Murder on the Orient Express
Sam and Cait call each other partner in crime. It just dawned on me how fitting it is.
Iād been travelling during new yearās but following proceedings. I havenāt commented at all as I was gathering my thoughts. I was coming to terms with this engagement before GG and wrote a piece which I planned to post after the confirmation. It was meant to be a fair criticism of Cait (and Sam indirectly) and now that I re-read it, it was more or less that. But my feelings have changed. The confirmation, how it was done and what followed have added resentment to my feelings but also understanding of the ordeal.
Maybe Iām going through the anger phase which is clouding my judgment. I donāt know. However, Iām gonna put it down anyway for my own catharsis.
I donāt think there should be any argument now about how Sam and Caitās words donāt match their actions. Itās this mystery, push and pull that got shippers in so deep. This is a community of intelligent people, and intelligent people ask questions and seek answers. Maybe shippers are too smart for their own good.
So hereās how Iām making sense of this whole fuckery. Thereās no way it can be pretty but itās uglier than Iād thought it would be. It doesnāt explain everything. But Iām going with it anyway.
Sam and Cait have amazing on and off screen chemistry. They are good friends. They hit it right off. Those are canons. Starz, Sony and they themselves realised they had struck gold. So theyāre using that chemistry to sell the show and increase their own popularity, to great effect.
They flirted up a storm in person and on SM, fooling everyone including fans and media, and maybe even a part of themselves, in 2014-2015. It was the heyday, the honeymoon, until shippers, a wave of shippers emerged and became a powerful voice in the fandom.
Things got so out of hand to the point that a serious denial was needed. They had personal lives to live and SamCait as a couple had eclipsed the show. Hence the IFH. However, a complete distancing wouldnāt do. The show and their own Q scores or what not depended on SM buzz especially during Droughtlander.Ā
What to do? All three partiesāthe show, Sam and Caitā needed the flirty banter but not the speculation that comes with it. Enter Skipper as distraction. And once Shitner and sidekick got wind of the situation they were all too eager to help. They probably didnāt realise their ulterior motives and Nazi methods at the time. But well.
I donāt know about Sam but Cait obviously does have an SO all along. Thanks to the queen anti troll, details about Tony McGill emerged quickly. Thanks to the fakeness of Skipper, shippers considered him pretty much the same thing. Until now.
Cait has to get married eventually. She probably hates that Aussie gossip to the bone as the woman must have ruined her plans on how she was going to do this reveal. Maybe she didnāt plan to do it during GG at all. Itās not important now.
The problem is, actions have consequences. The name McGill was first leaked by his friend, an ex-reporter in Dec 2014. That means Cait mustāve started dating him before. This timeline puts her behaviour with Sam in 2014-2015 highly questionable. I wasnāt in the fandom but I know SDCC 2015 to be a milestone in shipper history. I fully believe the shipper who saw Sam and Cait kissing near the escalator. How they were with each other at panels and interviews were seen not just by fans but also media and industry people. Thatās why now Cait has to fudge her dating timeline to 2 years.
Fudging it wonāt work for fans who have followed closely. But it doesnāt matter as the media would buy it. At least even KDS bought it. It also gives them the option to say Sam and Cait were together in 2015 but broke up, if push comes to shove.
Itās Murder on the Orient Express. Everyone had a hand. Even shippers. As I mentioned before, shippers are probably too smart for their own good. Oddities were quickly pointed out and analysed. I remember clearly how the concept of Q scores were explained by those in the industry and it applied nicely to how every time shit hit the fan, cute selfies and banters followed. However, what we have failed to do is to see the motives clearly without the romantic filter. We thought they were rebellions on the part of Sam and Cait. Turns out it was damage control, and damage control only.
Now that Tony and Cait are People official, Sam and Cait are free to banter and flirt to their heartsā content. And we have seen the beginning of it already. They may be more careful with their words, but they will keep going.
Cait harping on #bestfans contributed to my conclusion here. She knows sheās losing fans somewhere and overcompensating. And I can even explain the cold behaviour between Tony and her at events this way:Ā They avoid showing PDA because while his presence is needed, they donāt want loved up visuals of him and Cait in mainstream media. They donāt want the image of real life Frank blasted to the international audience on TV at Golden Globes. Being the meek and obedient type, he played it cool but heās no actor and ended up looking like he was afraid of even looking at his fiancĆ©. Cait was sheepish about her ring (and even chose to downplay it with a bigger bling on the other hand), and mortified by a potential engagement question because of all the baggage, not privacyĀ which is sounding funnier by the minute.
What Iāve described here does not preclude some sort of romantic involvement between Sam and Cait at some point. Human beings are weak and fluid, and they have shown that theyāre very capable of making bad decisions just like everyone else. I donāt think theyāre bad people. I think if I ever meet them Iād probably find them nice and normal, but theyāre also in a cutthroat industry where theyāre trying desperately to succeed after years of struggling. Unfortunately, shippers, the exact group of fans who have been such a big part of their success, are now collateral damage.
As an aside, I think my perception of her engagement ring sums up my own fantasied idea of her. I was really surprised that it was so conventional. For someone who have donned the most exquisite designer gear for years, Iād thought sheād at least go to a boutique jeweller to have it custom made. Or vintage from an auction. Or do away with a diamond completely. This is just like her choice of man. Of course sheās free to choose. Iāve no business with it. I chose to see her through rose coloured glasses so I admit my own hand in this.Ā
Iām part of the Murder on the Orient Express. However, it does not excuse their own behaviour one bit. Like me, they have to take responsibility but I wonāt be seeing it.
As @cb4tb so brilliantly put it in her post, which I agree completely, my sadness about this is a giantĀ āwhat a shameā, indeed.