★﹐Harder Than You Think.﹗﹑
Rivals to lovers abby x fem!reader
note - if you see any mistakes in the fic please feel free to tell me i'll go and fix it!! (this was not proofread by someone esle) This is also more short and sweet type one shot so i apologize if its cliche
If you want to join my personal taglist let me know!!
permanent taglist - @valeisaslut @sourrswitchblade @sewithinsouls
You knew from the moment she walked into the compound that she’d be trouble.
Abby Anderson. Towering. Scarred. Broad-shouldered and broad-tempered. She looked like she could punch through a brick wall — and probably had. You’d heard the rumors before she even opened her mouth. Ex-WLF. Trained killer. Real piece of work. A human battering ram with a resting bitch face and a reputation.
But the minute she challenged you during your first training session together — called your grip on a blade “sloppy” with that infuriating calm — it was over. She made you want to spit fire. Or win. Or both.
“I didn’t realize muscle mass was a personality trait,” you snapped, flipping your knife and tossing it hard into the wooden post.
It landed just left of center. Shit.
Abby smirked. One of those closed-mouth grins that felt more like a dare than a smile. She stepped up beside you, her own blade out. Thicker. Balanced.
“Didn’t realize ego could bleed so fast,” she said, retrieving both knives without waiting for permission.
But enough to make it your daily goal to beat her at something. Anything. Knife throws. Sparring drills. Food ration speed. Scavenging haul count. Hell, you once nearly started a bet on who could carry more bricks before collapsing.
She never gloated. That made it worse.
She just gave you that look. The quiet, knowing one. Like she knew you were trying too hard and loved it anyway.
That pissed you off more than losing.
The outpost wasn’t big. A few dozen survivors, max. Some were old Fireflies. Some ex-Scars. Most were just people trying to survive. They didn’t care where you came from, so long as you pulled your weight and didn’t start fights.
You and Abby were toeing that line daily.
She was stronger, sure. But you were faster. Sharper. Smarter in tight quarters.
At least, that’s what you told yourself.
The real problem was that you worked well together.
No one else could keep up with your rhythm. No one else could cover your blind spots as smoothly. And no one else had the guts to call you out when you were being reckless, except her.
“You’re gonna get yourself killed one day rushing in like that,” she said once after you cleared a runner nest.
“Better than sitting back while someone else bleeds,” you snapped, chest heaving.
She didn’t yell. Didn’t flinch.
Just took a breath and said, “I’m not your enemy.”
You laughed in her face. “Could’ve fooled me.”
But your stomach twisted, because part of you didn’t believe that anymore.
Part of you wanted her to keep saying things like that.
They paired you for patrol again.
Third time this week. Either fate was cruel or Manny was playing matchmaker in the most passive-aggressive way possible. You made a mental note to punch him later. If Abby didn’t beat you to it.
The morning fog clung low to the ground as you moved through the forest edge. Pines overhead. Muck underfoot. Every sound was amplified in the silence — twigs snapping, boots squelching, the whisper of your breath in cold air.
Abby walked ahead, quiet as ever, movements fluid. Tactical. Annoyingly competent.
“Try not to fall behind this time,” she said without looking back.
You rolled your eyes. “Try not to be a condescending asshole for once.”
She didn’t stop. Just tossed over her shoulder, “Still bleeding from that sparring match, huh?”
You clenched your jaw. She’d pinned you yesterday in front of half the camp. Quick and clean. No flair. Just efficiency. It had haunted you all night.
“Still milking that one victory?” you shot back.
Now she turned. Slow. One brow raised. “You think I keep track?”
Her eyes narrowed a little. Not angry. Just studying. Then she stepped closer. Not much. Just enough to make your pulse spike.
“Only when it matters,” she said.
Your breath caught. That tone again. Not a threat. A challenge. An invitation.
You stared at her, words dried up in your throat. Close enough to smell pine and sweat and something warm beneath it. Close enough to see the scar above her eyebrow. The way her lashes clumped at the ends.
To touch. To push. To test.
She tilted her head slightly. “What?”
“Nothing,” you said, stepping back before you could do something stupid. “Let’s just finish this patrol.”
But you didn’t know if you meant her.
The sky cracked open the moment you reached the outer perimeter.
Rain came fast — heavy and loud, drenching your jacket in seconds. Abby cursed behind you, voice low, as the two of you ducked beneath the skeletal remains of an old carport. Rusted steel. Sagging beams. But shelter, for now.
You both stood there, panting, water running down your faces, your sleeves clinging to your skin.
“Well,” you said, brushing soaked hair from your eyes, “at least we don’t have to pretend to like the view anymore.”
