♡ Bummie’s Little Freak ♡

It all happened super fast. They crashed against the counter, throwing down several glasses, beating and smashing each other before slamming into a table, Jared knocking Logan to the floor. I was on my feet rushing to them as Jared punched him in the face before John forced his elbow in Jared's stomach and rolled them around, now on top of him. “STOP IT!” I yelled desperately trying to get a hold of Logan. His fist collided with Jared's nose, followed by a cracking sound. Several other people came to help me separate these two. Two guys were holding Logan back as I stepped in front of him. He was not listening, eyes locked on Jared, thrashing around, wanting to free himself. Gripping the collar of his flannel  in a last attempt I jerked his head down to look at me. “That’s enough!” His gaze finally found mine, but there was still a wild fire burning in his eyes. “Please stop.” I pleaded, bottom lip wobbling. His movements ceased, eyes softening. When he was completely still, breathing slowing down the guys let go of him, giving me a questioning look, I nodded assuringly. “I got it, thank you.” John's eyes stayed on me the whole time. I spoke with Della, explaining what happened and that I would cover the expanse of the broken glasses. Jared sat in a booth with an ice pack for his nose, telling his side of the story to her whilst I sat John down in a chair, checking him for injuries. Putting an end to my fussing, he spoke for the first time since the fight broke out. 

“I’m good.”

“Your jaw is bruised.” I said concerned, fingertips carefully tracing the darkening skin.

“Nothing I can't handle.” He murmured and got a hold of my hand.

He pulled it down, but didn't let go just yet. 

“Are you okay?” There was a seriousness in his eyes, as he scanned my face quickly. 

“I wasn't the one who got punched.” I tried to lighten the mood when Della came over again.

She told us to go home, several other people having confirmed that Jared was harassing me and had started the fight, making him responsible for the damage. I thanked her profoundly and grabbed John's hand without thinking about it. We left Malone’s in silence, walking to his truck. It was when we were already driving that I started questioning why I even went with him. I shifted uncomfortably in my seat. Sensing my discomfort he pulled over, stopping the car.

We sat together in silence, neither of us willing to make the first move. His grip on the steering wheel tightened, knuckles turning white. Seeing how tense he was, I swallowed my unease, this whole thing had to end. We couldn't keep going on like that. With my gaze fixed straight ahead, I looked down the dark street. “Thank you for sticking up for me.” He was uncharacteristically quiet as he mumbled “Always.” After another beat of silence, I saw from the corner of my eyes how he loosened his grip and let his hands fall into his lap. John took a long breath, steeling himself.

“I missed you.”

“Its only been a few days.” I mumble, downplaying the whole thing. “Nearly a week.” He tilted his head looking at my profile.

“I didn't want to fight anymore.”

“We do that a lot recently.” He acknowledged, though there was a certain weariness in his voice. I hummed, eyes dropping in my lap, fingers playing with a loose string on my skirt. Maybe now is the time to get it all out.  My eyes flicked to his face before settling back on my hands. “I have been in love with you for months.” I laughed humorlessly, lips twisting in a cynical smirk. “I was delusional enough that I thought I had a real chance.” Shaking my head in slow motion, I felt the now familiar sting in my eyes promising tears. “I am sorry that I ruined this friendship because I couldn't keep it in my pants.” I closed my eyes, feeling my heart clench painfully in my chest. That's the ugly truth, it was all my fault. Selfish brat.

“Thats not true Y/N.” I shook my head again. I didn't want him to console me. His hand settled on mine, drawing my gaze to him. “I ruined everything by being a spineless coward, afraid of his own feelings.” I furrowed my brows in confusion. The corner of his lips twitch, in a sad attempt to smile. “Turning you down that night was sooo fucking hard for me.” He swallowed. “I have wanted you since the first time we met.” It was like my head emptied itself leaving only white noise. “You are so pretty- No scratch that, you are smoking hot, which is also the reason your two protectors declared to the whole athletics department that if anyone of us even thought about touching you we would be six feet under.” I blinked sluggishly, my synapses working feverishly to make sense of what he had just said. It was clear that he meant Beau and Dean but- they wouldn't. Remembering the last week my hands clenched. I felt red, hot, anger flare inside my veins. They would. They did! Logan rubbed his neck sheepishly “So I kept my distance but you were around almost every day, hanging at the house. Looking gorgeous, making jokes with the guys, beating Tucker in Mario Kart, just lazily invading my space and mind.” His hand, which was still on top of mine shifted, fingers intertwining with mine. “Beeing your friend was the most masochist thing I ever did.” Huffing he squeezed my hand. “You drove me nuts.” Licking my lips, I carefully asked “But you never did or said anything because of some stupid hands off speech from the boys?” A mournful smile graced his handsome face, eyes turning downwards. “You're basically Dean's sister. A good Bro would never go for a friends sister.” 

