i think every publisher should have to institute a ban on books that fail what i’m calling the “little life” and “what else?” tests
for reference.
I don't like this as general advice because it's basically uninterpretable outside of its context. What on earth is actually wrong with writing about your dead sister or your life? We don't know. Morrison's and Glück's students had more than we get here. Glück's student knows her own piece, has an easier time figuring out what weaknesses Glück saw in it, and probably got to talk more about it; Morrison's students had a lot more background statements to read her comments against. So the specific audiences of these remarks could make something useful out of it. But anyone reading this in Post Form is just going to project whatever they think Glück or Morrison meant (in the best case scenario they've read the authors' works but many won't have). So people aren't even really going to take away any good writing guidance except what they already thought, mutated by these memeified remarks.
Well I think there is a recognizable tendency of young writers, the kind you would find in a creative writing class to write sad stories about their lives and to present them in as "raw" a fashion as possible. And they're all really, really boring and they really suck to grade. And I think "no one cares" is just a useful tool for producing better writing from your students and the people trying to submit to your shitty literary journal. It's fine. The memefied form is fine.
Has this post successfully made a point? Dare we read the notes and find out? Here are the types of responses I've spotted:
You want to ban books. Like the nazis did.
Books about small, trivial aspects of your life can be beautiful! Why are you saying they can never be?
I have no idea what this writing advice means. You never outlined an actual test. You never clarified what to do or even, really, what not to do.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously that you should write things you haven't experienced.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously that you should only write what you have personally experienced.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously that you should add more detail in your writing.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously that you should add less detail in your writing.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously that there needs to be a plot.
You people are all idiots. The advice is obviously criticizing the specific person that really annoyed me in my writing class.
Well done everyone!




























