behind it. You can read a more in-depth analysis of the book here.
I hope you enjoyed this edition of Fic History, and please let me know if there's anything you think I missed!