Man are the dumbest creatures on gods green earth. I moved to detangle my hand from his but John wouldn't let me. “I know it is stupid and I am so so sorry for how poorly I handled your advances.” I sensed there was going to be a but as his dark eyes tried to pull me back in with a pleading look. 

“You were absolutely shitfaced that night. Even if Dean would not have promised to castrate me, there was no way I would take advantage of you like that. Never.” 

“So telling me we're just friends and to give you space was your version of looking out for me?” My tone turned sharper, eyes narrowing. 

“You were throwing yourself at me looking so fucking georguse.” He bit his lip. “My mind didn't work properly. The level of restraint I showed that night should be studied, okay.”

“Restrain.” I uttered in disbelief. “You crushed my whole self esteem, breaking my heart in the process and all you have to say is how hard you had to restrain yourself ?!”

Cringing, he cursed under his breath. “Okay, I am really bad with words, Sweetheart. So let me get this off my chest before I dig my grave any deeper.” His free hand rose to gently grab my chin, making sure I was looking at him. 

“I fucking love you.” My eyes widened, my heart stuttering. He didn't just say-.

“What?” I hushed breathlessly.

“I can't stop thinking about you. Day, night, even in the middle of fucking practice all there is is you.” His thumb was stroking my cheek tenderly. 

“You have a funny way of showing that.” I muttered, my throat closing up. Furrowing my brows i was confused. He just told me he couldn't make a move because of Bro Code but then he proclaims that he lo-..that he likes me. It didn't make any sense to me. Was this some fucked up prak? No. He may have crushed my heart but he wouldn't be that cruel.

“What about the dynamic duo?” I rasped, searching his eyes for the truth. He huffed irritated “Fuck ‘em.” Arching a brow I felt a treacherous tug at the corner of my mouth. Clocking it his own lips stretched into a hopeful little smile. “They messed this up enough as it is. I just want you to be happy again and if by any chance I can be part of that-” He didn't finish his sentence, instead giving me a meaningful look. My heart swelled, warmth pooling in my stomach. Okay, that's wholesome. I didn't know he could be this sweet. I felt my head move in a soft nod before I even made a concise choice. John's eyes followed the movement, eyes lighting up when he realised what that meant. “I’d like you to.” I shyly confirmed. Pulling my bottom lip between my teeth nervously, I waited unsure what now. But judging by the way his face progressively grew closer to mine he knew what to do now.

My eyes dropped to his slightly parted lips. Heart beat skyrocketing, as his tongue peeked out to wet his lips, I made a soft sound. Gaze flicking to mine, I noticed how his pupils dilated. “This okay?” He murmured with a suddenly gravell voice. “Yeah.” I whispered, moving closer so that the tip of my nose nudged his affectionately. John took a heavy breath before brushing his lips against mine. It was like an electric current shot through me, urging me to press my lips harder against his. His hand still cradling my face, moved to my hair as his lips moved hungrily with mine. Moving my hand up his broad shoulders, I buried my fingers in the hair at his nape. A low groan rumbled through his chest, his other hand grabbing my waist to pull me closer. Deepening the kiss I licked over his bottom lip. He opened his mouth eagerly, tongue darting out to tangle with mine. God he tastes amazing! I couldn't get enough of him, already drunk on his taste. As his hand slid from my waist to grab a handful of my ass a shamefully loud moan erupted from deep within me. Surprising even me. He pulled back, chest heaving, eyes blown wide. He swallowed breathlessly, thump moving over my swollen bottom lip. “Perfect.” He mumbled huskily.

Puls racing and brain fogged i leaned over and started kissing the side of his jaw that was not bruised. Seductively pressing open mouth kisses down his neck electing a breathy moan from him. “God I hate myself, but you got a stop gorgeous.” Johns hand softly grab my shoulders, halting my movements. Looking up, I couldn't mask the fear in my eyes having déjà vu. “Oh no, no, not like that baby. I swear I am totally into this, into you.” He is quick to reassure me, pulling my face against his chest, chin resting on my head. “But if you keep making those sweet sounds, I am gonna ruin my pants.” He sounded so serious about it that I had to stifle the laugh bubbling up. “Hey, that's not funny okay.”

“Who said you had to come in your pants?” I asked, feigning innocence. His grip on me tightened. He swore under his breath “You're killing me here sweetheart.” He gave me little kisses on the crown of my hair. “When i fuck you for the first time, it's not gonna be in my truck.” Heat bloomed on my face, heartbeat rushing straight to my core. He can't  just say that so casually. Wriggling out of his embrace, I cleared my throat and slid back into my seat. “Well then we should get going.” I tried to say casually, voice betraying me by cracking at the end. Logan swiftly leaned over and stole one last kiss before moving back behind the wheel and starting the motor. “Yes ma’m.” Glazing at him from the corner of my eyes I saw the big grin on his face. It was like the sun had risen. Meanwhile i was mentally going crazy. I just made out with John Logan, in his truck after he told me he lov-liked me. Somebody pinch me!  

