Luci could punch me and I’d thank him

It had been a week.

A whole week since Levi had barely even glanced at you.

You didn’t understand what had happened- one day you were both playing games together, and the next he just stopped talking to you, acting as if you weren’t even there.

Eventually you’d had enough- you had tried to get into his room since it was where he spent most of the time- but even after you said the password he wouldn’t let you in.

You let out a dejected sigh, but decided to not give up. He was still your best friend, right?

One day you managed to find him before he went inside his room. Even after you called out his name he wouldn’t turn around and face you, so you decided to corner him in.

“W-what the hell! What do you think you’re doing?!” He yelled, face flushed.

You placed your hands beside his head so he had no way to escape, even though he was taller than you it seemed to work. You glared at him.

“I’m trying to figure out what I did for you to ignore me this past few weeks! You’re acting like I don’t exist or something!”

Levi’s face suddenly shifted to a guilty expression, but he shook his head and looked at the ground.

“I- I have no idea what you’re talking about! Agh, just let me go already!”

“Not until you explain your behavior! It’s not fair Levi!”

“What do I have to explain?! I just don’t want to be with normies like you- I-I was only doing it before because Lucifer forced me! Besides, you’ve been getting real chummy with Simeon and everyone at Purgatory Hall, so why don’t you go and bother them huh?”

Your arms fell to your side as you kept your eyes on Levi.

“What is that supposed to mean?” You said, placing a hand on your hip.

Levi sighed and looked at the ceiling, crossing his arms.

“It means, I don’t want to hang out with you anymore! I don’t want to see you, or hear you, or feel you beside me! It’s so tiring having to be with you all the time, what’s so hard to understand? I hate it! I absolutely hate it- so j-just leave me alone already ok?” He yelled.

You felt as if you had just been slapped.

He was…tired of you?

Levi took a glance at you and flinched as a small sob came from your mouth. His eyes widened as he realized- maybe he had taken it too far.

Tears were falling from your eyes, and he moved his hand as if to wipe them away, but you took a step back, glaring at him.

“Message received.” You said in an icy tone that made Levi feel chills run down his spine.

“M-MC I-”

He didn’t have time to finish before you turned around and walked away, wiping your tears.

Leviathan felt a wave of shame wash over him. He wanted to go after you but- what would he say?

He had truly screwed things up, and now, he didn’t even stand a chance to tell you how he truly felt.

.

.

.

Levi had spent two whole weeks holed up in his room. He didn’t even go out to eat and only opened the door to grab the plate one of his brother’s had left for him.

That was until one night while Leviathan was wallowing in self loathing and shame, his door was banged open and Mammon came in, an angry look on his face.

“W-wha? MY DOOR!” Levi let out a loud scream as Mammon walked in as if he owned the place.

The older demon pointed at his brother, an angry look on his face.

“The hell did you do to MC to have them all mopey huh? They’ve been holed up in their room all day- talkin to no one!”

Levi crossed his arms and looked at the wall. “T-that has nothing to do with me!”

“THE HELL IT DOESN’T!” Mammon yelled, scaring the poor demon.

“I heard them sayin’ they were going to talk to ya a few weeks ago, and after that they’ve just been cryin’ and staying in bed, so clearly you said somethin’ to make ‘em upset, so spit it out!”

Levi looked at his brother, who was now glaring daggers at him, and sighed, eventually giving in.

“I…I told them I didn’t want to hang out with them anymore…”

“What the hell you do that for idiot?!” Mammon screamed, and Levi put both his hands up in self defense.

“I-I just- I didn’t understand-”

“Understand what?!”

“Why they were even spending time with me! L-look, I really like them ok? But they- they’re so amazing and I don’t…I don’t deserve them. A few days ago I saw them talking to Simeon and it made me think that I could never be as good as him…they’re better off with someone else than a worthless otaku like me…they deserve someone that makes them happy and can give them everything they wish for and I…I’m not that. I’m not worthy of their love. ”

Silence filled the room.

Then Mammon punched Levi in the face.

“Agh! W-what was that for?!” He asked, rubbing his cheek.

Mammon let out a tch, glaring at his brother.

“Listen up! I know MC better than any of ya- so believe me when I tell you that they care about ya! Levi, MC doesn’t want you to be like anyone else- they want you to be you! You should see the way they always talk about ya- Levi this, Levi that, it’s annoyin’! How do you think it feels huh? It’s true that you’re a weird otaku that never comes out of his room- and that you’ll probably never do anything with yourself-”

“Wow.”

