Guys! So I realised something and I cannot deal!
So in 1899 Jack Kelly was 17? Right? So he must have been born in 1882.
And 1882 + 11 = 1893
Ya know who else was 11 in 1893?
Winnie Foster.
Jack Kelly and Winnie Foster are canonically the same age and I. Cannot. Deal.
This just supports the theory I saw somewhere that Crutchie is just Jessie in disguise
Yes! Hello! That was my theory! (Or at least that’s part of my theory, I’m not sure if it’s the exact one you saw). It connects Tuck Everlasting, Newsies, Dear Evan Hansen, and Pitch Perfect.
And I wrote it before I saw Crutchie’s trading card, so in the theory it’s not cannon that he had Polio.
https://benjihansen.tumblr.com/post/161175768755/the-timeline-of-a-theory


