Whilst driving he laid his free hand on mine, thumb moving in idly circles on my skin. I was so lost in the moment I violently jerked back when my ringtone split the comfortable silence between us. “Jeez.” Clutching one had against my chest, willing my heart to slow down the other fished my phone out of my jacket pocket. Logan chuckled amused beside me, throwing his blinker on to turn left. Facing my phone I saw Dean's name flash across the display. Okay, act normal. I briefed myself before answering the call.

 “Hey wha-”

“Are you hurt? Where are you?” Dean practically yells into the speaker.

“Hello to you too.” I said, moving the phone a bit away from my ear. 

“Hannah called Garrett, said some creep tried to harass you?” Sighing, I pinched the bridge of my nose. Of course. BUT he didn't mention Logan so I saw that as a good sign, maybe I didn't have to murder Hannah. “I am fine Dean. Promis.” John sat up straighter hearing his friend's name. 

“Where are you? I will come get you.”

“I said I'm fine and I am already on my way home.”

“Alone?! Where are you?.” 

“I didn't say that. A fri-.” I stopped. We are technically not friends anymore right? Logan's gaze swiped to me before focusing back on the road.

“Listen everything is alright okay? I am nearly home so you can calm down.” 

“Ducky-.”

“I will talk with you tomorrow. Night D.” I ended the call before he could continue to stress about his. 

“So Dean’s heard about the fight?” We turned the last corner, reaching my dorm.

“Kinda, he heard I had trouble with some guy. Didn’t say a word about murdering you so i think you're fine.”  I shrugged, reaching to unbuckle my seatbelt. 

“I don't plan on keeping you a secret Y/N.” He turned the motor off.

“John.” I hesitated, unsure what this even was. 

“I want us to be official and all that shit.” 

“You- Really?” 

“What did you think? That I declare my undying love before every hook up?” He asked sarcastically, raising a brow.

Suddenly feeling dumb, I lowered my gaze unexpectedly interested in the floormats.

“I wasn't sure, you don't really do girlfriends.”

“I didn't do girlfriends, that's right. But that was before you.” I looked back up.

“Sooo no more puck bunnies?” 

“None.”

“Just us. Exclusively?" 

“As exclusive as it gets, I am all yours baby.” 

Grabbing him by his collar I pulled him in, smashing my lips against his. After a searing hot kiss I pulled myself away from his lips with great effort. “I’d like to be your girlfriend.”

“You didn't really have a choice.” He smirked smugly, winking at me. Scoffing, I playfully shoved his shoulder. “Too late for that macho shit, I know you're a softy.” I chuckle, pecking his lips. Gazing at me, with a dreamy smile he pushed a strand of hair from my face “Only for you gorgeous.”

note: i may or may not do a part two, my motivation fluctuates! hope you enjoy because this was super sad to write.

He’s looking at her.

His arm rests along the back of the couch, the sensation of it familiar enough that you barely notice it anymore. Every few minutes, when someone says something particularly funny, his hand shifts and his fingers brush against the exposed skin of your shoulder blade. It’s casual, absent-minded contact. It means nothing to him and everything to you.

Around you, the boys’ house is lively. Tucker is arguing with Birdie about the game they’ve been at for hours on the TV. Every once in a while, someone tells them to shut up. They do that for a total of five minutes before someone inevitably raises their voice, leading the other to do the same.

You should be finishing up your story. It was a stupid tale, one about falling asleep during a lecture.

Instead, you’re watching him.

Or rather, you’re watching where he’s looking.

His gaze drifts across the room so often that you’ve begun anticipating it, finding yourself following the path before he’s even finished turning his head. It happens during conversations. During periods of silence. During moments when he’s supposed to be paying attention you.

His eyes always find the same person.

You wonder if anyone else notices.

Maybe they don’t. Maybe they haven’t spent nearly ten years studying every version of John Logan.

Ten years.

Long enough to remember the cracked sidewalks of your hometown and the suffocating certainty that neither of you belonged there. Long enough to remember sitting on the roof of his garage at thirteen years old, passing back and forth what was always bag of Hot Cheetos while making promises far too big for kids your age.

You had been determined to leave.

And somehow, against every odd stacked against two middle-schoolers with seemingly unattainable dreams and no real plan, you did.

You earned your place through a STEM scholarship that had consumed countless nights and enough caffeine to raise alerts towards your cardiovascular system. He earned his through hockey, through early mornings and bruises and a relentless dedication that you supported him all throughout.