“But! MC still loves ya. Can’t really figure out why- but they really do. It sickens me to say it- but you’re a good person Levi, great even. You’re kind to the people you care about, and you’ve got a big heart. And MC was able to see all of that- that’s why they feel in love with ya.”

Levi slowly looked up at his brother.

“They…love…me…?” He asked.

Mammon scoffed. “Of course they do ya dumbass! I can’t believe you didn’t see it sooner. Who is it that they spend all their time holed up in a room with, huh? Who is it that they spend hours and hours talkin’ bout who knows what game? Who is it that they go to first whenever they want to share some big news, or are feelin’ down?”

“M…me..?” He asked, pointing at himself.

Mammon nodded.

“Yes. You. And if you don’t man up and go and tell ‘em that you’re sorry and how you really feel- then you’d truly be unworthy of their love!”

Levi looked at his older brother, eyes wide. Then he stood up and hugged him.

“W-what are ya doin’?!” Mammon yelled.

Levi hugged him tighter. “Thank you Mammon.”

The older demon rolled his eyes before hugging his brother back, a small smile on his face. When they pulled back he placed an arm on their shoulder, patting him encouragingly.

“No problem. You can repay me by cancelling every debt I owe ya.”

“Ugh…fine. N-now how do I tell them..how do I say what I just told you…?” Levi asked.

Mammon smirked. “Ah, you don’t have to. They’ve been outside your room this whole time, listenin’ in.”

Levi gasped as you suddenly walked into the room, your face flushed.

Mammon gently pushed his brother forward.

“I’ll be seein you two later. Don’t come out until all’s sorted.”

And with that, Mammon tried to place the broken door back where it was- to give you some privacy, and left you and Levi alone in his room.

The two of you said nothing, shyly glancing up at each other once in a while.

Eventually you decided to speak up.

“Uhm Levi I-”

“I’m sorry-”

You both said at the same time.

The two of you looked at the other and let out a small laugh, that eventually became louder and louder until you couldn’t anymore.

“Great minds think alike huh.” You joked.

Levi smiled and glanced at the ground, biting his lip.

“So y-you heard everything huh?” He said.

You nodded. “Yeah. Sorry for eavesdropping I just…I was really hurt you know? By what you said- and I didn’t…understand any of it. Mammon saw how upset I was and, well, came up with this idea.”

Levi chuckled. “That was rather…nice of him.”

You nodded. “Yeah. He really acted like an older brother back then huh?”

“Yeah. As much as I hate to admit it, he was right. I would truly be worthless if I didn’t explain myself to you and told you how I f-felt.” He blushed. “I..I actually like you MC. A lot. You’re the only one that isn’t put off by my ramblings, or that doesn’t mind how useless I am…I like you a lot m-maybe even more than TSL.”

You gasped. “And Ruri-Chan?!”

“There are limits MC.”

You chuckled. “Of course, of course.”

Slowly, you walked up towards Levi, and grabbed his hand. He blushed and looked at you, confusion lining his features.

“Levi…I like you too. Really. And I want you to know that, from what you said earlier…you..Leviathan you are worthy of my love. All of it. I love you, for being you. I don’t think you’re disgusting, or useless or worthless. You’re anything but that. You’re an incredible person, a good friend, a good brother- the way you care so much for the people you love is always so sweet. You give everything to the people closest to you, and I love you so much for it. I love you.”

You caressed his cheek, wiping a few tears away, and gently kissed his lips.

Levi stared at you, his eyes as wide as plates and his whole face red. He blinked a few times and placed a hand on his lips.

“D-do you really mean it?” He asked softly.

You nodded, leaning your forehead against his.

“I love you, Leviathan.”

Levi felt as if his heart was about to beat out of his chest.

Was this a dream? It couldn’t be right? No- but he was sure he could feel you in his arms right now- this was real!

A smile slowly began to appear on his lips.

“I l-love you to MC.” He stuttered, face even redder. “I always have- since we made a pact I…I love spending time with you and playing games with you. It’s always been you. And I’m so sorry I hurt you before- I was just so afraid you wouldn’t feel the same and acted selfishly. I promise I’ll never do it again. ”

You smiled and the two of you shared a chaste kiss, your arms wrapped around his neck.

“Have you two finally resolved it already?!” A voice called out from outside.

Levi let out a small gasp, face flushing.

“M-M-Mammon?! What are you doing here- I thought you left?!”