Abby let out a sharp exhale — maybe a laugh, maybe just annoyance. She pulled off her backpack and set it down between you.
“We’re not moving until this slows down,” she said.
“No shit,” you muttered, crouching.
Minutes passed. Then more.
The silence stretched, punctuated only by thunder and the slow drip of water through rust holes above. You didn’t look at her. You were too aware of how close she was. Of the way her knees brushed yours when she shifted. Of the steam rising off her skin.
Eventually, she broke it.
“You always this reckless?”
You turned your head slowly. “You always this judgmental?”
“I meant it,” she said. “Back in the nest. I’m not your enemy.”
The words surprised you both. But they were true.
You looked down at your hands. Mud under your nails. Scar on your thumb. A tremble in your fingers that wasn’t from the cold.
“I just don’t like losing,” you added, quieter this time.
Abby studied you. “Neither do I.”
And there it was again — that tension. Not anger. Not even rivalry.
Just heat. Like you’d been circling something dangerous without naming it.
Outside, lightning flashed. A jagged line across the grey.
Inside, something cracked open.
And this time, neither of you looked away.
The rain didn’t let up. Not really. Just softened into a steady drizzle by the time you headed back. Everything squelched. Your boots. Her boots. The path. The space between you.
You should’ve said something.
But what the hell would you even say?
That you kept catching yourself staring? That her voice stuck in your chest like a splinter you couldn’t dig out? That you didn’t just want to win anymore — you wanted her to see you.
The thought made you angrier than it should’ve.
Back at camp, the world was dim with dusk and mist. You split without speaking, without looking. Abby peeled off toward the barracks. You went straight for the showers.
Like you could wash off the way she looked at you.
The way your skin burned under it.
Later that night, you found her in the common room. Hood up. Elbows on knees. Staring into a fire that had long since gone to embers.
You didn’t know why you walked in.
Didn’t know why you sat beside her.
Neither of you spoke for a long time.
Finally, she said, “You always got something to prove?”
You stiffened. “You always gotta ask questions with knives in ‘em?”
She didn’t laugh. Just leaned back against the bench.
“I used to think being strong was the same as being right,” she said.
You turned to her. “And now?”
She looked at you then — not just glanced. Really looked.
“Now I think being right doesn’t mean much when no one wants to stand next to you.”
“I don’t hate you, you know,” you said, quieter than you meant.
“Yeah,” Abby said. “I know.”
She didn’t say anything else.
Because the space between you wasn’t empty anymore.
And maybe, just maybe, that was enough — for now.
Not just in combat — though she moved like she had something to prove, something to outrun. No, she was fast in every way that mattered. With comebacks. With fury. With the way her eyes flashed like a struck match every time she turned them on Abby.
Abby told herself it was annoying.
That twitch in her gut? Just adrenaline. Old habits. A leftover instinct to win.
But she kept watching. Kept cataloguing the curve of her lip when she smirked, the stubborn set of her jaw, the way her fingers always flexed twice before throwing a knife — like it was muscle memory, or a tick she didn’t know she had.
And that meant something dangerous was creeping in.
Abby leaned against the doorframe of the armory that night, fingers tapping absently against the edge of the holster strapped to her thigh. She watched the flicker of firelight across the campyard. She knew she should sleep.
But her body was still humming. From the patrol. From the rain. From her.
She’d been close enough to smell her shampoo — citrus and gunpowder — and it had done something stupid to Abby’s brain.
It wasn’t supposed to be like this.
She’d spent years sharpening herself into something unflinching. Something built. But this? This was messy. Sharp in the wrong ways. A thousand tiny cuts instead of one clean break.
She didn’t even know when it started.
Maybe it was the second time they sparred. Maybe it was the blood on her lip. The grin she gave Abby after she hit the mat. Or maybe it was earlier than that — when she first heard her laugh. Harsh and honest. Like she wasn’t trying to sound pretty, just real.
But she wanted it anyway.
But when she said it, and saw how the girl looked at her — chin up, eyes hard, like she’d rather die than be seen soft — Abby knew it wasn’t going to be that simple.
Because the truth was, she liked her.
She respected her. Feared her a little, even — not for what she was capable of, but for what she made Abby feel. She was sharp and bright and unforgiving, and every time they talked, it felt like standing too close to a fire she had no business warming her hands by.
Abby clenched her jaw, swallowed thickly, and stared at the flame in the distance.
No one warned her that wanting something could hurt more than losing it.
Because wanting her felt like grinding glass between her teeth and pretending it was sugar.
And still — Abby couldn’t stop coming back.