Different roads, same destination.

For nearly a decade, the two of you had existed side by side.

And for six of those years, you’ve loved him.

You weren’t sure when you realized it, but once you did, it felt as though things finally clicked into place. There had always been that speculation from others that you two were something beyond a mere friendship—but there was no weight to it. Not while it wasn’t true, anyway.

You thought it may have been the puberty. John was no longer a scrawny kid who you hovered over. He’d grown into himself as the years passed—taller, stronger, more confident. It was a simple crush that came as a result of change, you told yourself.

But you had began to think it was more than that, that it always had been. Once the feeling arrived, it made no effort to fade—settling into the empty spaces between inside jokes and late-night phone calls, between shared victories and devastating failures. It lodged itself so deeply within your bond that you stopped looking for where friendship ended and something else began.

Maybe that was your mistake.

Across the room, Hannah laughs.

The sound is soft enough that most people would miss it beneath the chatter, but John hears it.

Of course he does.

Hannah Wells has a way of drawing attention effortlessly. Her smile comes easily, brightening her entire face like a Christmas tree. Honey-brown hair spills over one shoulder as she speaks. Her deep cerulean eyes crinkle when she laughs. Hearing her sing for the first time made it no better.

And she is so kind.

She remembers your birthday, she asks you questions on a subject you think had long been over. She makes you feel seen.

It’s impossible to blame him for looking.

The problem is that lately, he hasn’t seemed capable of looking anywhere else.

His fingers brush your shoulder again, mindlessly.

Across the room, Hannah says something to Allie that you can’t quite make out.

Logan smiles.

And suddenly, despite his arm around you and his knee pressed lightly against yours and nearly ten years of friendship sitting comfortably between the two of you, you’ve never felt further away from him.

Tucker notices your shift in mood before Logan does. You like Tuck the most out of all of Logan’s friends. He’s a year below the rest of you, though you like to say he’s the most mature out of all of them. He’s observant, you learned.

He tilts his head at you, silently asking if you’re okay. You send him a half-hearted thumbs up. Something clicks for him and he accepts your answer, redirecting his attention to the game.

You think Tucker knows about your crush on John. A part of you hopes he doesn’t, but another part of you knows that he does.

At some point, Logan notices you’ve stopped talking. By the time he has, you’re fiddling with your bracelet. He frowns, glancing at his own matching one on his left wrist. You were both surprised they had never broken. Logan enjoyed referring to it as a testament to your long-standing friendship. The blue and purple embroidery of both your bracelets have become a halo of fuzz, but they remain intact nonetheless.

Logan glances back at you, studying you once again—knit eyebrows, lip tucked between your teeth. You’re upset.

“What’s wrong?”

You meet his doe eyed gaze and hate yourself for thinking about drowning in them. He knows you as well as you know him. So much so that you can’t lie and pretend you’re okay. He’s read you and he’s decided that you’re not.

So you do the next best thing.

“It’s just stuffy in here,” you reply passively, maintaining a poker face when you push off the couch and his fingertips leave your shoulder blades. “I’m gonna get some air.”

The cool evening air hits you the second the front door clicks shut, but it does nothing to clear the sudden suffocating weight in your chest. You walk over to the edge of the porch, gripping the wooden railing just to have something solid to hold onto.

Behind you, the front door opens and shuts. Familiar footsteps thud against the wood. You don’t need to turn around to know it’s him, you’d know the specific cadence of his stride anywhere.

"Hey," Logan says softly, stepping up beside you, jacket in his hand. He leans his forearms against the railing, his large frame blocking out the slight breeze. "You left your jacket inside. It’s freezing out here."

You make no effort to retrieve the coat from his grasp. You don’t look even at him. Instead, your eyes fixate on a tiny, industrious spider crawling across the top of a plastic patio chair a few feet away. It is small, frantic, and entirely unaware of the shifting plates of your universe, completely consumed by the monumental task of weaving a web between two cheap slats of faux-wicker. You envy it. You want to be anything else—a spider, a piece of dust, a thread on your frayed bracelet—anything but the girl standing under the porch light, slowly unraveling.

"I'm fine," you tell him, the words slipping out easily, rehearsed from a decade of practice.

"You're not fine," he insists softly. It’s not an accusation. It’s a statement of fact.

"I am fine," you repeat, but your voice is uneven.

You always are, somehow. It’s a reflex by now. Burn the midnight oil until your vision blurs, crash through exams on three hours of sleep, watch the boy you’ve loved for six years slip through your fingers like water—the answer is always the same: I’m fine.

"Don't do that," Logan mutters, turning his head to look at you. His eyes are swimming with an earnest yet frustrating concern that always makes you want to spill your guts. "We don't do that. Talk to me. Did someone say something inside? Did I do something?"

