Chocolate Chip Chokehold
Leon Kennedy
tags! Firefighter Leon Kennedy x baker neighbor reader, man in uniform smut, yearning, low-key spying, size difference (muscle-wise), bicep kink lowkey, choking with bicep, cream pie, aftercare
Sumsum - A clumsy run-in with a dangerously charming neighbor ignites an instant, unspoken tension. What starts as a simple exchange of sweets quickly turns into lingering glances, heated looks, and a growing obsession. Drawn back to his door under the guise of kindness, you find yourself stepping into something far more intoxicating, where every look, word, and touch teases the line between innocence and desire, and neither of you plan to resist.
WC. 5163 (I'm a whore for long fics and plot)
Barbies Note⌠I literally just gave in to the feminine urge to bake cupcakes, which resulted in me slaving over my oven for an hour longer than I should have. Then the whole experience had me thinking⌠What if I had a neighbor that I could bake and cook for, realize he was incredibly hot, then fuck like bunnies bc we're just attracted to each other like that. So that's kinda this story in a nutshell with chocolate chip cookies and some plot instead of cupcakes bc Iâm a plot maniac even tho I suck at writing it sometimes.
â45, 50, and 55⌠Aw shit! I made too much againâŚâ You sigh loudly in exhaustion, wipe the sweat off your brow, and sit back on your kitchen stool. Since you own a bake shop by yourself, this isn't the first time you've had to work out of your home kitchen because of a pipe busting or some other frivolous problem in your bakery. This also isn't the first time that you've baked too much and been stuck on who to give the extras to. You always have the option to give them to the people who ordered the desserts in the first place, but they always expect the same courtesy when ordering next time, and you rarely make miscalculated mistakes when you work in your bakery. (Your preferred area of work.)
The next best option is to give the extras to your neighbors. âHow about the old lady across the street?â You contemplate, âNo, you've already done that once this week⌠And she has diabetes, so she'd probably reject a second batch anyway.â Now, there's always the newlywed couple to the right of you, but whenever you talk to them, you end up staying for absolutely too long because they keep reliving their relationship journey. Every. Single. Time. It'd always start with what youâd bring them.
Didnât matter if it was brownies or cookies; they had an unrelatable love story for it. One story that they never let down is one about cupcakes.
âAnd thatâs when she took the cupcake and smeared it all over my face. Mind you, I looked down for one second to grab the ring box from my pocket!â Darrel laughed with a toothy salesman smile.
âOh, hubby, stop it! If I knew that you were going to propose, I wouldâve never caked you. The sign in the restaurant said that if you unsuspectingly caked the person you came with, your meal would be free.â Gabriela pouted with her bottom lip jutting out.
It's grossly cute in a way, a way that makes you want to cry and binge eat all the cookies you just made until you die from sugar poisoning. Nevertheless, you have a successful business to run, so you can't. Before you could get yourself worked up about it, the sound of a nearby car pulling into its driveway snaps you out of it. You look at the time and let out another sigh. âLate as usualâ you trail off while pushing the extras to the side to carefully pack the order into small boxes while counting them in increments of ten.
You grab your biggest delivery basket and arrange it so they all fit a bit too snug for your liking, and rush your way out to your car. The basket begins to slip from your grip as you groan and grunt. âShit, shit, shit!â You exclaim louder than youâd like, even though itâs warranted. After all, you didnât spend three additional hours perfecting a loaded Cookie Monster x s'mores cookie recipe just to drop ALL of them (curse your âone trip onlyâ mentality) before you even make it to the car. Despite you trying your hardest, all your efforts are in vain. You feel the woven straw and wood handle slide from your grasp, peppering your hand with splinters to dissuade you from hanging on any longer. Then poof, itâs gone from your grasp. With how heavy the basket was, you expected it to hurt at least a little when it dropped on your foot, but it didn't. You sigh, eyes squeezed shut in frustration and pain. You reach down with your good hand only to miss the basket multiple times. With no other choice, you look down, expecting to see that the basket may have just missed you, only to be met with a pair of scuffed black boots.
