Is Bhaal pro or anti abortion? I feel like this could go either way. It’s possible he’d be for killing a foetus on principle, but also, that could mean less Bhaalspawn and tbh foetuses aren’t people yet, so does killing the potential for a person really count?
Perhaps he’s anti-abortion because he doesn’t believe life begins at conception and instead demands his followers be killers of actual, fully-born babies. None of this weak ass ejecting a clump of blood and cells bullshit. (Then every period would be an act of worship which would be pretty metal but maybe too easy, and again, he likes making bhaalspawn.) You’d think he could be into that, because it sounds gross and can be traumatic, but maybe not at the expense of a real proper murder, you know?
Sooo I guess I think Bhaal is for spontaneous miscarriages and against abortion. Maximising pain and suffering for all, amen!
OK SO!
If we go by pre-death Bhaal lore, he’s not gonna be interested in killing children, whether born or not, because he wants his followers to do IMPRESSIVE murders, being the most pleased when they kill someone more powerful than themselves. So no, he’s not into killing babies or children because that’s not hard at all.
On the OTHER HAND
Guess who does really like having children sacrificed on his altars?
BANE
Wow thank you for bringing me the actual D&D lore!! Who knew Bane would be pro choice for all the wrong reasons… I really shouldn’t be surprised 😭
an expansion on what @hydrasorelse said:
bane likes child sacrifice because everyone else hates it. do not go to a banite priest for an abortion, consent kills the whole vibe for him.
all of the dead three are fundamentally about power. their differences are in what they see as the ultimate exercise of it. in the original drawing of lots where the three musketeers split jergal’s godhood, bhaal’s argument for his superiority was that sure, bane had dominion over the living and myrkul the dead, but he controlled which camp a mortal would fall into. by killing, he took from bane; by not killing, he deprived myrkul.
all killing of any living thing—even animals—is an exercise of power over life and death, and therefore pleasing to bhaal. but the more difficult a victim is to kill, the more power is exercised, yeah?
there's also a difference between murder as an act of worship, and a situation where you were going to be committing some murder anyway so you shoot off a prayer to the relevant god.
one (1) source says a victim MUST be more formidable than the killer. everything else says bhaal just prefers it, and choice of victim is a matter of pragmatism: working as an assassin/mercenary/bounty hunter to support yourself, or furthering bhaal's influence either through one's temple or one's own advancement. but how anybody feels about the murder, including perpetrator and victim, doesn't matter in itself to bhaal.
a helpful tool is jurisdiction. what falls under bhaal's purview and what's more relevant to a different god? fair and honourable combat is a different guy. impulsive, indiscriminate killing is a different guy. vigilantism and vengeance is a couple different guys. suffering is shar's thing.
my take is that bhaal is cold-blooded murder with a selfish ulterior motive. if you kill because you get paid for it, that's bhaal's gig. if you kill to steal someone's stuff, hurry along an inheritance, remove a rival for a promotion, that's bhaal's gig. if you kill because you enjoy it as a skill and an artform, that's bhaal's gig. and then there's killing directly for bhaal and his interests, of course.
so when it comes to children: not ideal due to lack of challenge, but still murder. sidestepping the question of to what degree an embryo/foetus counts as an individual lifeform, i think it's fair to say that, in any case, they're so defenceless that it's simply not interesting. a bhaalist priest is not going to waste a spell slot on an abortion. (my suggestion would be selûne, goddess of pregnancy.)
when it comes to bhaalspawn: it was part of durge's religious duty to reproduce; sarevok believed seven-year-old orin would be a pleasing sacrifice. bhaal is neutral on everyone else reproducing, but he wants there to be more bhaalspawn specifically so they can kill each other. he'd probably prefer more even match-ups, like orin vs durge, but infanticide is fine. i think the best bet for a durge that doesn't want to be a parent is malicious compliance: (a) kill anyone potentially pregnant by them before conception has a chance to occur, (b) kill the baby as soon as it's born.
disclaimer: this is only my interpretation of the lore i've researched, and there's a good dose of interpretation in here because you have to actively make the different bits and pieces fit together. off the top of my head, the most important ones are the sourcebooks faiths & avatars and elminster's forgotten realms, plus the article on deathstalkers in dragon magazine #322.





















