Being in Andrewâs arms created a sense of safety and warmth in Coraâs heart. No matter what was going on in her life, he was always the one that kept her grounded and sane. He was the one who was able to put a smile on her face when all she wanted to do was frown, he was the one who lifted her heavy heart and made the burden of all she had to carry that much lighter. Andrew was â he was perfect for Cora in each in every way. In the way that he looked at her when she was acting goofy or being sad. In the way his eyes lit up when she smiled at him. In the way that, even if he couldnât always find the right words to say sometimes, his presence and his heart could always reach through the shadow of the veil that hung over Coraâs mind on occasion. So of course he was the one she ran to in her time of need. Of course he was the one who made her feel if only slightly better already just by holding her. He was her angel. He picked her up when she was down and graced her with his light.
Reaching up a hand to rest on top of one of Andrewâs, Cora felt the damn break. She had been attempting to stay strong, had been attempting to stop from completely crumbling. But the safety that she found in Andrew, the comfort and the solace â she knew there was no judgement, that he would care for her even if she wasnât always the strong woman that she pretended she always was. She felt like she could unload all her troubles on him and he would gladly take on the darkness of her sadness with willing shoulders and a loving heart. There was no wonder in why she suddenly wrapped her arms around him again, burying her face in his chest as quiet sobs wracked her body. She could break, but she couldnât be loud â even in her distress and suffering, she knew her daughter was sleeping peacefully and refused to wake the child. What would Ana think if she walked into the living room to find Mommy in tears? Nothing good, Cora was sure.
âEverythingâs wrong,â Cora managed to get out, clutching onto Andrewâs shirt like it was her only lifeline, the only thing keeping her afloat. âI canât â I donât know what to do, Andrew. I donât know how to â how to do it all. I donât know how to handle these things.â She pulled away from Andrew, her shoulders still shaking slightly as she turned her back to him, once again wrapping her arms around herself. Andrew was safe, and secure â but Cora didnât like seeming weak. She didnât like showing vulnerabilities. Crying to him was one thing, but admitting what was going on in her head? That was completely different, and she felt better when she didnât have to look into his eyes as she spouted off about her insecurities and complications.
âMy second year just started and â and itâs hard. And I knew it would be, I did. I â I knew it would be so hard, and that itâll only get harder. But how am I supposed to be a great student, a great friend, a great mother, and a great girlfriend all at the same time? While trying to move? Iâm not â Iâm not Wonder Woman, you know? I canât â thereâs not enough time in the day. Iâm not smart enough, or fast enough, or patient enough or â or good enough. Iâm not good enough. And Manny, he ââ Cora closed her eyes tightly, sniffling once again. âHeâs such a nice guy, Andrew. He is. Heâs so sweet and so good with Ana and â and Iâve been afraid to tell you about him. But why? Youâre Andrew and Iâve never kept secrets from you.â
She finally turned to her ex, the father of her child â and shrugged slightly, her eyes holding a look of defeat. âI was afraid to tell you because â because I realized something. Manny is the first person Iâve dated since you and â and I thought that was because I wanted to get through school first, you know? No distractions. But the more time I spend with him â heâs great, but heâs⌠heâs not you. Every single guy thatâs â thatâs shown me any kind of interest since high school, I always find a reason not to date them. Because of Ana, because of school, because of work â but they were all just excuses. The fact of the matter is, no one can hold a flame to you. And Iâve been afraid to tell you about Manny because â because Iâm afraid that youâre not going to care and that â and that I donât mean to you anymore what you have always meant to me. And I donât â I donât think I could take that. That, on top of everything else. I couldnât take the heartbreak on top of all the stress Iâm under. Manny is special, and wonderful but being with him has only made me realize that there is only one person in this world that Iâm really, truly, honestly meant to be with and â and itâs not him. I donât love him. I love â you. But how is that â how is that fair to him? Iâve used him, essentially. So not only am I stressed out and not good enough and apparently afraid of rejection, but Iâm also a terrible person.â She let out a mirthless laugh, shaking her head, before covering her face with her hands. âIâm a mess.â
Very rarely had Cora allowed herself to be seen like this -- vulnerable and scared, every ounce of the confident girl with the world in the palm of her hand stripped away to reveal the one who was terrified of all that it entailed. Andrew let his hands fall, placing them onto her shoulders as he listened; no words were uttered on his behalf while she spoke, listening to everything, every thought swimming through her mind, tumbling all out and into the open.Â
The name was like a punch to the gut because of all the people in this town, he never thought he would have to worry about him -- but then again, what loyalty would he have to Andrew? He had always been Coraâs friend and not his, it became abundantly clear. For a moment, he saw red, his jaw clenching as he thought about just how long Manny had waited to make his move -- was it since he took her to their prom? Or even before that, waiting patiently until the perfect moment arose to swoop in to take Cora from him.
But then -- she wasnât his, was she?Â
Even now, as she listed every glittering attribute of the other man, he felt so small in comparison. It would explain why Ana had been speaking of her precious Uncle Manny so often. Why they had spent more time together. Why she had pulled away from him. It was because of Manny. Andrew had already lost her, and here he had been pathetically hoping that the day would come that she would turn to him and look at him with that very same look in her eyes -- the one she used to look at him with, the one that held not even the slightest hesitation -- and tell him she was ready to forgive him, ready to open her heart to him, ready to be more than whatever they were now, if they were anything at all.Â
With his eyes downcast, his shoulders fell into a slump, a ball forming in the center of his throat.Â
âBut heâs... heâs not you.âÂ
His blue eyes snapped up to meet hers, searching for an answer, but she kept talking and talking, and -- God, his heart raced in his chest, almost sure that Cora could hear it from where she stood less than a handful of inches away from him. When she covered her face, his hands easily wrapped themselves around her small wrists to pull them away, reaching up to cup her face once more as he said, âYeah, you are. You are definitely a mess, Cora St. James.â
Before he said another word, he leaned in, brushing his lips against hers before he pressed closer to her and kissed her sweetly, softly, but with the underlying hint of wanting more because he always wanted more -- he wanted all of Cora. Every good part of her that came right alongside every bad part; the peaks and valleys, the beautiful and the ugly. He wanted every piece of her just as he yearned for her to want every piece of him.Â
Pulling away was no easy feat, but when he eventually could, with his cheeks slightly flushed, he said, âYouâre my mess, Cora. And Iâve-- Iâve loved you since before I knew what love meant. I have never once stopped loving you. I donât think I could, even if I wanted to. Even if it meant being in love with someone who didnât want me back, I didnât want anyone else but you. I still donât. Youâre my whole life -- you and Anastasia. I would wait for however long you needed me to if it meant that one day I could call you mine and you could call me yours and be proud of the man you chose to be by your side.â
âYou donât have to do it all by yourself. You have me, for however long you want me. Just... just let me help, Cora. I promise not to let you down again.â