Slightly alarmed by the mysterious man towering over you, your eyes begin to slowly rake up his body like you were in a horror movie. You start with his heavy-duty boots that were polished yet splattered with mud and⌠ash, through a wild guess. Once you determine that there is nothing else of interest down there, your eyes wander farther up. They trail over to his thick black sweatpant-clad thighs, and it doesn't take more than one glance for you to realize the girth heâs packing there. It seemed like one of them was twice the size of your head. From his legs alone, you can only imagine what else the man could be packing. The thought makes your mind run with foul ideas and your mouth parts with your tongue darting out to subtly lick the top row of your teeth.
You snap out of your lustful train of thought when you feel something tap you on the head.
âMy eyes are up here, princess.â The man above you says, followed by another chuckle that has you shooting upright with a shiver pulsing through your body. Your eyes squeeze shut, trying to adjust to the sudden movement before you meet his face. Blinking open your lids, you notice that his eyes were already on yours, analyzing and reading you like an open book. Along with that, his expression is relaxed, yet knowing. Almost as if he already knows everything you want to do to him. And everything that he is going to do to you when the opportunity presents itself.
The newfound sexual tension between you two weighs heavily on your shoulders and washes a hot wave over your cheeks. The heat has every crevice of your body moistening with sweat and/or arousal. God, you need to get laid. There is no reason for you to be folding so easily when nothing has happened. âStupid fucking imaginationâ You think to yourself. You open your mouth to speak in hopes of making you look less like a horny dumb bimbo, yet your body works against you. Your throat viciously dries up, causing you to stand there, parched with your mouth open. Only when the man starts talking again do you conscientiously close your mouth.
âWere you⌠expecting something?â He jokes once more with a low laugh. Finally getting fed up with getting laughed and chuckled at, you find the words to defend yourself.
âN-No, No, not at all. What I meant to say was, um. Thank you for your help, but Iâm fine!â You say, snatching the basket of cookies from his grasp, forgetting how heavy it was and only causing the splinters in your hand to ram themselves deeper than you ever felt.
âAre you sure you got it under control?â He says, finally displaying another expression other than his knowing smirk. âYup!â You retort back, clearly struggling with the heavy basket, breath hitching in your throat. Yet, you power through and shimmy closer to the car, almost sandwiching him in between. When you jolt your head to the side, he realizes that he's in the way of you and the delivery car. He scoots out of your way, slowly, his eyes still trained on you as you gently toss the basket into the backseat and strap it in like it was a toddler. You slam the door when you're done, and turn around only to notice that the fine man helping you was still standing there, watching. Not knowing where to start, you both stand in silence as time and the world around you moves painfully slow. Your mouth opens once again, and again, nothing comes out. Not because you were sexually smitten by the man, though your actions and the heated tension between you both would say differently, but because there simply isn't anything you know about him to start a conversation. In fact, you expect him to take the awkward situation into his hands and tell a joke with a low chuckle again, but nothing. There is no joke made, only silence.
âWhy is he still here?â
âI hope he isn't expecting a reward because I don't have anything for himâŚâ
Your thoughts trail off as an idea pops into your head.
âOh! Wait here!â You exclaim out loud and jog back inside.
After five minutes of disinfecting and patching up your hand, you pack up the extra cookies and write down the allergens, ingredients, and flavors on the box. You jog them back outside to your helper, bandaged and determined. âThere you go! This is a token of my appreciation for you saving my ass when I almost got flipped out on it. And don't worry, I wrote down all the allergens just in case.â You smile and place the cookies you proudly baked into his hands. âHmmm, I'm kinda watching how I eat right now.â He says, making your face drop, before he decides not to be such an ass. âBut if you made them, I'll try them⌠After all, a little taste wouldn't hurt.â He drops his voice a couple of notches, reverting back to the tone and demeanor he started the conversation with. The last part of his sentence would've gone right over your head if it wasn't for his lustful eye contact.
Your eyes light up with shock, but before a single word can leave your lips, he's already brushing past you with the kind of ease that speaks of confidence and danger. His hand slides across your waist, slow and deliberate, a firm touch that lingers just long enough to leave your skin burning in its absence.
You stand there, replaying the brush of his fingers, every unspoken word humming in the air between you. There's something about him, something sexy, something mysterious that makes you want more, and something sweet under all that.
Then you hear it. A soft, creaky hinge.
A door opens.