“I needed to make sure you didn’t run out the room or somethin” he said.

Levi visibility deflated. “Y- you didn’t think I would confess?! After everything you said?”

“Eh for all I know you would just make a break of it as soon as I left. I didn’t think you’d actually go through with it to be honest.”

Levi glared at the doorway. “Mammon!!!!” He screamed, and immediately opened the door to chase after his brother.

You laughed as you walked and leaned on the doorway, watching the demons run around the hallway.

Nothing could happen that would ruin your joyous mood- you were sure this was the happiest you had ever been ever since you got that special card from a game you and Levi liked to play all the time.

You placed a hand on your lips.

I really love you, Leviathan.

And the thing that made everything better?

The angel felt tears form in his eyes. He couldn't anymore. He just couldn't.

But….he couldn't stop it.

Or maybe he didn't want to stop it.

True, his hands were tied and he had a blindfold on, but there wasn't anything wrapped around his mouth that wouldn't allow him to speak. He could say the safe word any time.

He let out another moan as he felt you insert something -probably one of the toys you had shown him earlier- and bit his lips, flustered that a sound like that would even come out from his mouth.

How did he manage to get into this mess??

.

.

.

.

A few hours earlier the two of you had walked into your room, holding hands and smiling at one another.

Simeon sat down on your bed as you quickly went and took a shower, tired from all the shenanigans that had happened throughout the day. Although it was truly nothing different from usual, the amount of chaos those brothers caused couldn’t surprise you anymore. At least, sometimes.

He sat on your bed, and suddenly heard you call out from the bath.

“Simeon, could you please grab my hairbrush for me? I’m almost done!”

Whenever either of you finished taking a bath you would brush each other's hair, chatting happily about what you'd done throughout the day.

Simeon absolutely loved it, having you in front of him, running his fingers through your hair and feeling you so close...

He quickly looked on the bedside table to get the brush, but it seemed like it wasn't there.

He opened the top cabinet.

Not there.

Then he opened the middle one.

Not there either.

He wasn't even going to try the third one since it was usually locked, but as he closed the second one he somehow managed to open it, just a crack, and he felt curious about what was inside.

Just a little peek wouldn't hurt right?

Simeon checked to see if you were still in the bathroom and opened it.

The angel knew you wouldn't get mad at him, and he'd tell you if you asked him about it.

Or if the guilt got to him, whichever one came first.

He opened the drawer, and took a look inside.

He took out what seemed to be...cuffs? And placed them on the bed, his eyebrows knitted in confusion.

Then he took out some red ropes that felt soft to the touch, and cocked his head to the side.

He had no idea what these things meant.

Then, he found something he did recognize.

He immediately turned red as he realized that what he had grabbed, was in fact, a dildo. He had never seen one before and didn't know how to feel.

Slowly, some of the items in the drawer began to make sense, and Simeon blushed even more.

The two of you had made out a few times, some of them getting a bit steamy, but you would always stop before it went any further.

But maybe now...maybe you wanted to take it to the next step?

He grabbed what seemed to be a weird shaped rock, or plastic toy or whatever, and was about to inspect it closer when-

"Hey Simeon did you fi-" you immediatly stopped dead in your tracks as you saw what Simeon had in his hands.

He let the object drop to the floor immediatly in surprise.

"Oh! Uh...uh MC! I was- I didn't mean to-I mean- th-the brush!!" He stuttered, his face red as a tomato as he went down on his knees to pick up the small object.

You felt your face flush and quickly bent down to help Simeon too, making your hands touch. Simeon let out a gasp at the touch and blushed even further, unable to look at you in the eyes.

You sighed.

"Uhm...yeah I guess I forgot to lock it after last night...." You shyly mumbled.

"L-last night?" He asked, and you slowly nodded.

A frown appeared on Simeon's face. "You used it to....to pleasure yourself?" He asked, shyly, and you nodded.

"It's just...well sometimes I need to relax a bit or let out some steam and well....y'know....the usual...." You admitted.

"But...am I....” he bit his lip. “Are you doing this because I can't give you enough?" He asked.

Your head immediatly shut up and you moved closer, squishing his cheeks.

"No, no Simeon, you are doing amazing. It's just...sometimes I just… get the urge to....well, do it. It's normal. And...well, since we haven't talked about that yet or even gotten as far as taking off our clothes- I just wanted to wait until you were comfortable."

