kind of really annoyed by the bara Simon/twink Grace tropes that are going along the Bloodymary tag, when that's really not what their characters are alike at all. like I know a lot of it was rooted from people who only watched one movie n not both but guyss!!!! That's not it at all!!!!! (character study)
First off, Grace is just as buff as Simon. They're both muscle men. Grace starts out literally calling himself "forever muscles" when trying to regain his memory. A point can be made if they meet up during the scurvy era but if they're meeting after Grace has been on Erid (with higher gravity) for a nonzero amount of time AND fed a proper supply of meburgers, he should be relatively swole once more. I could even argue that the most afflicted Simon would be weaker than post-movie Grace. So jot that down.
Second, I saw one fic where Simon shows up at the beginning, acts like a bodyguard, shuts down Grace at every turn and then just does all the scary stuff Grace does originally, cause he's overprotective and "more capable." And to this I say: FuUuUuCk that.
Simon is not a big brave stone cold mean man man, just like how Grace is not a smol silly innocent little lovey boy. And something I think a lot of people aren't getting (or don't know how to conceptualize) is that Simon is not braver than Grace. I could argue Grace is more brave. Or at least that their bravery is completely different from each other.
Sure, these two movies are very similar. a random guy is stuck on a ship in the middle of an uninhabitable infinity, and must deal with the consequences of that while they fight to change anything about the world. But they are completely different situations. Simon is raw bravery, and Grace is prepared bravery.
Grace wakes up with amnesia, but still completely educated and with resources. Simon goes down aware, quick learning, but not with an ability to understand the whys. Grace has the technological world at his fingertips. Simon is told nothing until it's too late. Grace is never given a chance to beg for his life once he wakes up with nothing. Simon is a surgery without anesthesia, begging for every chance to end up okay with the slimmest hope of being heard. Grace gets a little alien friend to help him at every turn. Simon's little alien friend's idea of helping is taking him out back to be shot with ascension.
Most notably, Grace has minutes, weeks, years. He has so much time to be productive, to learn, to grow, to prepare himself for his bravery. Simon has seconds. Maybe minutes, if the blood is being particularly nice.
This can also be turned on its head, of course. Grace is brave because he does it anyway. If he wanted, he didn't have to be brave. He could've not stuck out his head, not taken his head off, not met the alien, not risk literally everything for the taumoeba. He had years to be a coward, and he could've. He would've regretted it, and hated himself, but he could've not been brave.
But Simon never got that luxury. It was fight or die. Ram at full speed and risk the ship, or die. Barter with every scrap or die. Scream and sob and irradiate yourself and feel the hivemind ocean curdle your skin and fight. or. die. And in that way, it's hard to say whether it was adrenaline or bravery that made him survive as long as he did, or whether the two options are just different sides of the same coin.
Again, I'm not saying that either of these men are, like, better than the other. What I'm saying is that Simon loses his temper because he is terrified out of his mind, but he also cries just as much as Grace does in the span of a few hours/days. He is a trembling chihuahua in a dog fighting ring. Grace is terrified, but he is allowed joy, acceptance, companionship and choice, even when so much of his situation was chosen for him. If the situations were swapped, I'm not sure if Grace would survive even half as long. I'm not sure if Simon would be brave enough to save the world.
(edit: as a commenter [larix-laricina] also put it, Grace has someone to fight for. He has a reason to be brave, his kids and then Rocky. Simon has a plant at the very most. he fights because there is nothing left to fight for. So in the chance they swap places without having their memories changed, Simon would probably just live and die cozy in his spaceship, considering it blood retirement. Rocky would have to fight for every step if they even met)
All this to say: If anyone's the twink (or twink stereotype), that's SIMON π€. GRACE IS THE BARA π€π€π€. If Simon is teleported onto Erid he should get to be pampered like a princess in the comforting arms of Ryan Gosling just like Markiplier saidddd!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GUyss come onnnn!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And if I'm wrong may lightning smite me dowNNAUGHHHHH (<-was just smoted)