You turn around on instinct, curiosity snapping through your body like electricity. That's when you see it. The door to the house beside yours swings open, and in he goes.
He lives right. next. door.
Suddenly, your late-night thoughts and depressive ponderings have a new star. One with strong hands, a dangerous grin, no name... and a front door just steps away.
Who knows how long before those thoughts leak into the foreground of your brain and become actions.
â
The door clicks shut behind me, and I donât move. Not yet.
I lean into it, shoulder first, lazy and loose, like Iâve got all the time in the world. Like I didnât just walk away from something irresistibleâŚ.
No, someone.
I glance down at the minty green and pastel pink box in my hand, immediately thinking of her.
Cute. Sweet. Gentle. Thoughtful. âSaint-likeâ...
Those words come to mind by instinct, but I know that there is more to her. She wants to seem innocent, like sheâs simply the good-girl-next-door with vanilla and buttercream stained jeans, like she âunknowinglyâ marinates in temptation, and good intentions.
Bullshit.
Her intentions were nothing but lustful towards me, and that was upon arrival. That was before she even saw my face. She âtriedâ to pretend like she wasnât eye-fucking me the moment I showed up. But I see right through her. Anyone could. The way her tongue flicked across her teeth. The way her thighs clenched oh so deliciously when I chuckled. The way her stare clung to my thighs like she was picturing herself right on top, riding like her pleasure depended on it.
Oh and it willâŚ
The kind of softness she portrays is always hiding something filthy underneath. And the way she looked at me? She wants it dirty. She wants it fast. She wants it all. And Iâd give it to her. Right on her flour-dusted countertop, her cheek pressed to the marble, with nothing but that heart-shaped apron on while she moans and whines as we watch those little cookies that she probably put hours into burn to ash.
A low, whispered, groan emerges from my throat at the thought. I wipe my face in pent-up frustration and toss the cookie box onto the coffee table. I donât even want the damn things. But I do want her.
Keeping these thoughts in my head for any longer will be torture, but Iâll also enjoy every second of it.
â
Itâs been a week.
Seven days.
Seven sleepless, jazz-filled, touch-starved, baking-filled days since your embarrassing encounter with the man next door.
But thatâs on purpose. Because your bakery is still out of commission, you've had to continue working out of your personal kitchen, which didn't pose a problem at first. You enjoyed the musical freedom you had at your house. Blasting jazz, r&b, and house music is something you could never do at your bakery because there was an apartment building on top. You also loved that you could lounge around on the couch when you had down time. And lastly, you didn't have to drive home after work. Once your shift was done you could walk upstairs and take a shower. The 5 oâclock traffic after a tiresome day was no more. But then there were the cons. Only hours into your fifth day working from home and you realize how fucked you are with having a clear view into your next door neighbors house. With how much you've watched him this week, you can practically guesstimate his schedule.
He runs an 11/13 split. 11 hours gone at work and 13 resting and whatever his day entails. And you found out through observation that he is a fire fighter, so your soot hunch wasn't far-off.
He wakes up before the sun and takes a jog around the neighborhood before coming back to take a shower. Walks around in nothing but that god forsaken burgundy towel, and you don't want to admit how much you should've given him his privacy during times like that, and you didnât. Anyway, he throws on his undergarments and leaves his chest bare while he makes his mediocre breakfast of slightly burnt toast from his toaster (everyone knows it's the best when it's from the oven) slaps some jam, not jelly on one half and protein peanut butter on the other and eats them separately at his kitchen island before getting dressed and heading off to what you guess is work. Then it cycles Monday through Sunday.
You know this is unhealthy. Obsessive, even. Maybe borderline or over the line unhinged.
But itâs just looking. Just⌠observation.
You havenât done anything.
Yet.
â
Youâve overcooked this time.
Of course you did, haha! It's like the universe is taunting and laughing at you, or⌠The universe might be trying to take you exactly where you belongâŚ
So now youâre standing here, hot plate in hand, heels that were meant to impress but now feel like self-sabotage weapons, making you shift your weight from one foot to the other. You try telling yourself that you're not falling for him in the most shallow way possible without even knowing his name yet. You tell yourself itâs just a neighborly gesture. A nice deed out of the goodness of your heart. A peace offering.