Simeon glanced down at you with surprise, and then a small smile appeared on his face. He gently ran a finger through one of your locks of hair, and then began trailing it down your cheeks.

"You are so amazing...did you know that? Doing this...holding back because you wanted to wait for me. I can't explain how happy his makes me..." He smiled and you couldn't help but smile back, nuzzling his nose against yours.

"Well I didn't want to rush it, and waiting for the other person to be ready as well is what you should do."

Simeon nodded. Then, he looked at the ground and bit his lip, deep in thought.

"Simeon...?" You asked, and he grabbed your hands and gently pulled you up, grabbing your hips and pulling you close to him.

"S-Simeon?!" You gasped in surprise, and he looked at you with a sheer look of determination.

"MC....I’m ready now. I want to do it."

"B-but you don't have to if you don't want to-"

"I do want to! I want to please you, to show you how much I care. I can't believe how bad I was, making you endure it all in your own....but now you can lean on me. I can help you."

He walked over and pushed you gently on the bed, pinning you down in a chaste kiss. You immediatly felt like your heart was going to burst, and your body felt hot, so hot.

The kiss slowly became rougher, and Simeon moaned against your lips.

Then he pulled away, panting, and looked at your nightstand beside the bed. He reached down to grab one of the toys, and nodded towards you.

"I know I'm new to this, so you might have to guide me a bit on how to do it, but I'm a fast learner, I'll get the hang of it in no time." He pulled up the object that had fallen earlier and nodded confidently.

"Right, where does this go..? Do you want me to put it somewhere specific or...-" he trailed off as you got up and smirked, taking the object on his hand.

"This." You pointed at the object. "Is called a butt plug. It's just like it sounds."

Simeon blushed at your forwardness but nodded reaching for the butt plug, looking a bit frightened but confident. "Alright, I'll try my best to put it on you, although I might need some-"

You interrupted him by letting out a laugh, and then covered your mouth.

"S-sorry Simeon, it's just- hahaha! You're so adorable."

"Is it supposed to be used differently...?"

You shook your head and before he could ask something else, pulled him by the hand to the bed, and then got on top of him, a smirk on your face. You showed the butt plugg to a very flustered Simeon and leaned closer, caressing his cheek.

"You see love....this is supposed to go in you."

.

.

.

Simeon gulped as he thought about the compromising position he was in. His hands where tied against the bedpost, and he had something blocking his vision. He'd never imagined he'd be laying in bed like this...or doing this with you.

He gasped as he suddenly felt you grab his length, already hard from the excitement, and gently rubbed it.

"Mmmmm!" Simeon moaned. You smirked at the reaction and gently, began pumping him, slowly. Simeon gasped and thrust his hips forward unintentionally. You chuckled.

"My my~ What a naughty boy, moving like that without any permission...but I'm glad to see you're enjoying this. Look, you're even about to cum! And we haven't even started yet~"

"Mmmmph, it's just- ah- it feels so good..." He gasped, and let out a small squeal as he reached his climax quickly, making your hand dirty with his cum.

"S...sorry it...came out all of a sudden..." He said, and you couldn’t help but smile. Even in this situation he kept thinking about your well-being and it was just adorable

"My sweet Simeon, it's alright-Now we don't need to get the lube, and can get to the butt plugg even sooner."

Simeon gulped, feeling his body get hot at the mention of the object. A part of him felt nervous, but another part felt…excited and aroused at the thought.

You softly caressed his cheek. “Are you sure about this?” You asked, wanting to check if the angel was ok with the action.

Simeon nodded, and you kissed his lips before moving down and gently inserting your fingers into his hole- making Simeon gasp at the sudden touch.

Using his juices as lube, you helped Simeon prepare for the toy, and slowly inserted it.

“Ah…!” Simeon arched his back, biting his lips to try and muffle his groans.

“Is that ok?” You asked, and the angel nodded, a few whimpers slipping from his mouth.

Eventually the whole object went in, and you let Simeon catch his breath.

You got on top of him and kissed his mouth, and then whispered in his ear, “I’m going to turn it on now, alright?”

“W-wait, turn it o-mmphh!!” Simeon moaned against your lips. He could think of nothing but you and your touch and kiss, and how hot it felt down there. His mind became foggy and the only thing that would come out of his mouth were whimpers and whispers of your name as he felt himself slowly reaching his peak.

Then you turned it off.

“Wha…what…?” Simeon said, his voice hoarse and with a hint of disappointment.

You chuckled.