You let out a breath that cuts like a laugh, though there’s no humor in it. You look out at the dark front yard, at the dead leaves scattering across the pavement.

You finally turn your head to look at him. You note the exact way the yellow porch light catches the bridge of his nose, the slight shadow of stubble along his jawline. You know every iteration of this face. You know the childhood version, the teenage version, and this current, devastatingly handsome collegiate version.

And yet, looking at him right now, he feels like a stranger wearing your best friend's skin.

"That's just it, Logan. You haven't done anything." Your voice drops, stripped of its usual warmth. "You haven't been doing anything. Not with me, anyway."

He blinks, a small, defensive crease forming between his eyebrows. "I don’t understand.”

“I know you don’t,” you murmur.

“Then explain it to me.”

"It means you’re pulling away," you say directly, the words tasting like copper in your mouth, but you force them out anyway. You don't mention Hannah. You don't have to bring up the way his eyes track her, or the way his laugh sounds higher when she’s in the room. This isn't about her. This is about him. This is about the space where your best friend used to be. "You’re always somewhere else. I talk to you, and it’s like I’m throwing words into an empty room. You look right through me lately. You’re right here, and it feels like there’s a thousand miles between us."

Logan stiffens. For a second, his mouth opens to deny it, the knee-jerk reaction of a guy who prides himself on being loyal. But as he looks at you—at the tight line of your jaw, at the way you're holding onto your own arm like you’re trying to keep yourself from falling apart—you can see the fight slowly leave him.

The silence stretches, punctuated only by the joyous yells of your friends inside.

"I didn't. . .” Logan starts, his voice dropping an octave. He rubs a hand over the back of his neck, looking down at his shoes. "I didn't realize I was making you feel like that. I swear to God, I didn't."

"Well, you are." Your voice trembles just a fraction, and you hate yourself for it, pulling your shoulders back to overcompensate. "I know that friends drift. But I don’t wanna be background noise in your life.”

Logan steps closer, closing the small physical gap between you. He reaches out, his large hand wrapping around your forearm—right over the frayed threads of your bracelet. You pray he doesn’t notice the hitching of your breath.

"You're not background noise," he says sincerely, his desperate eyes searching yours. "You could never be. I'm sorry. Seriously. I've had. . . I’ve just had a lot on my mind lately, and I’ve been distracted. I’ve been a shitty best friend, and there’s no excuse for it. I’m so sorry."

You look at his hand on your arm. You look at the genuine regret pulling at the corners of his eyes. He doesn't know that the distraction is killing you for an entirely different reason. He just knows he hurt his person, and he wants to fix it.

You swallow the ache in your throat, nodding slowly. You let the anger go, because holding onto it hurts worse than forgiving him does.

"It’s okay," you assure him. "Just don’t forget about me, dork.”

"Never," he promises, squeezing your arm before letting go. A small, relieved smile tugs at his lips, the tension leaving his shoulders. He makes no effort to back away from you. It’s all the more suffocating. "I promise. Hey, you still have that big winter showcase coming up in two weeks, right? For your department?"

"Yeah," you say, a genuine spark of nervousness lighting up your stomach. "It’s the Friday after this upcoming one."

"I'll be there," Logan says instantly, his voice full of the certainty that usually makes you feel safe. "Front row. I'll even wear a stupid button-down shirt so your professors think I'm respectable. Deal?"

You look at him, wanting so badly to trust the boy who used to share bags of Hot Cheetos on a garage roof.

"Deal," you agree.

The fluorescent lights of the auditorium are blinding. It is 5:30PM. The STEM showcase had officially kicked off at five, the culmination of sleepless semesters, data sheets that blurred into meaningless code by three in the morning, and enough stress to permanently alter your brain chemistry.

Your phone sits completely dark and powered down in the bottom of your tote bag. You hadn't sent Logan a reminder text today. You hadn’t wanted to seem needy, and besides, you figured he’d remember.

He knew what this meant to you. He’d been the one to hold you on the floor of your bedroom a week ago ago when the overthinking caught up to you, his large hands rubbing slow circles into your back while you sobbed into his chest, terrified that it wouldn’t be enough. He’d promised then, just like he’d promised on the porch, that he’d be here.

Last night, you had even swung by the hockey house, your presentation slides printed out and shaking in your hands, just looking for a final bit of reassurance to quiet the jitters. But Logan wasn't there. He’d been at Malone’s, helping Hannah setup tables and banners for the upcoming weekend showcase she offered to host for music majors.

It was fine, you told yourself. It really was. He was trying to be better, and you could see the effort. The crush was still a persistent ache in your ribs, but he hadn't let it bleed into your friendship the way he had before. You understood what it was like to be at someone’s beck and call—hell, you’d been at his for six years. You couldn't blame him for falling under Hannah’s gravitational pull.

