lacy, oh lacy (part 4) (+ a bit)
A/N: we finally made it friends, we came to the end of this fic. thank you for all your kind words and for continuing to read every time the word count multiplied, I tried to give this an ending I felt fit. this has been so fun and I've enjoyed reading your comments and messages. extra fat forehead kiss with this one, much love xx.
summary: in which Logan must decide how to take a risk, and you have to decide how much more you're willing to sacrifice. you perform at the pop showcase and get some encouragement from an unexpected friend.
pairing: john logan x bestfriend!reader
wc: ~9.5k (my eyes are burning)
tw: angst, insecurity, confrontations, doubt, self-realizations, idiots-to-lovers, learning to communicate feelings, swearing, alcohol mention
disclaimer: I do not own any of these characters from off campus, nor do I own the song used in this fic. all credit to the brilliant artists, authors, and show writers.
Part One Part Two Part Three
Hey Y/N, can I talk to you before the showcase?-x Logan
Logan’s text had left a heavy feeling in your chest, unsure of what Logan could possibly want to talk about. Usually he was so superstitious with his traditions, you never really heard much from him until after the game ended.
Your game overlaps the showcase, talk after?-x Y/N
You always tried to make Logan’s games and he always came to your performances, but with the unlucky timing of today’s campus events you would both unfortunately be missing from each other. Part of you was sad that your best friend likely wouldn’t make it, but you were also partially relieved you wouldn’t have to explain the inspiration behind your song to him.
Sure, missing my good luck charm though :( -x Logan
He had texted you hours ago, and you hadn’t been able to feeble together a response. His message just sat in your phone’s inbox, mocking you as your heart involuntarily beat faster at his seemingly innocent text.
“Hey, Y/N, do you have a second?”
Hannah stood behind you, her hands repetitively creasing the corner of one of her notebook sheets, her smile didn’t reach her eyes. You slid your phone into your guitar coat pocket, turning your attention fully to her.
“Hannah, sure. What’s up?” You raised your eyebrows in concern.
“Nothing, it’s nothing. I just get nervous before things like this and you’re like my only friend here right now and Bethany is convinced she’s going to win and just listening to her I was getting more and more nervous so,” Hannah was rambling.
You reached up and grabbed the hand creasing her paper.
“First of all, you’re going to do great. You’re so talented, I can’t imagine you not doingwell. Second of all, never listen to Bethany, you know how she is,” you rolled your eyes at the thought of the girl who flitted around the department like she was above everyone in it.
“I think I’m also just, I don’t know if upset is the right word? I wanted Garrett to be here to night, but he broke up with me and things are sorta weird right now. I only last minute decided to do this,” Hannah said.
“Mmm,” you nodded, remembering that Hannah had last minute re-entered after she had dropped out initially.
“And like it’s dumb to want him here, right? Like we broke up and he wouldn’t have been able to make it anyway most likely because he’s probably at the game, even while he’s suspended,” she kept going.
“I don’t think it’s dumb,” you interrupted.
“No?” Hannah’s eyes met yours.
“No, I don’t,” you laughed before continuing, “I don’t think it’s dumb that you want him here. You love him so it’s only natural you would want him here, and I can’t speak to what’s happening between you two right now but I’ve seen the way Garrett looks at you. He loves you, Hannah. And for what it’s worth, I have a lot of hope that you guys will work it out.”
Hannah paused for a moment, your words ringing in her mind before she pulled you in for a hug, startling you.
“Thanks, Y/N. I know we aren’t super close but I hope maybe we could be,” Hannah said as she pulled away.
“I’d love that,” you smiled genuinely.
“But enough about me, how about you? How are things with Logan?” Hannah asked.
“Oh, Logan and I are just friends. I wish he could be here but he has the game. And with Garrett out for four games he’s been super wrapped up in practice since I saw him last,” you looked down at your feet, not wanting to have this particular conversation with Hannah.
“I’m sure he wishes he could be here too, Y/N.”
“Yeah, it’s okay though,” your shoulders dropped, slightly more defeated than you’d allow yourself to admit.
“Is it?” Hannah raised an eyebrow.
“We all kinda thought you guys would’ve gotten together by now,” Hannah said so casually you would’ve thought she was talking about the weather.
You freeze, feeling like you did in the hallway with Allie and at the party with Dean, feeling like everyone had caught on to how you felt about your best friend.
“Who’s ‘we’?” You asked carefully.
“Well, me and Garrett talked about it, and he talked to Dean who had talked to Tucker and they all said the same thing. Oh! And my friend, Allie, the one who also works at Malone’s? She was just saying the other day how cute you two are when you come in together. You two always sit in the back booth and just talk for hours, it’s like you never get tired of each other,” she listed off.
“We’re just friends, Logan doesn’t have feelings or anything like that for me,” you reaffirmed.
“It’s just…I don’t wanna overstep or anything but like you see the way he looks at you right?”
“You are not the first person to say that this week, I don’t get it. Like Logan and I are just friends, that’s all we’ll ever be,” your tone fell off at the last part, dejection settling in your chest.
“Is that all you want to be, though?”
You physically couldn’t answer Hannah, your eyes downcast to the floor as you wrung your fingers together.
“Hannah, I know for a fact Logan likes someone else, I see the way his eyes light up when he sees her. It’s never going to be me and I’ve accepted that,” you barely managed to get out.
Hannah let the silence stretch between you, realizing how much this has taken a toll on you.
“I don’t know who this other person is, but it’s a damn shame if he doesn’t see you, Y/N.”
You laughed lightly at the irony.
“I’m serious, Y/N. You are one of a kind, you deserve someone who sees just how amazing you are. If not Logan, then someone else who will fight for you,” Hannah was so sweet in her reassurance, you felt like maybe you could believe her.