“Well, after coming last time without any permission, I’d say you should undergo through some kind of punishment, don’t you think?”

“B-but”

“Ah-ah” you placed a finger on his lips, silencing him. “I don’t think I gave you any permission to speak.”

Simeon immediately shut his lips.

“Good boy~” you cooed, stroking his hair.

“I also deserve to feel good too you know? How selfish, wanting to come all by yourself.” You pouted, sitting up and straddling him.

The two of you moaned as you slowly inserted his length inside of you. But you still didn’t move.

Simeon whined. He needed you to move so badly- his mind was filled with nothing but the thought of you- of how good you felt, he wanted more, he wanted you to both reach your climax at the same time, to hear you as he came inside of you.

“Simeon~” you said. “Do you want me to move?”

“Y-yes! Yes please!”

You smirked tracing his lips with your finger. “Hmm, do you want to come?”

“I do!”

“Beg for it.” You ordered.

Simeon’s eyes widened from beneath the blindfold.

“I’m not moving if you don’t ask for it properly my love~” you said, and to taunt him more you thrust your hips forward, making him moan in response.

Simeon gasped. “I…I- I really, really want t-to cum- please, please let me cum!”

“A bit more~”

“MC, I really want t-to feel you- please, please move, I can’t- I can’t take it anymore, it’s s-so hot, I really, really really want to cum, please MC, please!”

“Since you asked so nicely~”

Simeon groaned as soon as you began moving your hips up and down.

“M-MC I…I want to see you…please…” he whined.

You gently took the blindfold off, revealing Simeon’s beautiful blue eyes, tears forming in the corners.

“Kiss…kiss me, please…” he begged.

You nodded, and crashed your lips against his, your tongues roughly clashing against each other.

“Mhmm…MC, I-I’m so close…” he whimpered between each kiss, and you nodded, holding him tight.

“I’m close too…ah!”

The two of you cried out in pleasure as you quickly reached your climax.

You both panted, and slowly smiled at each other.

“Was that good?” Simeon asked.

You nodded happily and kissed his nose. “It was amazing.”

He smiled, a small blush tinting his cheeks. “I liked it too.” Then he motioned with his head towards the ropes. “So, heh, are you, uhm…going to untie me now?”

You chuckled and got off him, leaving him in a confused daze.

“…MC?”

You grabbed something from the cabinet and licked your lips, smirking at the angel.

“But Simeon- we aren’t done yet~”

The angels eyes widened as you tied the blindfolds on him again, and before Simeon could say anything else- turned the vibrator on.

.

.

.

You both didn’t know how much time had passed- the only thing on your minds the pleasure you both felt against each other.

At one point the ropes around Simeon had loosened- leaving red marks on his skin. His blindfold had come off too, hanging off to the side and showing a bit of his teary eyes.

You laid down next to him and gently held him, making him lay his head on your chest. You stroked his hair and sighed.

“S-sorry…I might’ve gotten too carried away…” you said, biting your lip. “I just- I got excited and- well it was- I just…yeah…”

Simeon let out a small laugh and looked up at you, his eyes filled with adoration for you. “It was…a lot.” He admitted, making you blush and groan against the pillow. “But…” he continued, and cupped your check, making you look at him. “I enjoyed it. Especially since it was with you.”

He perched himself up on his shoulders and kissed you, touching his forehead against yours.

“I love you MC. And I’m happy that you were the first person that I…well…a-and, I…I wouldn’t mind doing this again.” He smiled, and you couldn’t help but smile back, nuzzling his nose.

“I’m sure you’re tired…why don’t you stay the night here? Might as well…” you said.

Simeon blushed a bit, not wanting to think about what the demon brothers might say to him tomorrow for staying over (and the marks on his wrists, neck and chest -he was going to have to borrow a hoodie from you) but he did want to spend the rest of the time left with you.

You both cuddled and peppered small kisses all over each other, whispering sweet words.

“Wait…” you suddenly said. Simeon raised an eyebrow.

“You…did you just say I was your first?” You asked, eyes wide. Simeon slowly nodded.

You immediately covered your mouth and turned pale. “Holy shit, Michael is going to kill me- not only him but the rest of heaven- oh GOD SIMEON!”

After trying to calm you down (you were sure you were going to get punished by all of the three worlds for corrupting their most precious angel) Simeon and you fell asleep on your bed, happily in each other’s embrace.

Here’s the unholy people that wanted to be tagged (sorry for being so late lol)