Because I cannot deal right now, and Tim went all -write fanficfion if you don't like what I write- here's a prompt to fix some of the dumpster fire that happened in 5x11.
Buck is waiting for Eddie and chatting up with Lucy. He's having a good time talking to her until Lucy starts getting a little too close and insinuating things, and buying Buck drinks.
Buck's too nice to say anything but he starts getting a little uncomfortable.
When she says she likes to see him squirm, he denies it and looks to the side, trying to see if Eddie has made it and trying to put some distance with Lucy.
Which is when Lucy pounces to kiss him.
Buck startles and reels back. He stutters and is too shoked to say anything at first.
Lucy goes all "live a little" and tries to kiss him again.
But Buck is aware of her now and says he has a girlfriend.
Lucy backs off and apologizes.
Buck apologizes if he sent the wrong message or something. He didn't mean to.
Lucy is all "no harm no foul, you were just being nice, I misinterpreted."
Buck texts Eddie, who says something came up and he couldn't come.
Buck decides the night is now awful and can't decide if he's too drunk or not drunk enough to deal with all this bullshit.
He goes to the loft and tells Taylor about the kiss, apologizing.
Taylor asks if he reciprocated.
Taylor then says he has nothing to apologize for then. Obviously it was an unfortunate misunderstanding and he didn't do anything wrong.
Buck still apologizes, because that's who he is, trying to say that he should have expected it or something.
Taylor jokes that he's not a mind reader. If he wasn't even looking at Lucy when it happened how was he to guess that's what Lucy was going to do.
Buck doesn't think of Lucy that way and doesn't want to kiss her nor did he want to reciprocate. But it does leave him thinking about the night before the kiss. How much fun he was having and the easy camaraderie he had with Lucy before the misunderstanding. He can't stop thinking that he needs to reevaluate his relationship if a one day friendship felt better than a 6+ month relationship.
So, character development! Buck is the one who breaks up with Taylor after a few days. Accepting that sometimes leaving is the right thing, and how for once, it has to be his non-impulsive, unwavering choice.
She asks if it was about Lucy.
He says yes, but explains it wasn't the kiss. It was the fact that he felt more comfortable and open with a new friend than with his girlfriend and that obviously isn't right.
Taylor admits the relationship has been on a standstill for a while and she knows Buck has a lot going on too. She wanted it to work, but she had a feeling it wouldn't.
Buck goes to Eddie and finds him in the middle of his meltdown.
Buck is there for Eddie, who opens up, at last, bridging their divide so they can heal and come together.
An epiphany: Buck realizes he's in love with Eddie Diaz instead.
No need to claim a prompt. If written on AO3, please gift it to me. On tumblr, tag me. I have the same name on both websites.