“Ladies, we start in 15 minutes. Warm up if you need,” your professor interrupted your conversation, the nerves and reality setting back in for the both of you.
“Let’s do this,” Hannah began anxiously folding her paper corner again.
You could only offer her a small smile and nod.
You set up your equipment, placing the foot pedal for your loop recorder close to the stool as you connected your laptop to the speaker. Your hands were shaking. Hannah just gave an amazing performance and being directly after her did very little to calm your nerves. The bar was set, and Hannah set it high. You weren’t sure you could place in the top three let alone be the best performance tonight. You needed this scholarship but doubt settled into the pit of your stomach and made you worry in nervous anticipation.
You looked stage left to the side stage and found Hannah watching you, giving you a thumbs up in support as she smiled and encouraged you from where she stood.
For the longest time you had wanted to believe that you and Hannah could never go beyond the friend-from-class title you stood behind. But now you were more hopeful than ever that you two could be real friends, close friends even. She had shown up for you and comforted you tonight, she picked up the pieces to something she never even fully understood she was in the background of. She never judged you or looked at you like you were dumb or wasting her time.
Time and time again, Hannah had sung your praises and made you feel like someone worth knowing, like someone worth loving. She knew you loved Logan, and she believed that he loved you too. You wished endlessly for her to be right.
Hannah was your friend. She had your back and she believed you could do this.
Every emotion you had felt over the last couple weeks circled your mind endlessly, anxiety gnawing at your conscious as you took a deep breath and picked up your guitar and your pick. You found a seat on the stool that had been set up for you, and closed your eyes to center yourself amidst the never-ending self-criticisms that picked you apart and made you feel like you had always needed to be more.
This song was the manifestation of every thought and feeling you had been desperate to ignore or push down, every physical symptom and pang you swallowed, it was everything to you because it was the things you so often left unsaid despite the way it devoured your soul and eviscerated your heart. Maybe you could never tell Logan how you felt without having what remained of your heart crushed, but this was yours. This was your truth to own and to bear despite whoever was looking. No one could take that away from you.
~Lacy, oh, Lacy, skin like puff pastry
Aren't you the sweetest thing on this side of hell?~
You started singing, voice ringing clearly as your fingers moved across the frets of your guitar with practiced ease. Your eyes fluttered shut as you strummed along, foot tapping on the looper pedal to add different harmonies in the background of your playing.
~Dear angel Lacy, eyes white as daisies
Did I ever tell you that I'm not doing well?~
You try and focus on your singing, your conversation with Hannah fading into the back of your mind as all the emotions you poured into this song resurfaced and twisted in your mind.
~Ooh, I care, I care, I care
Like perfume that you wear
Watchin', hidden in plain sight~
You had hidden in every corner, watched from right by his side and as everyone around you had seemed to catch on. It felt like a train-wreck you couldn’t turn away from as you longed for him to turn to you just once. Your desire had been a weapon against your own heart as you had convinced yourself you cared too much to ever let it affect your friendship with Logan.
~Ooh, I try, I try, I try
But it takes over my life~
You had tried for so long to bury it all, bury the fact that you were in love with your best friend. And what did that get you? The price of your silence and for what? To be miserably in love either way? Doomed to watch your best friend choose someone else every time? You repeatedly told yourself Logan didn’t owe you anything, but damn that didn’t stop you hoping.
The sweetest torture one could bear~
Memories of sitting in a booth at Malone’s, watching Logan watch Hannah. Karaoke night. Beau and Dean’s party. Hockey games. The house. Every place that Hannah had been at and unconsciously causing Logan to catalog her every action as though he was afraid to miss something. Every time you had watched him fall more in love with her and further away from you.
I feel your compliments like bullets on skin~
And despite it all, Hannah had never once said a bad word about you. Even on the days you could hardly talk to her in class because it hurt too much. She had seen the best in you and wanted to become closer friends. Every compliment shattered your desired perception, every praise was salt in the wound. Whether it was for the fear of being mocked or or the reality of being seen, you were never really sure.
~Well, aren't you the greatest thing to ever exist?~
You remembered every time you watched Logan watching her, you remembered every time his eyes followed her across every room. You had never blamed him, knowing that Hannah was radiantly beautiful and lit up every space she entered with her bubbly personality. She captured the attention of every one in every room, and that included Logan.
~You got the one thing that I want~
She didn’t even know it, but Hannah held the heart of the man you had been endlessly pining over to no end. She had been at the center of your pain and longing without ever knowing and had even offered you advice and support like the sweet person she was. She had Logan in the palm of her hand and you could only watch with a longing ache in your side.
~Ooh, I try, I try, I try
But it's like you're made of angel dust~
You had done everything to explain away your feelings, to rationalize the pain make it seem like something you just needed to get over.
You remembered every time you thought she was prettier, smarter, kinder, or floated on air. You rationalized that it was only natural for Logan to choose her over you and in doing so you were also choosing her over yourself every single time. You took all the pain that you put yourself through just to try and rationalize it all and you turned into lyrics, pouring your heart into the microphone as you sang with so much conviction that you didn’t notice how the audience hooked onto your every word.
~Lacy, oh, Lacy, it's like you're out to get me
You poison every little thing that I do~
And backstage, when Hannah had comforted you and supported you, you had come to realize that it had been unfair to put her on this pedestal. You had made her into this untouchable being that dictated your self worth and all she wanted was to be your friend. You had known it all along, but it was never her fault that Logan had feelings for her. She was simply in the crosshairs of something she never knew she was a part of.
