Part one part two part three part five
Warnings: smut, groping, oral sex (fem receiving), p in v, creampie NEVER DO THIS!, switch Matt
Description: you go over to the triplets house to hangout with Nick but you and Matt sneak off and end up having fun together instead.
A/n: hope y'all like this part it's my personal favorite of the series so far. Sorry it took so long but it's way longer than the others so I hope that makes up for it also for my fluff lovers part 5 is gonna be pure fluff maybe a bit of angst but mostly fluff.
You and Matt have been friends with benefits for a few weeks pretty successfully. However both of your feelings for each other have been growing over the weeks though you're still oblivious to each other’s. Tonight you went over to the triplets house to hangout. Nick invited you over to watch some dumb movie Chris picked out and also just to hangout. Right now Nick and Matt are talking and Matt suddenly changes the subject trying to be subtle but quickly failing.
“So uh dude do you know if reader is like talking to anyone? Nick looks up mildly confused.
“Uh well there's this one guy she really likes but she won't tell me who it is.” Matt tenses at that.
“Oh… well do you have any idea who it could be?” Nick pops a bag of popcorn into the microwave setting the timer.
“No not really but she does talk about his eyes a lot apparently they're really blue and pretty. Matt walks away presumably to Chris's room.
Just then you get to their house and ring the doorbell. After a few seconds Nick opens it.
“Oh hey reader.” he says with a smile forming once he sees you.
“Hey Nick.” you say walking in with a smile that matches his. You follow Nick into the kitchen where he's popping popcorn in the microwave. You look around at him and smirk.
“Excited for movie night?” Nick rolls his eyes and takes the bag of popcorn out of the microwave pouring it into a bowl.
“I'm sure we're gonna be spending most of the night making fun of the movie.” He says carrying the bowl into the living room. Just then Chris walks in Matt following behind him they were clearly already discussing something.
“Dude I totally won that round.” Chris says, grabbing the remote.
“No you didn't, you literally lost.” Matt says, rolling his eyes.
“Yea but that guy totally cheated.” Chris yells now putting the movie on.
“Whatever dude.” Matt says clearly annoyed then he sits down right next to you on the couch. Nick sits on your other side and Chris sits next to Matt. The movie starts playing and it is indeed weird but you all keep watching because it's so dumb it's funny. But about halfway through the movie Matt pulls a blanket over the two of you, his hand finding your thigh under it. Your eyes widen at the movement but you keep them on the screen. His hand starts trailing up to your inner thigh and you turn to look at him.
“Matt, what are you doing?” you whisper with urgency. Matt stays silent though a smirk forms on his face and his grip on your thigh tightens.
“Matt, seriously your brothers are right there.” he smirks and turns to you.
“relax they won't notice.” you try to focus on the screen but it becomes increasingly difficult as his hand goes under your skirt fingers brushing against your underwear. You stand up a blush forming on your face.
“Uh guys I'm actually getting pretty tired I'm just gonna go to sleep.” You quickly walk off and sneak into Matt's room then Matt also turns to the boys.
“Actually I'm pretty tired too.” He gets up quickly and goes into his bedroom finding you on his bed in just underwear and a bra. His eyes widen and a tent forms in his pants almost immediately.
“Fuck bun, look at you all ready for me.” he walks over to the bed quickly pulling his shirt off and sits on the bed in front of you. You sit up and straddle him, hands resting on his shoulders. His hands trail up your thighs until they reach your ass which he grips firmly. You start grinding against him and he lets out a quiet groan, his hands moving to your back unclipping your bra. Your bra falls forward and you pull it off completely. Matt grips your breasts firmly and starts squeezing.
“Mm bun you really do have perfect tits.” His thumbs brush over his nipples and he leans in wrapping his lips around one. His tongue brushes against your nipples earning a moan from you and your hands move down to his pants unbuttoning them. He switches to your other boob and you pull away pulling his pants down with some struggle. He lifts up his hips to help you now in just boxer briefs. You start rubbing his bulge and he throws his head back letting out a loud groan and you throw your hand over his mouth trying to muffle it.
“Matt quiet.” he pins you to the bed and pulls off your underwear staring down at your wet core. He moves down your body and spreads your legs inches away from your dripping pussy so close that you can feel his breath. He wraps his arms around your thighs putting your legs over his shoulders.
“Fuck such a pretty pussy.” he licks you gently groaning at the taste then buried his face in you and starts eating you quickly and sloppily. His tongue circles your clit then plunges into your leaking hole. He thrusts his tongue in and out his nose brushing against your clit. Your thighs clench around his head and you put your hand on the back of his head gripping his hair and keeping him in place. He moans feeling you pull his hair and speeds up his arms now wrapping around your waist and after a few moments you cum your juices flooding out all over his face. Matt pulls back breathing heavily and you sit up pushing him against the bed much to his surprise. You pull off his underwear, his hardness springs out already leaking precum and you wrap your hand around it, pumping it a few times before lowering yourself onto it. He fills you attaching you out satisfyingly
“Fuck bun, you feel so fucking good.” you start moving up on him resting your hands on his chest for support as you ride him. You speed up riding him quickly using him to get off then suddenly he starts thrusting up matching your rhythm . The added force from Matt's moments create a delicious sensation between your thighs and you feel him start to twitch inside of you. A few moments later he moans loudly as he cums his release filling you which is quickly followed by you finishing all over his cock. You collapse on top of him, both of you breathing heavily against each other's necks. You roll off of him laying next to him on the bed.
“Wow bun I didn't know you had a dominant side.” He says teasingly, earning an eye roll from you.
“Yeah whatever.” You say shifting away from him.
“Hey don't leave me.” He says playfully and sits up grabbing some tissue from the nightstand as he starts to clean the two of you up. Once you're both clean he pulls you into his arms looking down at you, his eyes full of both love and restraint. And only moments later you fall asleep snuggling against him. He looks down at you stroking your hair.
“Fuck why can't I just tell you how I feel.” He pulls you closer and falls asleep a few minutes later still struggling with his feelings.