Marinara Sauce for the Year
A few years ago, we started making marinara sauce -- and now it’s an annual ritual we wouldn’t dream of missing. There is nothing better than homemade marinara added to pasta, chili, and soup all winter long. So every year, when tomato seasons starts in earnest, we try to make it a point to get a considerable amount of tomatoes, peppers, garlic, and a few eggplants to make our homemade marinara sauce.
Some years we make a small batch each weekend, other years, we only do it once or twice, but in BIG batches. The fun of the small batch version is that each batch comes out differently. Some are more like paste, some are fantastic for pizza, some are fabulous chili base, still others are a spicy marinara. Of course, the big batch method is that it’s more standardized, and you have a better idea what you’re getting when you open a jar throughout the year.
This year, we went for the big-batch method and got the box you see above plus another box of the same size, full of a variety of heirloom, beefsteak, and Roma tomatoes - for a total of about 50 pounds of tomatoes, 2 Japanese eggplants, 4 large heads of garlic, a basket of sweet peppers and a few hot peppers.
Here is our Marinara Recipe:
Set the oven to 325 degrees and allow it to preheat.
Line a rimmed sheet pan with aluminum foil (this will make clean up a LOT easier.)
Slice the beefsteaks and heirloom tomatoes in half horizontally and slice Roma tomatoes in half vertically. Poke out the seeds with your fingers.
Peel and clove the garlic -- tap into some the new holes you’ve created in the tomatoes -- this will help to keep it from burning. (We use 1/2 of a clove per sheet pan.)
Slice the peppers in half and remove the seeds. (We’re not super huge pepper fans, but it adds something special to the sauce. Use as many sweet and/or hot peppers as YOU like.) We usually use 1-2 Anaheim and 1 Jalapeno per sheet pan. Lay on top of tomatoes.
We add eggplant for body and texture to our sauce. About 1/4 small Japanese eggplant per sheet pan. Lay on top of tomatoes.
Add salt and pepper to the sheet pans, and sprinkle with Italian Herbs or Herbs de Provence - whichever you prefer (we prefer Herbs de Provence).
Place in the oven and roast for 60 minutes.
Check on the peppers - they are probably done at this point. Pull the peppers out and place them in the Vitamix Blender for later.
Put the tomatoes back into roast for another 30-60 minutes at 325.
Raise the temperature to 400 degrees for 30 minutes.
When you remove your tomatoes from the oven, they should look something like the pictures below.
If ever the tomatoes are looking more done than the picture below, pull them out -- the length of time is very dependent on the TYPE and overall MOISTURE of the tomatoes you are working with.
Once the tomatoes are out, scrape them off the sheet pan and place them in the Vitamix Blender.
Blend until smooth. (if they are too dry, you can add water to thin the sauce out a little so it will blend nicely.)
If you’re making a BIG batch, pour each blender-full into a large soup pan and gently mix to standardize the flavors in the batch. Repeat until all the tomatoes, peppers, garlic, and eggplant have been thoroughly blended.
This is the most personal moment, but adjust your sauce for taste. We always assume that the marinara is only base, and we’ll finalize the taste add meat and/or chunky vegetables on the day we use it, but getting the rough flavors in place now will make it easier then. Add salt, pepper, garlic, paprika, or whatever you want at this point.
Then comes the easiest part. Transfer the sauce into mason jars. We use pint-size jars for pasta meals (there are two of us in the house) or half-pint-size jars for pizza sauce. We’ll also do a couple of quart size jars for soup bases throughout the year. But portion it as makes the most sense for you and your household. The key is to put them in small enough batches that you can open just enough for your needs at the given meal.
If you’re feeling ambitious, you could actually can them, but we usually cheat and put them in the freezer at this point. They freeze well and will last the year.
And that’s it! Marinara Sauce is done for the year! So much better than the stuff you can buy at the store and I like that I know exactly what I put it.
Our yield from this batch was 19 pint-size jars of sauce.
Give it a try and adjust the flavors to what your household likes. You won’t be sorry!