Logan hadn't been there last night, but Tucker had.

Tucker had stopped chopping vegetables, wiped his hands on a dish towel, and sat you down at the kitchen island. He listened to you stumble through your abstract, giving you a supportive nod when you finished. When you told Tucker he didn't have to worry about coming tomorrow since it was so last minute and Logan would be there anyway, Tucker had just given you an easy smile.

“Then you’ll have two of us cheering you on," he’d promised.

Now, standing by your trifold and your laptop, the nerves are a sickening weight in your stomach. You’ve just finished presenting to the final round of judges. Your mouth is dry, your throat tight, but you’d gotten through it just fine.

Tucker had slipped into the back of the room right before your time slot, his broad shoulders cutting a reassuring silhouette against the crowded aisle. Seeing his familiar face had kept your knees from buckling.

But Logan’s seat in the front row—the one he’d promised to occupy in a stupid button-down shirt—remained completely empty.

It hurts. A sharp, localized sting right beneath your breastbone. You hadn't told anyone else in your life about the showcase because public speaking made you feel entirely naked, meaning Logan and Tucker were your only safety nets.

Everyone else would most likely be at Malone’s. You didn’t want them to choose between you and Hannah, because you knew they’d try to compromise, complicating things. You didn’t want a whole crowd, you were okay with just one person being there.

But you swallow the lump in your throat and smooth down the fabric of your slacks. It’s fine. Logan probably just got caught in campus traffic, or he had a handyman gig that kept him late. He missed the actual presentation, yeah, but there’s still time. The showcase goes until eight.

As long as he shows up before the winners are announced, it’ll be fine. He’ll still be there to celebrate with you. He has to be.

Two hours later, the auditorium is a blur of echoing applause and bright flashing cameras.

When the department head speaks your name into the microphone, announcing you as the first-place recipient of the showcase, the room erupts. Your peers are cheering, clapping you on the back as you walk up the stage, but the sound feels like it’s happening underwater.

Even the heavy glass they hang around your neck and the oversized novelty check—grant money that will entirely fund your next semester of research—do nothing to lift the leaden weight in your chest.

Tucker maneuvers through the crowd as soon as you’ve left the stage, a massive, proud smile lighting up his face as he pulls you into a bone-crushing hug. He hoists you slightly off your feet, laughing, telling you he always knew you had it in the bag.

But when he pulls back, his smile falters. He looks at your eyes, watery and strained, and the pride in his expression softens into a deep concern. He knows. He can tell exactly how badly you're hurting.

But even now, with a first-place medal heavy against your sternum, you find yourself building a fortress of excuses for John Logan.

You give him the benefit of the doubt, because the alternative is unendurable. He’d never do this intentionally. Not after last week. Not to you. Something had to have happened. A family emergency with his mom. Something with Jules. Maybe he’d taken a brutal hit at practice and was sitting in the training room with a concussion, his phone locked away. He had to be hurt. He had to be incapacitated.

"Let's get you out of here," Tucker says softly, his hand settling on the small of your back, shielding you from the lingering crowds as you pack up your laptop. "I can walk you back to your dorm."

"Actually," you say, your voice tight as you zip your tote bag, "can you take me back to the house? Honestly, after the day I’ve had, I’m dying for a home-cooked Tucker special. I need some real comfort food."

You try to make it sound like a casual request, but Tucker’s hand goes entirely still against your back. He doesn't laugh it off. Instead, an uncomfortable hesitation washes over his features. He looks away, his jaw tightening as he stares out at the emptying auditorium.

In that single beat of silence, a cold and sickening realization dawns on you.

Perhaps Logan isn't sick. Perhaps he isn't hurt. He isn't in a hospital or dealing with a family crisis. Tucker knows exactly where he is.

He forgot.

The thought devastates you, a physical blow that leaves you in theoretical agony, but right on the heels of the sadness comes a sharp, blistering wave of fury. You’re a winner. You just secured your future for the next semester. This should be one of the greatest nights of your life, and yet Logan has latched himself so deeply into the fabric of your existence that he can still ruin it without even being in the room. You hate yourself for letting him have that much power over you.

"You sure you want to go to the house right now?" Tucker asks, his voice uncharacteristically quiet, laced with a warning he isn't entirely voicing.

You stop, staring at him. Your chest heaves. "Why? Is he there?"

Tucker looks at you, his brown eyes full of a grim, reluctant pity. He stays silent. He doesn't say a word, but his silence tells you everything you need to know. He's there. He's perfectly fine, at the hockey house while you were standing on a stage alone.

A hot, dangerous spark ignites in your blood.