~Lacy, oh, Lacy, I just loathe you lately~
You had never been able to bring yourself to hate Hannah. She was simply existing, trying to find her own beat and write her own story. Every time you wanted to hate her, you could never come up with an actual reason. It was just an easy place to put the blame for your unrequited feelings. And really there was no one to blame, just as Hannah had simply existed, you simply fell in love with your best friend.
~And I despise my jealous eyes and how hard they fell for you
Yeah, I despise my rotten mind and how much it worships you~
You sang the final line of your song, strumming the last chord as you felt the string vibrate against your finger. Silence filled your ears afterwards.
Well that’s not promising, you thought.
You brought your eyes up from where they had fixated on the edge of the stage, surprise washing over you as you met the gaze of the very man you didn’t think was coming.
“John?” You whispered almost silently under your breath.
John Logan had just heard your song. Your song about him and your unrequited love.
Before you knew it he was jumping to his feet and clapping as he hollered your name.
“Yeahhhh! Let’s go, Y/N!”
Suddenly, applause broke out, Logan having lead the way as the audience jumped to their feet and giving you a standing ovation. The hockey boys were screaming your name, clearly ecstatic about your performance. You could see Allie and some of Hannah’s other friends, Jules and Beau were also there and cheering for you. Your friends from Music Comp were to the side, and out of the periphery of your eye you could see Hannah bouncing and clapping in the side stage.
Over all the noise, you heard someone calling your name the loudest.
It was Logan. He had his hands clamped around his mouth, cheering you on. You could feel your heart soar as you two made eye contact, pride radiating off of him as you heard him call out,
You felt like the floor could open up and swallow you whole and that would be the probably be for the best.
Everyone had finished performing their pieces and the judges had left to deliberate. They had returned and were seated at the table, having passed a folder with the results to the the emcee of the event, one of your professors from within the Music Comp department.
You and Hannah stood side by side back stage, hands tightly gripping each other’s as nerves wracked both your bodies. They had already announced third and fourth place winners, and all that remained was first place and runner’s up.
Those two spots also had the most desired prizes.
First was a hefty scholarship, and second was a paid internship that would also pay a decent chunk of Briar’s unsightly tuition.
Several people remained, praying and hoping for their names to be called. You were beginning to feel a bit defeated. Several of these people, many of whom were your friends, had performed phenomenal songs. Everyone had taken this challenge to heart and put it all out there on the line.
No one was leaving here tonight saying that they hadn’t given it their all. A few people had come up to you directly after your performance and spoke so highly of you that you felt relieved at least that you could say your song wasn’t terrible. People had seemed to like it, and that standing ovation was something that would stick to you. Your mind drifted to Logan, who had led the standing ovation and practically screamed your name until you left the stage.
He had called you his girl again.
The memory of him proclaiming it so loudly in front of everyone made your heart race and your mind dizzy. You figured you might have some things to explain about your song tonight, but for the first time in a long time you felt like maybe there was hope after all. Maybe it was delusion, but for tonight you’d let yourself have it.
“And first runner-up is…”
You and Hannah squeezed each other’s hands, feeling like there was no air left in the room. Anxiety had shattered you both, and from where you peeked around the curtain you could see all of your collective friend group holding hands for dear life.
You let go of Hannah’s hand, jumping up and cheering for her as she walked onstage to accept her award. You could hear the cheers erupting from your friends as they shot out of their seats, screaming out of their minds for Hannah as she beamed and shook your professor’s hand. You could barely make out the way Garrett looked the most alive you had ever seen him, like he was absolutely vibrating with joy for her. You hoped that was good omen that things were going to be back on track for them soon.
With Hannah on stage, that left you alone in the side stage, your hand reaching up to scratch your neck as you accepted defeat. There were so many talented performers this year, and if Hannah only got second you could only imagine that left you somewhere in the lower ranks.
You would be able to make it work, without the scholarship. It would just be hard and you might have to pick up a part time job somewhere around campus to help out. You had put your heart out there on that stage, and you could genuinely say you were proud of yourself for leaving it all out there. You were so caught up in your reverie you barely registered as they announced first place.
“And in first place is…Y/N L/N!”
You stared at your professor, your mind was slammed into a tailspin as he gestured for you to come join him onstage. Several of your friends cheered you on from the side stage where you stood, someone giving you a gentle push to go accept your prize as your eyes instantly found Logan’s in the crowd.
Your friends were going crazy, Dean was bouncing up and down so hard you thought he might actually take off into outer space. Beau and Jules were trying to start a chant with your name, Tucker and Garrett clapping and cheering as your mind reeled in bewilderment. You joined Hannah on stage, giving her a brief hug and ignoring her whispered “I told you so,” as you shakily accepted the certificate and shook your professor’s hand.
Logan still held your gaze, his eyes betraying his emotions, his hair slightly messy from having run his hands through it so much while desperately praying for your name to be announced. He was grinning from ear to ear, his breath caught in his throat as he held your gaze.
You watched his lips move as he called out to you,
For once, you didn’t feel second to Hannah.
You had spotted him when you exited the building, he had been staring at the exit waiting for you to presumably talk about his text from earlier. He had also been biting his nails, so he was nervous it seemed.
“Hey there, superstar,” Logan called, his smile widening as he noticed you approaching.
He shifted his position so that he had his hands in his pockets, leaning against his truck with an effortless, casual stance. His eyes were tracing your figure as you stopped in front of him.
“Logan, you came,” you said quietly, still in disbelief that he made it despite having a game.
“I wouldn’t have missed this for the world.”
There it was, the butterflies fluttering in your stomach despite themselves. You didn’t think this feeling was ever going to go away, you were fairly certain you could spend the rest of your life pining over this sweet man and you’d feel no relief. You could only give him a tight-lipped smile before fixating your gaze on your hands.