But deep down, in that sweet-sticky part of you that is kept locked behind lipstick and linen aprons, you know it isnât. In fact, you want him to taste, devour that part of you.
Itâs not about feeding him. Or being polite.
Itâs about maybe brushing fingers again.
About hearing that low, amused laugh that tightens things inside you that have no business tightening. About how he looks at you like heâs already tasted the mess between your thighs and decided he wants seconds. A dark lust filled glance. A low chuckle in that voice that made your thighs clench oh so naughty and deliciously.
You damn near drool at his doorstep before the soft creak of his front door pulls you back to earth, just in time to feel the warm press of his presence fill the space in front of you.
Your eyes flutter open before he says anything, giving you a moment. Just one sinful, stolen moment to drink him in.
Heâs dressed head to toe in black.
A black compression shirt clings to his broad shoulders like it was tailored with your fantasies in mind. Black joggers hanging low on his hips, low enough to show the lethality of his v-line, but cuffed just enough to tease what else is down there and the casual sin in his stride. He looks like trouble disguised as need, heat wrapped in shadow and mystery.
And the way he leans against the doorframe, one hand on hip and the other by his head with his bare forearm flexed just so, it makes your mouth go dry.
He looks you up and down like youâre a dessert he didnât order but fully intends to devour anyway.
âYou always dress like this to drop off cookies?â
God, that smirk. That knowing in his eyes.
Itâs not polite. Itâs not sweet.
Itâs feral. Starved. Curious.
It almost makes you want to forget how shallow everything is and feel him plunging deep into every hole you have.
Almost.
âWell, actually, itâs food this time.â You say, side stepping the question he already knows the answer to. You hold the plate up as if it was a delicate gift. You see him scan your features as you put on a small truly innocent smile while you still switch the weight back and forth on your feet which he chooses not to comment on yet. Instead, an unnecessarily lustful groan accompanied by what you believe to be his signature chuckle gracefully leaves his lips, making a hot dip in your stomach. There's a hint of rasp in his voice as his next words, filthy and sinful, roll off his tongue like hot ice. âOh Sweet thing, you shouldn't have.â
Oooooh. fuck.
You almost dropped the plate right then and there and forced him into a mating press, if that was even a forcible position. Your hands tighten around the edges of the plate you were holding, your shoulders tensing along with them. A toothy grin tugs on the corner of his lips as he watches the words make waves on your body. He makes the pet name sound like it's your name, like it's on your birth certificate, like it was made for you. It's like a verbal lick to every sweet spot and erogenous zone in and out your body all at the same time. His words shoot straight down to your cunt and flood your panties in arousal after doing a number on your shoulders. You mash your legs together to combat the drenched feeling and clear your throat.
âA-ah, well⌠I didâŚâ You murmur, voice tight in your throat, the strength in your arms faltering from tensing them for so long. The plate almost slips from your hand.
He sees this but doesnât make a move to take it from you. Instead, he leans in just enough for you to catch the scent of something woody. The arm on his hip gracefully wraps around your waist, his hand leaving a faint guide on your lower back. âWhy donât you bring that inside?â he taunts low, coaxing, devastating. His words leave your mouth with nothing to say and your brain empty, leaving you with no other option but to obey.
You take three small steps inside, yet they feel like the biggest decision you've ever made. As if it was only to confirm the way you were feeling, the door shuts behind you with a quiet click followed by a lock. Itâs a seal. A promise. A warning. A warning that you didnât take but are ready to receive all of the sticky consequences for.
Your eyes scan over his living space, it's dim with soft lighting and sleek cream colored walls. The place looks very modern with dark academia pops of color, seeing as most of his furniture and miscellaneous table pieces were burgundy or navy blue. You walk past the living room, straight through to the kitchen. You place the plate down on the counter with care, like itâs still your main reason for being here. But the moment you straighten up, you feel his presence behind you.
Coming closer. Closer. Closer until his handsâstrong, calloused, and hot sneak onto the counter top on both sides, caging you in. They're still far enough from your body that you can still think coherent thoughts, however you don't know how long that'll last. His proximity makes you sputter out as you direct your focus to the covered plate of food in front of you and drag it closer. âI⌠I made oven baked salmon with a sideââ A hand, specifically his left one inches closer to your body until it rests ever so lightly on your lower stomach, it makes your breath hitch.