The dawn crept softly over the compound, casting pale gold across dew-slick grass and weathered wood. The world was quiet except for the distant crow of a crow and the steady rhythm of your own breath, puffing out in little clouds of white. You stood near the edge of the barracks, fingers twitching with nerves that felt alive beneath your skin.
Abby came into view from behind a rusted fence, her tall frame outlined by the early light. The damp strands of hair stuck to her neck, and the scar above her brow caught the glow, making it look almost like a silver slash. Her eyes, sharp and guarded as always, locked on yours. There was a softness there this time — a flicker of something almost shy.
“You’re up early,” she said, voice low and rough around the edges.
You shifted your weight, stepping forward a little, daring to close the distance you’d been circling for weeks. “Didn’t want to miss the sunrise,” you replied, your voice quieter than you expected.
Abby glanced up at the sky, streaked with pale pink and lavender clouds, then back at you, lips quirking with a small, knowing smile. “Figures. Always trying to catch something before it slips away.”
The space between you was charged, the cold air suddenly thick with heat and possibility. You could smell the faint tang of citrus soap mixed with earth and something distinctly her — sharp and grounding.
Your fingers itched to reach out, to touch that scar or catch a stray curl behind her ear. Instead, you swallowed the lump in your throat and spoke, “I’ve been thinking.”
Abby’s brow quirked. “That’s dangerous.”
You grinned, a little breathless. “Maybe. But sometimes, it’s worth the risk.”
She took a step closer, narrowing the gap until you could see every shade of green and gold in her eyes. Your pulse hammered in your ears.
“I don’t want to fight anymore,” you admitted, voice steady but vulnerable. “Not with you. Not over this.”
Her gaze softened, vulnerability cracking the edges of her usual tough facade. “Neither do I.”
You looked down for a second, nerves twisting your gut. Then, slowly, you reached out, brushing a loose strand of hair behind her ear. Your fingertips lingered against the rough skin of her cheek.
She leaned into your touch, eyes fluttering closed for a moment.
“I don’t want it to be complicated,” you said, voice barely above a whisper. “Just… us.”
Abby swallowed, voice low and sincere. “Yeah. Just us.”
The silence between you was fragile and electric, stretched taut like a held breath.
Carefully, you closed the last few inches, lips meeting hers in a slow, tentative kiss — like tasting something fragile and precious for the first time. Her arms wrapped around your waist, pulling you closer, the warmth of her body chasing away the morning chill.
When you pulled apart, breaths mingling, her smile was radiant and unguarded.
“Guess I’m glad you’re not my enemy,” she teased softly.
You laughed, heart light and full. “Maybe we’re better than that.”
The camp came to life around you—slow, quiet. Birds chirped, and distant voices floated through the mist. But you felt like you were in your own little world with Abby, fingers intertwined, sharing small smiles and gentle touches that said more than words.
At breakfast, she swiped a piece of your bread when you weren’t looking, flashing a mischievous grin.
“You’re lucky I’m too tired to chase you down,” she joked, voice playful but warm.
You smirked. “I’ll take my chances.”
Later, near the cracked training grounds where your rivalry first ignited, Abby pulled a knife from her belt and tossed it with effortless precision — the blade sinking dead center into the weathered target.
“Your turn,” she said, eyes glinting with challenge and something softer.
You took the knife she offered, feeling the familiar weight settle in your palm. Breathing steady, you aimed carefully, muscles tense but sure. The blade thudded into the target just a hair off center.
Abby clapped softly, eyes bright with pride. “Not bad.”
You grinned, feeling a rush that wasn’t about winning anymore — it was about this, about her.
She stepped closer, fingers brushing yours in a casual, electrifying touch.
You nodded, heart pounding with a mix of nerves and joy.
The sun climbed higher, warming your skin, the earth around you glowing with new light. The walls you’d built around yourselves cracked open just enough to let something real slip through — something tender and fierce all at once.
You paused, breath hitching as Abby reached out to tuck a stray curl behind your ear, her hand lingering against your cheek like she didn’t want to let go. Her eyes searched yours, full of unspoken promises and quiet strength.
“You’re not so bad,” she murmured, a teasing smile curling at her lips.
You laughed softly, brushing your thumb over her scar with reverence. “Takes one to know one.”
She leaned in, voice dropping to a serious whisper. “We’ve both been fighting for so long. Maybe it’s time we stop.”
You nodded, heart full and steady. “Together.”
Abby’s grin softened, and she pulled you into another kiss — deeper, warmer, and brimming with all the things you’d both been too scared to say.
When you finally parted, her forehead rested against yours, breath mingling.
“No more enemies,” she whispered.
“No more fighting,” you agreed.
You wrapped your arms around her, holding her close as the morning light bathed you both in gentle gold.
For the first time in a long time, you believed it was real.