“You were so unbelievably amazing. I felt so starstruck watching you perform out there. Your song was…I think the best I’ve ever heard you perform. I know I’ve said it before but you really put it all out there every time you perform. You were so otherworldly, it felt like I was witnessing something once in this life time,” Logan continued to sing your praises, in doing so causing a warmth to crawl up your neck and across your face.
You met Logan’s eyes, nervous about what he thought about the contents of your song.
“I’m glad you liked the song, I put a lot of work into it.”
“Trust me, Y/N. Everyone in that room could tell. You were unbelievable, we were all mesmerized as we watched you perform. I’m so lucky to call you my best friend,” Logan reached a hand towards yours, pulling you a step closer and playing with your fingers.
“I couldn’t help but notice, your song was a little sad, though.”
You could tell Logan wasn’t going to let this go.
You couldn’t think of anything to say.
“We don’t have to talk about it, but I just wanted to ask, who is your song about?”
You sighed, Logan was straight to the point, as usual. You told yourself you were going to own it, that in bearing your heart you weren’t going to let it hurt you anymore. Now it was time to do just that, despite the way the idea filled you with dread.
“It’s about something I’d been feeling for awhile, watching someone I—uh, felt a certain way about feel that way about someone else, and all the feelings associated with that,” you stammered, hoping Logan dropped the subject.
Logan studied you, his eyes flickering with a whirlpool of emotions as he seemingly stared straight through your soul. You felt as though he could see right through you and the walls you had been steadily putting up. It was unraveling you.
“Right, well—um,” Logan fumbled his words.
Logan was always so certain of himself, hiding his real emotions behind his solid exterior so you were struggling to understand why he seemed so uneasy before you now.
It felt dangerously close to vulnerability.
“There was something, Y/N, I wanted to talk to you about before,” Logan reached a hand up to scratch his neck, pulling at the collar of his jacket before meeting your eyes.
“Yes…your text,” you said nervously, anxiously awaiting what Logan was so urgently waiting to tell you.
“Garrett! Put me down!” You heard drift across the street, you redirected your attention from Logan to find Hannah being picked up into Garrett’s arms.
Laughter carried across the wind, melodically ringing in your ears. You watched as Garrett held Hannah, spinning her around and kissing her deeply.
Looks like they’re finally back together, you thought.
You were elated for her, you had become extremely fond of the sweet girl and you hoped she got everything she wanted, she deserved it. This seemed like a pretty great start to that.
Logan noticed your gaze fixed on the happily reunited couple, turning to watch them for a moment before turning back to you.
“Looks like Garrett got his girl back. Took him long enough,” Logan echoed your thoughts.
“Hmm, hope you aren’t too upset you lost your chance to swoop in and sweep her off her feet,” you murmured, still watching the two lovebirds across the way.
“Yeah, Hannah wasn’t the one I was hoping to sweep off her feet tonight,” you snapped your neck to look at Logan, brows furrowed in confusion.
“Don’t tell me you’ve got a new girl already,” you could feel your heart sinking.
“No! N-no it’s someone I’ve actually wanted for a long time, I’ve just never had the guts to say anything until now,” Logan hurriedly tried to correct what he was saying.
“Wanted for how long? And why is this the first time I’m hearing about it?” A twinge of hurt flaring in your chest.
“Since freshman year. And because I was scared.”
John Logan scared? That didn’t sound right. It would almost be laughable if not for the tension riddling this man and threatening to boil over as his shoulders straightened and his eyes grew darker.
“Oh. This is like love love?” You said quietly.
Logan sounded definitive in saying that. Like he was absolutely sure that this mystery person was the one that he wanted in every single way. This was going to be what seismically shifted your world and sent if all crashing down around you, you were sure of it.
“So then who’s this long time crush you’re gonna sweep off their feet?” You choked out, feeling like Logan was taking all the air with him when he was undoubtedly about to let you down slowly.
A strained quiet descended, Logan searching for the right words to say.
“That was you…actually,” Logan sighed as he awkwardly scratched the back of his head.
There was no way, absolutely no way.
You had just spent so long watching Logan watch Hannah, just to say he wanted to sweep you off your feet? You had to have been hallucinating, that’s not what he actually said, right? Maybe this was all a dream, maybe none of it was real. That had to be it. There was no way.
“But,” you started, your voice quivering as you tried to understand everything.
“I thought you were in love with Hannah?”
“I’m not,” Logan said immediately like it wasn’t a question in his mind.
“You’re not?” You sounded confused, you couldn’t make sense of the situation.
“I thought I liked her. I was doing everything I could think of to push down everything I felt towards you. I tried to convince myself that if I ignored it, then it would go away. But it didn’t. If anything it just got worse as time went on and the more I tried to fight it. I wanted to believe I could like Hannah the way I liked you because there was less to lose. If you didn’t feel the same, I thought I might lose you out of my life for good. And I didn’t want that, Y/N.”
“Your song tonight, gave me a lot of perspective on how much of an idiot I’ve been. If I’m right, and god I hope I’m right, I think you might feel the same. If you don’t then I understand if you want to walk away from me right now and never talk to me again, and I’ll respect that.”
“I don’t ever want you to feel like you’re hard to love. And I’m sorry if I’ve ever been the guy to make you feel that you were, Y/N.”
“John,” you whispered, a single tear streaming down your cheek.
Your emotions were a mess, every thing you had felt the past several weeks bubbling up under your skin. Your heart and mind were engaged in a battle, dueling each other in such powerful intensity as you tried to rationalize everything Logan said to you now and everything that had happened lately.
