Sing it with me!!!
I was tired of waiting
We'd been together so long
But not really together
...But really that long
You ran away from my loving
You got all in your head
I tried to walk it back but
You freaked out and said:
"I like penis coladas
But I cannot be gay
I have to go right now, bro
Don't look at me that way
I know that we were almost something
But the sound of my name
Reminded me I can't do this
I must go find a dame"
I could only think about your lady
With you in your bed
I tried to go get la-aid
But we psychosexu'lly stared instead
So I went home alone
Jerked off in the shower, hard
Had to picture your fa-ace
Felt I was trapped in that bar
"Yeah, I miss penis coladas
Going down on your hole
I think that's called a rim job
Your mom taught me that lol
I want to see you at the All Stars game
Though I'm dreading it too
If you are engaged then
I don't know what I'll do"
So I waited with beer in hand
Tried to be unflappable
I asked, "Are you still with whatshername?"
He said, "We were not compatible."
I looked the word up later
I felt much less doomed
Then he said that he'd see me
Up in my hotel room
"I know you like penis coladas
Okie, so you're gay
You are also real' boring
Mr. Re-eal Estate
And you look at me with yearning eyes
And you call me by name
Can we have this love now?
Stay with me and exclaim*
[*because you're coming so hard]
"Yes, you like penis coladas
And sucking cock with no shame
I guess you're 'decent' at hockey
Now be good and behave
You like making love at all times
And turning it into a game
I'm the love that you really want
Come with me* and be gay"
[*Yes, is pun, Shane]
Credit to @luvbugbites for their tag "AND SUCKING COCK WITH NO SHAME!" that prompted me to want to finish the refrain (which then snowballed into the whole song)
Rejected bits/versions:
If you like folding clothes
And overthinking in bed
Come with me and I'll Dom you
Till way more's done than said
------
"But you ran from my home that
I maybe bought just for you
I would never say it
But the windows might do
If you come back I promise I won't ask for more
I'll be good and behave
Let's just fuck again please
I will not call you 'Shane'"

