âYou know damn well that's not why youâre here.â He whispers, teeth making themselves known on your ear. âMay I?â He asks, to which you consent. As if it wasn't what you wanted most right now. âI'd like nothing else more.â He nips the top and you find yourself leaning into the pain with closed eyes rather than jolting away. He hums a âmhmmâ, watching your expression gently contort from shy and guarded to one full of pleasure and longing. âIf it was, then your face wouldn't be twisting with ecstasy when I've barely even touched you.â You only catch the tail end of his sentence and bite your lip when you feel the need to challenge his words with begs and pleads of âmoreâ or âpleaseâ.
As if he could read your mind, both hands trail down to your cunt and to no surprise, your pussy is sopping, weeping, crying for him to touch it. âAnd if it was, â holy fuckââ He rasps, flipping your skirt up to slide a finger through your clothed pussy. âYou wouldn't be this fucking drenched.â You hadnât noticed his feather-like touches on your cunt until he moved his arousal clad finger to his lips. âOh, sweet thing. You taste like absolute heaven.â Two thick fingers, riddled with aged scars and even a lonely burn mark tease the outside. They ghostly wander up, down, and side to side on your lips with feather-like touches. You grind backwards onto him, hoping that he would get the message that you didnât want to be teased. âSo impatient, sweet thing. It looks like you really came over here for one thing.â He attempts to taunt you but it goes in one ear and out the other until he pulls your panties to the side and slides two thick fingers inside your sopping pussy. Your body arches against the cool edge of the counter when they plunge deeper. He moves unapologetically, stretching you with each deliberate thrust. The scars on his knuckles brush against your inner walls with tastefully bold and insistent strokes. Heat coils tight in your core, your thighs trembling as slick already starts dripping down his hand. He curls his fingers inside you, looking for and finding that spot that makes your vision blur.
"That's it, sweet thing," he praises against your neck, his breathing wispy and ragged. "Let me feel you squeeze around my fingers." His free hand slides up your side, gripping your hip hard, pulling your frame back against his chest. You buck your hips, chasing the pressure, and moans spill from your lips as he pumps faster. His thumb presses down on your clit, rubbing in tight slow circles that send sparks shooting up your spine. The orgasm crashes over you without warning. Your walls flutter and spasm around his fingers, gushing slick that soaks his palm. You cry out, head falling back onto his shoulder, but he doesn't stop. He keeps driving, drawing out every pulse until you're shaking, bent over on the counter, oversensitive and whimpering.
You hear the wet slide as he licks them clean, moaning at the taste. Before you can catch your breath, his hands are on your waist, spinning you to face him. His eyes gaze into yours as he lifts you effortlessly onto the counter. You donât realize that he's slipped off your panties until your ass hits the cold surface. You yelp, startled legs spreading instinctively, but he steps between them, his joggers tented with the thick outline of his cock.
He peels your shirt up and over your head, tossing it aside, then yanks your pants and soaked panties down in one rough motion. Naked now, you feel exposed under his gaze, your smaller body flushed and quivering while he towers over you, still fully clothed. His hands roam your skin, squeezing your breasts, pinching your nipples until they harden into peaks. You reach for him, fingers tracing the ridges of his abs through the compression shirt, but he grabs your wrists, pinning them above your head with one massive hand.
"Not yet," he says, smirking as he grinds his clothed cock against your bare pussy. The friction makes you whine, hips rolling up for more. He releases your wrists only to shove his joggers down, freeing his thick cock. It's long and veined, the head already leaking precum, and the sight makes your mouth water even as your pussy aches to be filled. He strokes himself once, twice, smearing the precum along his length, then lines up at your entrance.
After probing for a bit, he buries himself inside you to the hilt, causing a sharp gasp to push out of you. Feeling so full, your pussy stretches around his girth, the burn mixing with pleasure when he bottoms out. You cry out, legs wrapping around his waist, but he's too big, too strong, too long. His hips snap forward, fucking you deep and hard on top of the counter. Each plunge sweetly kisses your cervix, his balls slapping against your ass, the wet sounds echoing in the dim kitchen.