“No, Y/N. I meant what I said. You are not hard to love. God, it’s so easy. It’s the most natural thing I’ve ever done. I can’t imagine a day waking up and my heart not already beating for you. You crawled right under my skin and found a home within me. I’m only sorry it took me so long to realize that’s what this was for me,” Logan grabbed your hand, his eyes pleading with yours.
“There was a part of me that was beyond terrified that I would lose you if I said anything. But I can’t do that anymore. If I say nothing, I could lose you to someone else. So, I’d rather stand here and tell you that I am an ass, you’ve told me that more times than I can count and you’re not wrong. You’ve been by my side for so long and have seen me at my worst so many times, yet somehow you only talk about the best of me,” Logan paused, searching for any hint of what you may be feeling.
“But then I think that’s because you bring out the best in me. You make me want to be a better person, genuinely. You make me want to be better for you. I spent so long thinking I always had to be at my best for you to want me the way I’ve wanted you, and I can’t say I still don’t feel that way. But I saw Tucker’s hand on yours for two seconds and I almost put him through the boards, Y/N. I don’t want a better man for you. I want to be better, for you,” Logan heaved, out of breath for talking so long.
You were at a loss for words. It felt like too much, too fast almost. But that’s how it began with John Logan, it may as well have continued that way.
Your mind caught up with your heart, your breathing trying to even out as you processed everything. Your mind was still reeling.
“So you don’t like Hannah?” You questioned.
“No, no I don’t. It was only ever truly, you,” Logan
“There’s a lot of things I haven’t felt like I’ve been able to say,” you started.
“No, Logan. You don’t. Let me finish,” you placed a hand on Logan’s chest, keeping him a bit of a distance from you.
Logan swallowed but nodded, a dejected look on his face.
“I spent so long, watching you like Hannah. It destroyed me. The worst part was I couldn’t blame you, I looked at her and saw a million ways I didn’t compare. I convinced myself it was natural for you to choose her because this was all I would ever be.”
“Everyday, it felt like someone was ripping my heart out of my chest and tossing it around like a hockey puck, Logan. It absolutely tore me apart, I couldn’t breathe when I was around you but I couldn’t stand to be away from you. That night at karaoke? You looked so lovestruck I thought I could die right there and you wouldn’t notice.”
“I can never do that to myself again, I refuse to. I will never be second place, the second choice, or just the conveniently placed best friend. If I give you this chance right now, this is it. There won’t be another and if I ever am made to feel that way again, I will walk away. I will not let my self worth be absolutely warped like that again. Ever.”
Logan’s eyes widened, he took a tentative step towards you.
“I know it won’t be easy. I know there’s things I can’t fix overnight, but I am willing to try. If you’ll let me, I want to fight for you, for us. I want you, Y/N. That’s it. You are it for me,” Logan openly pleaded with you now.
Logan ignited sparks along every nerve, traveling down your spine and lighting fires all the way down. You felt so utterly alive and effervescent.
“Did I…what?” Logan was incredulous at your question.
“Did. You. Mean. It?” You grabbed his hands, challenging his unwavering gaze as you stared right back with equal intensity.
“I told you, Y/N. I meant everything I said.”
You deliberated for a second, searching his face for any sign that he was lying to you or pranking you or for anything even the slightest bit off to give you enough reason to refute his declaration.
You found nothing but adoration and something you couldn’t quite place.
John Logan felt the same way about you. The words didn’t even make sense to you. But as you stared up into Logan’s gentle doe-eyes, desperately searching your own for any inclination of how you felt, you did the only thing that felt right in that moment.
You reached up and grabbed Logan by the shirt, pulling him into you as you kissed him.
Logan was surprised, completely caught off guard by your brazen act. The feeling of your lips on his, pressing into him like he was the only thing tethering you to this reality ignited the fire inside him, pooling in his stomach as he suddenly remembered to kiss you back. He was savoring the feeling and taste of your sweet kiss, never wanting this moment to end.
You pulled away after the all too quick kiss, your chest heaving and breath rattling as you stared nervously into his eyes. Logan was also breathless, his pupils blown as they flicked to your mouth and back to your eyes again. The both of you were speechless, waiting for the other to make a move.
Silence stretched between you two. Logan’s hand reached up to cup your face, his thumb gently running over your bottom lip.
“Please,” you barely whispered as heat settled over your face.
“Please what?” Logan rasped out, his breath shaky as his hand gently stroked your cheek.
Logan grinned, unwilling to deny you. He pulled you back to him, never once releasing you from where he held you. His lips found yours again, eyes fluttering shut as euphoric delight crashed over you in waves. The hand caressing your face slid to the back of your head, pulling slightly on your hair in a way that left you gasping, Logan seizing the opportunity to gently slide his tongue into your mouth. His other hand came up to rest on your back, pulling you impossibly closer against his own body.
Now that he had you, Logan was never letting you go.
Prior to walking into Malone’s together, you and Logan ended up having a whole conversation in his truck about how to handle this now that you two were trying things beyond being just friends, and how to explain that to the friend group.
“So like…do we just say fuck it and tell them? The guys will go crazy,” Logan asked.
“Well, if we just keep things under wraps it gives us a bit to breathe and make it just ours,” you were still getting used to the idea that Logan returned your feelings, let alone you were kind of together now.
“Yeah, problem is I kinda had a whole discussion with the guys about how I was going to tell you,” Logan winced.
“Dean knows,” Logan confirmed.
“Guess we’re hard launching it then,” you sighed.
“We can wait until someone brings it up, maybe they’ll be normal about it,” Logan was blissfully ignorant.
“You’re hoping Dean Di Laurentis is going to be normal about this? He’s been watching us for months,” you pointed out.