"Take me there," you say, your voice dropping all the compliance, hard as flint. He begins to say your name, but you don’t allow him to. "Tucker. Take me to the house."

The ride to the hockey house is quick, though you believe that’s a product of the heavy thrum of your own pulse. Tuck keeps one hand on the steering wheel, your grim mood proving itself to be contagious.

Every few minutes, his voice breaks through the quiet of the truck, telling you to take a breath, telling you to try to calm down. But you can hear the sharp undercurrent of his own anger fueling the engine. He’s pissed on your behalf, but you don't have the capacity to appreciate it right now. You just stare straight ahead.

When the truck comes to a stop in the driveway, you don't wait for Tucker to kill the ignition. You throw the door open and march up the steps, completely ignoring him as he calls your name.

You push the door open, not so much that it was disruptive, but it was noticeable nonetheless.

The warmth of the house hits you first, along with the loud, easy cacophony of a Friday night wind-down. The TV is on, and everyone is scattered across the living room. Allie, Garrett, Dean, and Hannah.

And Logan.

The sheer normalcy of the scene feels like a slap to the face. You stand in the entryway, the first-place medal swinging slightly against your chest, dressed in the gray slacks and blouse you’d picked out so carefully. For a fraction of a second, looking at their relaxed posture and happy faces, you feel entirely microscopic. Like an ant on the back of someone’s boot, completely insignificant to the world revolving around them.

Then, the room goes quiet.

Dean is the first one to look up from the couch. His eyes take in your sharp posture, the formal attire, and finally, the heavy piece hung around your neck catching the ambient light. A grin breaks across his face, completely ignorant of the storm cloud rolling off your shoulders.

"Look at that," Dean announces, raising his cup in a mock toast. "The prodigal daughter returns!"

He’s trying to be supportive. Under any other circumstance, you’d smile, you’d thank him through narrowed eyes. You know he doesn't know. He has no idea what Logan promised, or what it cost you to stand on that stage alone.

But you don't look at Dean. You don't look at Garrett or Allie or Hannah.

Your eyes lock onto Logan.

He’s sitting on the edge of the cushions, and the exact moment your gaze finds his, the color drains completely from his face. It’s like watching a man realize he’s stepped off a cliff. His eyes drop to the medal on your chest, then snap back up to your face, wide and absolutely crushed. The realization of what he’s done hits him in a ton of bricks.

Usually, that look on his face would undo you. Usually, seeing John Logan look that miserable would trigger every protective instinct you’ve harbored for him, making you want to soften the blow, to tell him it’s fine, to smooth it over.

But tonight, you feel absolutely nothing.

The reservoir of sympathy has completely dried up, replaced by a fury that has been bubbling beneath the surface for months.

He hadn't just missed a presentation. He had broken a promise. He had lied to your face on the porch, sworn he was back, and then willfully chose to be somewhere else.

You stare at him, the silence in the room turning suffocatingly loud as the others finally catch onto the tension, and the only thought roaring through your mind is how completely invisible you’ve been to him.

That look of shame is enough gratification for you. If he can feel only a fraction of the pain you’d allowed yourself to endure these past few years, that was good for you. You couldn’t stand staring into the eyes of the man you once thought you knew anymore.

You turn your heel against the floorboards, every instinct screaming at you to walk out that door, to erase John Logan from your life, and to leave him standing in the wreckage of a ten-year friendship.

"Wait," his voice cracks through the silence of the room as he calls your name. "Please wait. I’m sorry. Just—please, just wait!”

You halt entirely. Your flats glue themselves to the floor, the medallion thudding against your chest like a pendulum swinging into a dead stop.

Sorry?

The word tastes rancid just hearing it bounce off the walls of the hockey house. You hadn't known what you wanted him to say when you walked through that door.

You hadn't known if there was a combination of vowels and consonants in the English language that could possibly fix this. But hearing his apology serves as nothing other than gasoline thrown directly onto a grease fire.

Slowly, you turn back around.

Your friends look horrified. You almost feel bad that they’re forced to witness this. You almost want to turn around and leave, leaving this argument for when you’re less heated, less hurt.

But you can’t. He needs to hear you. If not last week or the week before that, now.

Logan takes a step toward you, his hands raised slightly as if approaching a wild animal. "I lost track of time. The showcase at Malone’s—"

"Shut up," you say quietly.

The words aren't screamed. They are quiet, sharp, and dripping with an edge that makes Logan freeze in his tracks.

"Just. . . shut the hell up, Logan." You take a step forward, your shoes clicking against the hardwood. "Don't you dare use that as an excuse for being a pathetic, spineless coward."

He glances at the group that has gone dead silent. You don’t know if what he says next is for your sake or his, but you can’t bring yourself to care.

