After my last post talking about Muthr's book design, I was trying to remember where I had heard someone mention that her original design wouldn't work in the show. And I found it....in the official art book....
Well, might as well use this as an excuse for why Muthr's show design is a lot less effective for her story
As I mentioned in my post about Muthr's book design. Her looking uncanny is intentional. It's meant to give us the impression that Muthr is just a robot at the start of the book, which makes the eventual reveal that Muthr's love for Eva is genuine hit harder. Not only that, but as @dracocheesecake mentioned in the comments, Muthr's book design is meant to look haphazard because it was meant to be part of a quick solution that the first Cadmus had to make and produce quickly due to Earth dying. It's a design that helps the world-building and has so much personality
And that's why Muthr's design in the show fails. The most obvious problem with her design is that it looks too human. All her uncanny features are gone. Her detailed face and large canisters are replaced with just a simple 2D face and bun. Her exposed wires are completely gone. The curved lines on her neck and arms make it so she's wearing a dress. And she's just a green blob. Yes, she looks less uncanny now, but that uncanniness goes against the whole point of her original design and why it was so effective. She was uncanny, yes, but there was still a human charm to how she looked and was still able to show a ton of emotion whenever she's illustrated. Muthr's show design has none of the charm because apparently female characters all need to look soft and beautiful even if it goes against their story
The way they talk about Steve Jobs and mention Apple products as inspiration is what really caught my eye. I wouldn't be shocked if Apple themselves had some lean way in how Muthr and the technology in the show looked as a way to kinda promote their products. Just the way they talk about Muthr less like a character and more like a product gets under my skin
Also, the constant Lasseter glazing and reminders of "Hey, remember he used to work at Disney, aka your childhood! Just don't look up why he got fired in the first place!" Make me want to barf


