“Dear god,” you groaned, throwing your head in your hands.
“He’s not letting us get away with anything.”
“Nope,” Logan simply said.
You contemplated your choices for a minute.
“Well, let’s just roll with it, I guess,” you said, shrugging off the possibilities.
Because really, what was there to lose? Your pride because Dean was about to be a smug asshole about it and tell you both that he was right? You could live with that if it meant Logan suffered along with you under Dean’s relentless teasing.
Logan nodded and tapped his hands on the steering wheel.
“We could just go back to your apartment or the house, it could be just us for tonight and deal with the rest tomorrow,” Logan offered.
A soft giggle escaped you, Logan brightening at the sound.
“I promised Hannah I’d come out tonight. We don’t have to stay long but I feel like you owe me a margarita,” you beamed at him.
“Guess it’s decided then,” Logan didn’t even protest the margarita.
He hopped out the driver’s side of his truck, winding around the front to pull your door open before you got the chance to protest and holding a hand up to you.
“Ready?” He asked, his eyes watching your face for any initial sign of discomfort.
You grasped Logan’s hand in yours, swinging your legs down and onto the ground before meeting his gaze.
Upon walking into Malone’s, hand in hand with Logan, you could hear cheers immediately across the bar, all of your collective friends having beat the two of you there.
“Called it! You owe me 20 bucks, Tuck!”
“There’s the Pop Showcase Champ!”
“Ayoooo atta’ boy Logan!”
“Well, well, well. What do we have here?” Dean approached you two, a mischievous, shit-eating look on his face as he noticed your intertwined hands.
“Hi Dean,” you said as evenly as possible.
“First let me offer you my congratulations, dear Y/N for your splendid performance and well-won prize,” Dean rambled off.
“Thank you, Dean. Go ahead, get this next part over with,” you laughed, already shaking your head.
“Oh, I will thank you dear, sweet Y/N,” Dean turned to Logan.
“And now my boy, John Logan, may I finally at long last offer my congratulations to you on finally pulling your head out of your ass long enough to see this magnificent specimen that had been right in front of you for some time,” Dean clapped a hand on Logan’s shoulder.
“Thanks man,” Logan sighed, resigned to let Dean have his moment.
“Why don’t you let these two make their rounds,” Allie came up next to Dean and put her hand on his shoulder, coaxing him away from a lecture about how he was right the entire time and sparing the entire bar from hearing about it.
“Fine, fine. I’ll just leave it at this, I have been rooting for this for a long time. Y/N deserves the best and I’m happy you finally got the girl, Logan. Cheers,” Dean raised his glass before chasing after Allie to a table, something you noted to ask about later.
You and Logan turned and looked at each other, each laughing as you made eye contact.
You turned to see Hannah waving you over to a booth where she sat next to Garrett, his eyes full of adoration as he watched her.
Still holding Logan’s hand, you pulled him with you over to where the two sat, sliding in on the opposite side of the booth. Logan sat as close to you as he could get, his leg brushing against yours as he wrapped his arm around your shoulders.
“Y/N! You were so amazing out there, you absolutely killed it!” Hannah gushed.
“You did really great, Y/N,” Garrett nodded.
“You’re so kind, I thought for sure you were going to win, Hannah,” you grabbed her hand from across the table.
“Second place is just fine with me, it comes with a great internship opportunity,” Hannah gripped your hand back, no sign of bitterness or bad blood anywhere in her face.
“A paid internship at that,” Allie had abandoned Dean and Beau and was standing behind your booth.
“And as long as it was between you two and not Bethany, I’m satisfied,” Allie smiled.
The group laughed, Logan’s body rumbling gently against yours where your bodies touched. Warmth crawled up your neck, the cool vinyl of the booth a pleasant contrast. When you looked up at him, he was already looking at you. Your breath hitched as his eyes traced over your face.
“Ugh, get a room you two,” Garrett threw a straw at Logan.
“As if you two weren’t in each others throats when we got here,” Logan retorted.
Hannah blushed, Garrett wrapping an arm around her tightly, keeping her attached to his side.
“Can you blame me?” Garrett asked nonchalantly, looking at Hannah.
Logan turned his attention back to you.
It was your turn to blush, you felt it up into the tips of your ears.
“Y’know what Logan, you still owe me that margarita,” you got out of the booth, pulling Logan with you as Garrett and Hannah laughed at you. Allie slid into where you two had been sitting, switching topics with Hannah to talk about some new guy she went on a date with.
You glanced at Dean, noticing the way he watched Allie from across the room. For a brief moment, his eyes flashed to yours. You gave him a small, sympathetic smile and nod. You weren’t sure you fully understood what was happening between Dean and Allie, you were fully sure you probably didn’t want to know the depth of what they were up to, but you could empathize with Dean. You knew exactly what he was feeling at this moment, having lived something similar yourself. Dean broke his gaze first, turning to go find Beau and maybe distract himself.
By the time you reached the bar and Logan had ordered for you, Jules had joined you both.
“‘Bout time there, John. I wasn’t sure you had it in you,” Jules poked at Logan’s side.
“Thanks, Jules,” Logan passed you a margarita, taking the wrapper off the straw for you.
“Does this mean next karaoke night I can put you both down for some Sandy-Danny action?” Jules wagged their eyebrows at you.
“Sure, but I’m taking Sandy,” Logan joked.
You laughed, pure elation coursing through your veins. So much had happened today, and a lot had changed. There was still a lot to be worked out and you were sure doubt would still creep in from time to time. But you were hopeful. And as Logan had reminded you of your own advice, you were trying to focus on the things you could fix right now.