“Let’s go outside,” he offers, his tone resembling something of a plea. “We can—“

“No!” you spat harshly. “You’re gonna listen to me.”

You’d never spoken to him this way. Not in such a venomous tone, stripped from all warmth. For once, Logan does exactly what you’ve asked of him—to listen. His lips part but no words escape them.

"You sat on the porch two weeks ago," you continue, your voice rising now, the heat finally breaking through the ice. "You held my arm, and you looked me in the eyes and promised me you’d change. Do you have any idea what today was?"

Logan swallows hard, his brown hues welling with a desperate, pathetic panic. "It was the department showcase."

"It was the biggest night of my academic career!" you explode, the anger tearing out of your throat. "I have spent months working on this! I broke down sobbing over this because of how tired I was, and you were the one who held me! You knew exactly how terrified I was. You knew I didn't invite anyone else! What would’ve happened if Tuck wasn’t there?"

You gesture wildly to the medal around your neck.

"I stood on that stage alone, John. I scanned that auditorium for two hours, giving you the benefit of the doubt. I thought something had happened. I thought you were lying in a ditch somewhere or bleeding out in a hospital, because that is the only reason the John Logan I grew up with would ever miss this!"

A tear escapes his eye, rolling down his tanned cheek. "I messed up. Fuck, I know I messed up. Let me make it up to you, please—"

"You didn't mess up, you chose!" you hiss, stepping right into his space, forcing him to look down at the fury burning in your eyes. "You’ve made it perfectly clear where I rank on your list of priorities."

"I am wearing a first-place medal," you continue, your voice trembling with a devastating mix of triumph and agony. "I just won enough grant money to pay for my entire next semester of research. This should be the happiest night of my life. But all I can think about is how my best friend couldn’t show up when I needed him.”

"Please," Logan chokes out, reaching a trembling hand toward your shoulder, his fingers twitching to make that familiar, absent-minded contact. "Just—“

You snap your shoulder back, avoiding his touch as if his hand were coated in acid.

But as you jerk away, the zipper of his jacket catches on the frayed, fuzzy threads of your embroidered bracelet. There is a sudden rip. The threads give out all at once, unraveling in a split second as the broken token of your childhood slips from your wrist and flutters uselessly to the floor.

Logan freezes, his eyes dropping to the colorful, ruined heap of strings resting on the hardwood between you two.

It’s symbolic, you think.

"Don't touch me," you say, your voice dropping into a flat, dead register. You stare at him, washing away every ounce of the six years of love, every ounce of the ten years of friendship, until there is absolutely nothing left between you but a void.

"Don't talk to me. Not now. Not tomorrow. Not ever. You’re dead to me, John."

You turn on your heel and march straight out the front door into the freezing night air.

Logan doesn’t even think before stepping forward to follow after you, but Tucker shuts the door, preventing him from doing so.

He doesn't yell. Instead, he steps into Logan’s space, grabs a fistful of his shirt right at the collar, and shoves him backward into the hallway leading toward the bedrooms. Logan doesn't even try to fight it—he stumbles back, his eyes wide and vacant, completely numb from the fallout.

Tucker slams the door of his room shut, but he doesn't bother locking it. He doesn't need to.

“What the hell were you thinking?” Tucker demands, his voice a growl that vibrates through the walls. He isn’t screaming, but he’s not exactly whispering. “Because right now, I’m having a hard time recognizing one of my best friends.”

“Tuck, I didn’t mean for any of this to happen—”

“You made her a promise, man!” Tucker cuts in sharply. “You told her you’d be there. You looked her dead in the eye and gave her your word. Do you have any idea what today was like for her?”

“I lost track of time. Hannah—”

“Don’t do that,” Tucker says, his eyes narrowing. “Don’t make this about Hannah. This is about you. You screwed up. You’ve been taking that girl for granted for long enough, and she’s been in your corner through every stupid decision you’ve made. Last night, I was the one sitting with her while she practiced that presentation because you were too busy being handyman.”

“She stood on that stage tonight. Every time those judges walked up to her, she checked those doors. Every damn time. She thought something happened to you, because that’s the only reason she could come up with for why you’d break your word to her. And the whole time, you’re moving tables at Malone’s? That’s your excuse?”

“I know I messed up,” Logan chokes out. “I know. I’ll fix it. I’ll talk to her—”

“No, you won’t,” Tucker says immediately. “Not today. Not anytime soon.”

He takes a step back, folding his arms across his chest.

“She told you to stay away. So for once, stop thinking about what you want and listen to what she asked for. You made this mess. If you actually want a shot at fixing it, give her some space and hope she decides you’re worth talking to when she’s ready.”

“Tuck—”

“I’m serious, Logan. Leave her alone. The last thing she needs right now is you showing up trying to make yourself feel better.“