As a retired whore, I’ve been with many a fuckboy in my time.
Ilya? Not a fuckboy.
A fuckboy doesn’t care about treating you right or making you cum, or making it clear that it’s just a hookup, which is what Ilya does with the women he sleeps with. Neither him nor Shane treat their hookups with disrespect.
With Shane, his behaviour may be contradictory and confusing from Shane’s perspective, but it’s not coming from a place of disinterest or malice. We know that it’s coming from a place of fear- fear of discovery, fear of attachment, fear of love and what it would mean.
So yeah, in my personal subjective opinion, he’s not a fuckboy. He just enjoys sex, and that’s morally neutral.
That’s because he’s not a fuckboy, he’s a rake!
A romance novel rake is not a bad guy, he’s not a cad, he’s just a guy who loves fun and partying and FUCKING, and he’s very good at it. He takes pride in being good at sex, in pleasing his partners. Often in the beginning of the book he has many sexual partners and no interest in monogamy. And also often his love interest is a straitlaced virginal bluestocking (that’s Shane if you’re keeping track).
The rake will keep seeing his many partners and having (very good) sex with them until one day he finds, to his horror, that he doesn’t WANT to have sex with anybody else. He wants to change! He wants a committed relationship with one person! And when the rake falls in love (or admits to himself that he has fallen), he is ALL. FUCKING. IN. Maybe deep down he played this part because he thought some part of him was fundamentally unlovable, that nobody would want to commit to him anyway so he’ll just avoid that whole messy feelings bit but then BOOM here comes the doe-eyed sincerity of the ingenue with a steel chair!
Shane said “I don’t want to pretend I don’t like you anymore,” and suddenly Mr. Womanizer isn’t interested in sex with anybody else! Shane says “I am making a plan to keep you in my life,” and suddenly Mr. Cool and Composed is making teary eyed love confessions in TWO (2) languages!
God I fucking love it when a rake falls in love, it’s just so good.
