Jules left you two alone, Logan leaned on the bar and watched you sip your victory margarita. His stance was softer, more comfortable. He seemed relaxed and like he was truly enjoying everything in his life right now. The tension that so often sat between his shoulders was looser, a bright smile and on his face as though he was completely enamored.
Your heart skipped a beat.
Knowing you were watching, Logan cleared his throat.
“You did great today, and while you were up there I couldn’t help but notice how beautiful you looked as well,” Logan said nervously, a gentle pink tinging his cheeks.
His fingers moved to play with the hem of your dress, you had chosen a black, lacy dress that held you together with a corset back. It was reminiscent of your dynamic duo outfit, something that Logan had picked up on.
“It reminds me of this swan I met at a party once,” Logan started.
“She was so stunning and after she left I remember I spent the rest of the night kicking myself for being such an ass and leaving her at that party, I didn’t have any fun once she was gone,” Logan’s eyes flicked up to yours.
“That’s a damn shame, I’m sure she spent the rest of her night wishing you had stayed by her side, too,” you teased back mercilessly.
Logan’s eyes raked over your body, his eyes flashing as he breathed your scent in.
“Logan! You called him?!” Dean was pissed and pointing at some guy you didn’t recognize.
“Shit,” Logan swore quietly.
“Logan who is that?” You felt like you were watching something big unfold.
Next thing you knew, Dean and this guy were throwing punches at each other and Logan was up and trying to help the guys break them apart. Dean had the guy against the bar, you had quickly moved out of the way and spared a glance towards an unusually disarrayed Allie.
This was going to get messy.
The rest of the night had been a lot of separating the boys and calming Dean down and thanking people for their praise on your performance. By the time you and Logan had made it back to the hockey house, you were exhausted.
You had trudged up the first flight of stairs to Logan’s room, your feet dragging behind you until Logan came up behind you and swung you into his strong arms.
“Logan! What are you doing?” You all but shrieked, not worried about waking anyone up because you had beaten the others home.
“I said I was going to sweep you off your feet, didn’t I?” Logan smirked, carrying you the rest of the way up and into his room.
“You’re ridiculous,” you chuckled, resting your head against his chest as he carried you across before setting you on the bed.
“Take off your makeup and shower, I’ll grab a towel and shirt for you,” Logan instructed.
For once, you weren’t in a mood to argue with him and stood up to head towards the bathroom.
You paused next to where Logan stood, reaching up and pressing a gentle kiss against his cheek.
Logan swore he could have melted into a puddle right there, watching as you retreated behind the bathroom door and turned on the water.
While you were preoccupied, Logan set the towel and shirt on the bathroom sink, careful to still give you your privacy. He returned to his room and was putting away miscellaneous hockey gear and text books while he waited for you to finish.
He had straightened his bed and run downstairs to refill your water bottle you had forgotten during one of your movie nights. By the time he got back upstairs, he noticed the water in the shower had turned off and he could hear you lightly humming.
Smiling to himself, he set your water bottle on his night stand and changed out of his clothes and into some sweatpants and a loose t-shirt.
Just as he had pulled the t-shirt on, he felt your arms wrap firmly around his waist, as if you were afraid to let go. He softened, his heart skipping in rhythm and singing your name. Turning around in your arms so you faced him, he looked down at you pressed against him in his t-shirt. He never wanted to let go.
“You ready for bed?” He asked softly, noticing how sleepy you had gotten.
His chest rumbled as he laughed, picking you up gently and moving the couple of yards over until he landed on his bed. He laid you down gently first, climbing in beside you like he’d always done, his arm wrapping around your front and pulling the covers up until you were completely cozy and cocooned. You burrowed into his chest, his heart swelling as he watched your breathing begin to even out as sleep overtook you.
“What if when I wake up this was all a dream?”
Logan hesitated, pulling you tighter into his chest.
“Then I’ll remind that this is real. You’re it for me, Y/N. I’ll remind you as many times as you need.”
You smiled before fully drifting off into sleep, your soft, gentle snores filling the air. Logan tucked a loose piece of damp hair behind your ear, just enjoying this moment where you were totally his.
In that moment Logan knew for sure.
He was just as much yours as you were his.
It had been a few weeks since the showcase and finals had come and gone. The hockey season was still ongoing, but most of the guys had traveled home for a few days to get some time in with their families while they had a brief break. That left you and Logan alone in the hockey house for the last few days. It had been some of the best days you swore you ever lived. You had been spending time with Logan, reflecting on how everything had changed in the last few weeks.
You and Logan had said a lot to each other after the pop showcase and you had spent a large part of that night talking about the things that you both had been holding back, the insecurities created, and the doubts that you would still have to work through over time as your relationship bloomed into something like best friends, but better.
John Logan wasn’t just your best friend anymore, he was also your boyfriend.
And you were John Logan’s girlfriend.
If you sat and thought about it too long, you would start to form this absolutely dopey look on your face, smile so wide that your cheeks would start to burn. This time around though, you knew with certainty the same could be said for the man laying next you.
You laid chest to Logan, his hands making busy work of gently combing through your hair and rubbing circles into your shoulder. This was the most content you had been in a long time.
God it would take time getting used to that.
You took a beat of silence.
“I love you,” your voice was barely above a whisper.
Logan shifted in bed beside you, turning on his side so he was facing you. A shit-eating grin was forming on his face.
“Sorry, baby but I don’t think I heard you. What was that? Say again.”
Warmth flushed down you cheeks and chest, your hands coming up to cover your face as embarrassment washed over your features.
“Sorry baby, but I really need you to say it again,” Logan teased as his hands started skimming up and down the side of your arm and down to your legs.
“You’re such an ass, John Logan!” you exclaimed, smacking him lightly in the chest.
