Was it easier to lose someone after they’d lived a life like she had? Was it easier when Sharon had an entire childhood of summers at Peggy’s house, when they got to sit on the beach and eat ice cream together, when she passed down her thigh holster and they could talk about work? Was it easier when there was a decade of mourning, of learning to let go, before the inevitable happened? Peggy wasn’t sure. Everyone she’d ever lost had been taken far too soon. Her parents. Her darling, dead brother. Her best friend. Steve. Daniel. Peggy was a walking wardrobe of memories, dragging along the people who’d left this life long before she had behind her. Maybe Sharon was pleased, secretly, that Peggy was finally at peace – that she didn’t need to keep repeating her name, reminding her of the day she was born, saying no, Howard is dead, he’s been dead a long time–
But this didn’t look pleased. She looked haunted. Even in the split second before she seemed to realise this was actually happening, Peggy could read the weight of grief on her niece’s shoulders (it was something she was achingly familiar with, after all. She’d been a widow long before she was even married). “Not a long time, in the grand scheme of things,” Peggy said, “but it’s a lifetime when you’re missing someone.” Missing something. A support system, an anchor.
(She didn’t have much time between waking up and coming here, but there were certain events she couldn’t miss. SHIELD falling into the Potomac, the Red Skull even in death infiltrating the very agency she founded to the memory of a great man, to the letter of freedom and justice. How dare they – and how Sharon must look at her now. A foolish old woman who missed what grew under her nose for decades.)
“It’s almost exactly like our first home looked,” Peggy offered, a tight smile on her face. “Though we were attached to another house. We had neighbours that used to drill holes in the connecting wall so they could shout through for us to turn the music down. We were never playing music when they yelled, so we’re quite sure they were hearing things. Bizarre people, really.” It was the kind of place she’d pictured during the war. She’d never been the domestic type, never thought about a white picket fence and goats and children, but she’d thought about it then. She’d pictured it.
It was all to do with the people you surrounded yourself with. Peggy knew that well, after decades of living alone, then trying out the alternative. Losing people hurt, but it was worth it every time. She looked down at the shoes by the door, the coat hanging up on the hook. “She’s just like her mother,” Peggy offered. “You always loved getting messy in the garden. Used to track dirt right through to the kitchen. I always thought Daniel would’ve–” Loved that. Loved her. He’d barely known her. She may not even recognise him, except for photographs.
Then Sharon spoke again, and Peggy broke herself from her daze. “Oh, no,” she said. “That’s a little too close to the summer I stayed with Howard for my liking. I found a place in Bed-Stuy that suits me perfectly. Good neighbours.” It would be better, of course, if she was closer to Sharon, but she felt that was a little too presumptuous to say. “It’s okay,” Peggy said, and this time it was so easy to be soft, to reach out and put her hand over Sharon’s on her arm. “Whatever you’re feeling – if you’re angry or sad or confused – it’s okay. It’s always been okay. I’m still your same aunt, and if you need time, I can give that to you.”
You learned to live with it. That was the cold, hard truth of loss. You never really got over it, but you learned how to manage it. Learned how to know when to let it out, when to bottle it up — and how to do all of that without breaking under the pressure of the reality that you were faced with. Loss. Death. Grief. Sharon would have said she was years to prepare for it, years of walking in and putting on her mother’s wedding rings because her aunt remembered Amanda, but not her. At least, not as an adult. She’d talk to Sharon and ask her how the baby was, and if she’d bring her over to visit. And Sharon would always smile as if it didn’t cut into her heart, and say next time.
Sharon had spent those last years being whoever Peggy needed her to be, pocketing the rings when Peggy did recognize her and ask questions about her friends. And sometimes, there was no recognition there. Sometimes, Sharon was just a nurse who was checking in on the health of her patient. (Those days were harder.) “A lifetime,” Sharon agreed, letting out a strained laugh. Everything that had happened in the last ten years — she was sure that Peggy wouldn’t remember it. And in those ten years was so much. Danny came home. Trip died. SHIELD went down. Inhumans had made their presence publicly known. But those were big world things. Sharon, as invested as she was in the world, had been drowning in a lot more than those things. Germany. Being on the run. Crawling back to SHIELD because that was the only path home that didn’t end with her being charged with treason for what she had done. “I’d offer to help you catch up but I think I’d end up turning all the events around.”
There was a faint laugh, awkward still, while Sharon tried to find her footing with her Aunt again. (She was there — really there — and it was still hard to process, even as they kept matching up with stories. The normal things that would come up about Peggy’s late husband.) “We tried to figure it out in a single room apartment. But we couldn’t keep it up with the new addition.” They could have, if they really had wanted to. But there was freedom in this home that they didn’t have in the city. Especially when James needed to stay hidden from the world, and Tali wasn’t legal. And Sharon had a job where people would look for things in her life, like James and Tali, and try and hurt them in order to get back at her or manipulate her somehow. It was all so much risk and a lot of that remained even now, but at least James didn’t have to pretend not to be James anymore.
“Holes in the walls—” Sharon pinched her nose at the thought of it. She hadn’t spent much time in her apartment with her work, but she’d have to ask James later if he had any weird encounters with her neighbors at all.
Just like her mother. Sharon wrinkled her nose immediately, trying to let herself fall back into her normal reactions, let herself relax because this was her aunt. “Don’t agree with James. It’s his fault she’s bringing in mud. Something about getting dirty being normal and healthy…” and it was. It was very normal for children. (And Sharon knew that it was normal for her — even without Peggy there to remind her, Tony had been all too happy to retell all the terrible things she had done as a child to him.)
“Are you renting from Barton?” She understood it though, not wanting to stay here where she would be welcomed but that wouldn’t stop it from being awkward and strange. (And Sharon was sure that she’d want to talk to James first. Not for permission, but to make sure he cut his hair and looked polished. It didn’t matter that her aunt knew James from the war, she had a feeling in her gut that she’d scalp him like all her other boyfriends.) “I…” Sharon was conflicted, even here. It was starting to hit that this was real. Even as she kept repeating it in her mind, the longer that Peggy stood there, within reach, the more real it became. The more she was sure this wasn’t some fever dream. “I’ve been asking the universe for more time for as long as I can remember. And it never gives me any,” Sharon said thickly. “So, I’d rather not waste it here. I’m a lot of things but — I can figure that out later.” She didn’t want to waste what time she had with Peggy worrying about how it happened and being angry or confused or any combination there. She could save that for later. Though, this time, she was sure she wouldn’t need a bottle of whiskey and a fight with a bathtub.