the true horror of the Watcher
iâve gone on about this is one of my other posts already (and im gonna repeat myself a bit) and iâve seen some other people talk about it, but i really want to get all my thoughts out about this.Â
throughout the show, we see the Eye manifesting as betrayal of consent. honestly, whatâs so terrifying about being watched, observed, or even judged if you consent to it? if you know youâre being watched and are okay with it, if you share a secret willingly and gladly. even horrible and devastating knowledge is best processed when youâre prepared. a huge part of the Eyeâs horror is that itâs completely against your will. you don't want to be watched or you donât even know. your worst secret somehow got out and now everyone knows. the discovery you just made completely blindsided you. it takes away your autonomy, your privacy, and your security. more so, itâs a perfect breeding ground for paranoia. what if it happens again, what if your secrets are never safe again, who will betray me next? this particular manifestation is a perfect tool for the Watcher.Â
one of the most obvious examples is Jon and Elias having the ability of Compulsion. they can literally force anybody to tell them anything they want, and once they ask the question you physically cannot make yourself stop speaking!! Daisy describes it as âyour secrets pulled out like teeth, just because he asked.â (MAG 91) not only are your darkest secrets being revealed but they are taking it from you.Â
Jon is made into the âArchivesâ by Elias without truly understanding what he was being groomed for. and this is absolutely NOT to say that Jon was completely unwilling or that in a thousand little ways, he didnât choose to be an avatar. i mean that Jon was being groomed into the perfect lynchpin for Eliasâs ritual since Day 1 and he had no idea. Elias sends him on little quests, throws avatars his way, and puts him in situations for the sole purpose of getting him Marked by the Entities. Jon has no say in these encounters nor does he know what they really mean. Jon mightâve chosen to be an avatar but he had no say in participating in the Watcherâs Crown. i'm not even going to get into Jonâs overall relationship with his body but we all know itâs abysmal.
and i have to talk about the âHello Jonâ because this is a complete and horrific breach of Jonâs autonomy in so so many ways. for one, he cannot even stop reading the ritual once he begins and he so desperately tries. the fact Elias tricks him into summoning the Entities by writing the incantation as a statement is what really gets me. Jon feeds off statements. i know this is probably going to sound silly or melodramatic, but Elias pretty much slips something in his food. imagine youâre eating a sandwich and thereâs a fucking explosive in it. in so many different ways, Jonâs autonomy is completely stripped for the entirety of this episode. he cannot stop speaking, he cannot move, he was deceived, and the means of this betrayal was in something he believed and trusted would be safe.Â
Jon routinely reads peopleâs minds, and while it (usually) isnât intentional, he still breaches their consent. the others, for example Basira, makes a point to tell that he is not welcoming snooping around in their heads. we have the entire MAG 142 incident. Jon finds someone Marked and he takes her statement, he pulls it from her lips, and part of the horror is that she could not stop herself from speaking. she has no say in the matter, her secrets are spilled out before this stranger who will not stop watching her just because he asked. the statement giver says, âI want to tell him to, to go away; I, I wanted to kick him and run. But I sit down. And I start to tell him everything.â (MAG 142)
also Jon cuts a bullet out of Melanie without asking while sheâs asleep. Jon makes Jordan Kennedy into an avatar without asking; he remakes him, almost how Elias remade Jon. Gertrude, as well! She binds Gerry to the Catalogue of the Trapped Dead! I have to think she knows heâd hate that, but she does it anyway. Gerry has no autonomy here.Â
some might be thinking: isnât all fear pretty nonconsensual? yeah. i understand this argument, but i'm specifically talking about the way the Eye purposefully utilizes a breach of consent to create even more horror and fear. also, some of the subtle horror of the Entities is that sometimes it doesnât betray you. in s4, Martin chooses to isolate himself. while this choice is one he made under Peterâs persuasion, his trauma and abysmal self-worth, and his misguided attempt to protect the others, the emotions that feed the Lonely are from a willing and conscious choice. Martin willingly chooses to give himself to that fear and isolation. thatâs what makes it so horrifying. his autonomy was never disrespected and, if anything, Peter could not force him at all for his plan to work.Â
what really sells me on this concept is from the Watcherâs Crown Incantation. it says, âYou who wait and wait and drink in all that is not yours by right.â (MAG 160) the Eye is not entitled to all its knowledge. it is not entitled to see you. it does not deserve your secrets or fear or history. it takes it. the Eye drinks in information hungrily and greedily, it pulls it from your mind like teeth with no real comprehension except for a cold and malicious desire to know all that there is. it does not ask or plan or wait or persuade, it simply takes what it wants.