Wasting no time, Logan hitched his hands under your knees and slid between them as he moved you so you were lying flat against his bed.
He didn’t let you to finish that statement, his hands falling on either side of your head as he caged you in. He gave you no chance to escape him or his steady gaze as his eyes locked into yours, something unfamiliar swirling around in the brown irises you frequently got lost in.
“Y/N, I need to hear you say it. Say. It. Again.” Logan rasped out, his pupils dilating the longer he stared down at you.
You were breathless as you stared right back up at the man you could finally call your own, losing focus briefly and flicking to his soft lips before back to the eyes that once haunted your dreams.
“I love you, John,” you said firmly this time, watching as his smile spread to his eyes and dimples began to form.
Logan laughed lightly, shaking his head as if he hoped he never got used to hearing you say it, he hoped he felt butterflies and sparks and the fire you had lit in him for the rest of his life. He was fairly certain he would get his way.
“That’s good because I love everything about you, Y/N. I love that you’re so stubborn and always think you’re right.”
He placed a gentle kiss on your forehead.
“Because I am always right,” you retorted.
“Shhh,” Logan kissed your right temple, not tolerating your interruption.
“I love how you are the smartest, most creative person I’ve ever met.”
Logan moved to kiss your other temple, leaning in closer to your left ear.
“I love how you are the only person I know to cause a microwave fire from popcorn.”
You laughed freely as Logan pressed a soft kiss against your hairline.
“I love that you always search for the best in people, even when they don’t deserve it. Even when I don’t deserve it.”
Logan kissed the bridge of your nose, your heart squeezing.
“I love every part of your body and how devastatingly beautiful you are.”
Logan’s eyes ravenously traced your form before his warm breath fanned over your neck, kissing the pulse point in your neck.
You bit your lip, Logan noticing right away.
“I love how you choose to always drive me crazy.”
Warmth ignited fires through your nerves as Logan kissed right above your collar bone.
“I love those breathless little sounds you make every time I kiss you.”
He leaned down to kiss the corner of your mouth, moving his lips to your right ear.
“And most importantly, I love how easy it is to love you. I’d sooner forget how to breathe than ever forget how it feels to love you.
Your breath hitched in your throat, the edges of your vision blurring with unshed, happy and content tears. Logan leaned down to kiss you fully, his lips meeting yours in an passionate battle as your flesh melded into one. You let out a breathless sound while Logan’s kiss consumed you, the feeling of his lips against yours leaving you feeling like every fiber of your being had electricity pulsing through. It felt like white-hot flares were bubbling up under your skin, making you impossibly warm and deliriously happy. Each spot he had kissed you before felt like a million tiny fireworks were dancing across the surface, the feeling tattooed into your skin by this man.
Logan pulled away, his hand moving to cup your face as he earnestly looks you in the eyes, absolutely sick with adoration.
“And there’s a million more reasons why I love you, and I plan on telling you a new one every single day until you’re absolutely sick of me,” Logan finished.
You could barely handle all the love you felt, you felt as if your heart was overflowing with something you once never thought would be yours. There would be moments where you still hesitated to believe this was all yours, and there would be moments Logan would be terrified he’d scare you off for good. You would both handle those moments as they came, if they came. Laying there in Logan’s arms, you felt as though the two of you could handle whatever life threw at you next.
You reached a hand up, brushing a curl out of Logan’s face as you stared into his doe-like brown eyes, reveling in the way they softened as he leaned his face into your palm.
“Well, I don’t think I will ever get tired of that, John,” you said sweetly.
Logan only grinned as he pulled you in for another kiss.
Yeah, you could get used to that.
You were incredibly, 100% without a doubt, obvious to everyone else, in love with your best friend John Logan.
And your best friend, John Logan, was 100% without a doubt, obvious to everyone else, in love with you.
A/N: and so it's come to an end :'(
I've enjoyed writing this so much and I hope you all enjoyed it too. I'll probably take a break bc this was way above what I ever imagined, but I wanna start working on my next fic soon, anyone down for a lil Logan x maneater!reader maybe?? also I tried to leave the song in this as ambiguous as I could while still referencing the song that inspired the fic so I hope that comes across okay? like it's not my song so I felt a bit weird writing it as my character's song so I wanted to go about it more like these are the lyrics as they apply to the story and what the character is feeling as they sing, not just the song that is necessarily being sung also that way if you had a different song in mind you can live your artistic liberty dream. idk ik its not that deep but what can you do. either way thank you for all the love, this story is now yours <3 thanks for being along for the ride :) xx
taglist: @nihoshi17@taivantaylor@solstice-333@littlepippilongstocking@anyasthoughts@sisterslytherinog@dina2223@cherryangel-coke@yvesjgk@sela-gypsy@leithold@abcdefghijklmopqrstuvwxyzz@jigsaw11111@itmekelpy@coldheartedmar@k-alen@fandom-princess-forevermore@itsheathermarieposts@savedbystyle@abominablesnowman24@yegrnn@sagittarianwolf@hteusefam@gandalfthegoatsblog@dinafox2006@dumplingsyum@irisjustlikeheaven@makinbananapancakes@bruce9818@skyesthebomb@wilmonyibo7@powellssaturn @huang-the-greek @tacocoburittoto @wh1stlet0e @girlbossforever@il0vereadingstuff@saltyfriendsaladbandit@idgasb@jordan-connor@loony-brain@superbfishhumanoidweasel @hadesnumber1daughter @devildoll769 @wintermoonly @undercoverbatwoman @chervbs @outpostsworld @pola-rosa @nisarelle @honeylesshaze @ilovesharry @woderfulkawaii @ky-laa
@starktcc @ajw1231 @budgetcupid @run-for-the-hills