idk people even hated on moffat to begin with, the moffat episodes were always the best ones imo
Ok but I’m honestly surprised you didn’t know that, as I haven’t able to get on a single DW topic without hearing about how horrible Moffat is. And I’ve been in the fandom for years.
And yes, his episodes are some of the best, without a doubt. However, stuff like this doesn’t really matter to people who think you’re the worst writer in the world. Literally. Every single insult you can think of for a writer, I’ve seen it implied to Moffat.
And no, I don’t know how it all started. If I had to guess though, I would probably say it was caused by a clickbait article listing “problematic” things Moffat said: most of which were either taken out of context, and later debunked. Even five years later I still occasionally catch that article circling around tumblr, and…well, you know how tumblr is. They’ll do anything to make themselves seem #woke.
The only good thing to come out of it? Moffat heard their criticisms, and listened to them. Because it’s true, some of the things he did were wrong, but he acknowledged that and learned to be a better person, which you can see reflecting in his writing on DW over the seasons.
Unfortunately, for all they’re “People can grow and change!!” speeches, tumblr rarely acts on what they preach.