He leans in, capturing your mouth in a bruising kiss, tongue fucking your mouth in time with his cock. You taste yourself on him, salty and sweet, as your hands finally grip his shoulders, feeling the massive muscles work under your palms. The size difference amplifies everything when his body engulfs yours, pinning you down as he drives into you relentlessly.
"Fuck, you're so perfect for me," he grunts, breaking the kiss to nip at your jaw. His pace quickens, cock dragging along your walls, hitting that hot spot again and again. Air is knocked out of your sails with every slam. Your second orgasm builds fast, coiling tighter with every thrust. He senses it, one hand sliding to your throat, not yet squeezing, just resting there like a promise.
"Cum for me," he says, voice rough. You shatter around him, pussy clamping down like a vice, milking his length as waves of pleasure rip through you, more powerful and electrifying than the first. âOooooh, FUCK!â He doesn't slow, pounding you through it, your juices squirting around his base and dripping onto the edge of the counter.
As you come down, panting, he pulls out just enough to flip you over. âWas that good, Sweet Thing?â He teases. You both know that he knows the answer, but you dumbly nod anyway. âYou need a name to scream while I fuck the lights out if you, Sweet Thing?â You nod again, nothing fully processing what he's saying. âIt's Leon.â Before you can repeat it, your chest is pressed against the cool marbled surface, ass out, and he pushes back in from behind. The new angle lets him go deeper, his hips slapping against your cheeks with a bruising force. One hand snakes around your waist, pressing down on your tummy bulge while the other flexes, his bicep bulging hard against your throat.
He pulls you back into it, the thick muscle compressing your airway just enough to make your head spin. Stars burst behind your eyes as oxygen deprivation heightens every sensation, making your pussy flutter wildly. Your eyes threaten to roll back with your core getting hot. You gasp for air in short bursts, the pressure building a third orgasm from the edge of pain and ecstasy.
"Feel that?" he rasps, tightening his bicep hold as he fucks you harder. The feeling is intoxicating, your smaller neck trapped in his massive bicep, veins popping under the skin as he stays flexed with each thrust. You reach back, fingers digging into his arm, feeling the sturdiness there, and it tips you over. âOh fuck, Leon! Oh, oh yea!â
Your body convulses, toes pointing as all the blood in your body rushes to your pussy for the third time. He groans, the squeeze pushing him close, but he holds off, releasing your throat to let you breathe. You suck in air, dizzy and euphoric, as he flips you back over, legs over his shoulders now.
He folds you in half with his hands in the crevice on the back of your knees, the position letting him plunge even deeper, his muscular frame engulfing yours. Sweat glistens through his compression shirt, outlining every ridge of his toned, lived-in, chest, and arms. You stare at his biceps, still marked from your nails, and he notices, flexing them deliberately as he rails you.
"You like these?" he teases, voice strained. "Fucking slut." He laughs heartily. The words send you spiraling toward a fourth peak, your clit gently grinding against his pelvis with every thrust.
You come undone, walls pulsing frantically, and that's his undoing. With a guttural and weathered moan, he buries himself deep, cock throbbing as he unloads. Hot ropes of cum flood your pussy, painting your insides white, the creampie overflowing around his base and trickling down your ass. He keeps thrusting through it, milking every drop, until you're both spent, his weight pressing you into the counter.
Finally, he pulls out, watching his cum leak from your tight hole with a satisfied smirk. He scoops you up, carrying your limp body to the bathroom, before he gets the shower started. Despite how new all the amenities were in his house, the water still took a second to warm up. Pushing you up against the glass shower door, he takes your lips with his as you wait. He switches it up every now and then, going from your lips, to your neck, then collarbone, all before repeating.
Eventually, you both get in the shower and words become non-existent between you two. Just gentle breaths as you wash his back, and he washes yours, thorough, but brief.
Wrapping you in a spare towel, he carries you through the dim house, and straight to his room. He tosses a clean sleep shirt your way and you immediately know what to do with it. The rest of the night passes in a calm, uncomplicated breeze. Ultimately, the focus shifts toward rest, as the exhaustion of the day and certain activities finally takes hold.
âGood night, Leon.â
âSweet Dreams, Sweet Thing.â
















