༒︎ teach me how to scream
fratboy! eren x nerd! armin x reader
wc: 2.2k
tags: college au, m/m/f , smut, college frat party, alcohol use, smoking, threesome, double penetration, double creampie, degrading, face-fucking, tongue piercing, anal, voyeurism, semi-public sex, rough sex, oral fixation, smut with some plot, dirty talk, nipple play,dom/sub, hair-pulling, semi drunk fucking, some fluff. etc.
Somehow, you ended up at one of the biggest college parties you’ve been to in a while.
One moment you were taking shots with your closest friends, next thing you know…
You end up in a bedroom alone with no other than Eren Yeager and his best friend Armin Arlert…
How did you even end up in this predicament?
⋆⁺₊⋆ ━━━━⊱༒︎ • ༒︎⊰━━━━ ⋆⁺₊⋆
Loud EDM music blasts throughout the house, the bass thrumming beneath your feet. Strobe lights flickered like lightning in a storm, the crowd pulsing with energy—sweaty bodies pressed together, cheap perfume and even cheaper liquor saturated the air.
Why did my friends invite me to this shit…
You weren’t planning on staying long. Just a little pregame with your girls, maybe flirt with that cute sophomore from your bio lab, then Uber home before the real chaos starts.
But chaos always found you first.
Leaning against the kitchen counter, you kept an eye on Sasha and Mikasa, trying to seem like you weren’t babysitting them. At the same time, they cackled over another round of tequila shots. That’s when you feel a light tap on your shoulder.
“Hey, can I pour you a drink? Looks like you need one,” the man offers smoothly. Confident.
Turning around, guess who you see? Eren Yeager is one of the people hosting this party. The name alone is enough to make some girls weak in the knees and others swear him off entirely. You weren’t sure which category you fell into.
Your brows lifted. “Didn’t expect you to talk to me tonight,” you said, lips tugging into a small smile before you could stop yourself.
He laughs, already grabbing shot glasses. “You seemed bored. And clearly, you need a drink if you’re going to be posted up like security for Sasha and Mikasa all night. Someone’s gotta save you.” he tilts his head, grinning as he pours out four shots of vodka.
Before you could respond, another familiar voice chimed in behind him.
“Eren, pour out some more? I could use some.”
Armin. Armin Arlert, his blond hair slightly tousled, cheeks flushed from the heat and crowd.
You blinked once. “Didn’t expect to see you here.”
Armin’s eyes found yours. He smiled, warm and quiet. “Same to you. Thought parties weren’t your thing.”
“They’re not,” you admitted, knocking back the first shot. The burn made your throat tighten—but the second went down easier. “Sasha and Mikasa dragged me here. told me I needed to ‘socialize more.’” You rolled your eyes, smirking slightly as you licked your lips.
Eren watched with interest. “You’re really full of surprises.”
You shrugged, playing coy. “I like to keep people guessing.”
The three of you lingered there for a bit, the music thudding against the walls. And then Armin leaned in, voice low.
“It’s getting a little crazy in here. You two wanna go upstairs and smoke?”
“I’m down,” Eren said easily. Then he turned to you. “Coming with?”
You hesitated for half a second, caught between logic and curiosity. But the way Eren looked at you—half-daring, half-inviting—made the choice for you.
“…sure,” you said, a slow smirk curling on your lips. “I could use a cigarette right now.”
⊱༒︎ • ༒︎⊰
The three of you made your way through the crowd. As you walked up the stairs, you suddenly became hyper-aware of the way your miniskirt swayed with every step. You could practically feel their eyes on you.
You didn’t dare look back. But your pulse quickened.
“In here,” Eren said, opening the door to a spare bedroom. Armin heads in first, moving to crack open the window, letting in a welcome breeze.
“We can just share for now,” Armin offered, pulling out the cigarette pack and holding one out to you.
You accepted it, fingers brushing his. Eren steps in front of you, pulling out a lighter. “Here, let me.”
He leaned in close, lighting it for you with a quiet flick. His eyes didn’t leave yours as you inhaled. “Thanks,” you said softly, exhaling the smoke out the window.
Eren grabs it from your fingers, placing it between his lips—his mouth where yours just were. Then he turned to Armin, passing it along like an unspoken secret.
He tilts his head back, letting the cigarette rest lazily on his lips as he continues to finish what remains.
You talked for a while—half-dazed, half-drunk on proximity. The bed was too inviting to resist, and eventually, you all ended up sprawled across it. The tension was thick enough to touch.
And then you felt it—a hand on your thigh.
Light.
Teasing.
You shivered.
Your gaze snapped to Armin, who was watching you with a look that was both soft and burning. His fingers lingered just a second longer. You opened your mouth—but before you could say anything, Eren’s gaze caught yours.
He didn’t look surprised. In fact… he looked like he’d been waiting for this.
The tension in the air between the three of you could practically crack a mirror.
You laughed under your breath. “Just kiss me, if you really want this,” you said to Armin, voice breathy and seductive.
His hand curled against your face instantly. The kiss was hot, eager, desperate, like he’d been waiting to taste you for years. You whimpered into his mouth as his tongue brushed against yours, the cold metal of his tongue piercing sending you into a daze.
You broke the kiss, breath ragged, slowly climbing into his lap. His hands found your hips, holding you firmly. “You don’t know how badly we’ve wanted this,” he murmured.
“Oh, she knows,” Eren said, settling into the nearby armchair, unbothered as he watched you both. His voice dropped. “Go ahead. Put on a little show for us.”
You felt a wave of heat spread across your skin. But you didn’t hesitate.
You stripped slowly—top slipping off, then your bra—your eyes never leaving theirs. Armin can’t help but groan, hand sliding up your side as he leans in to press his lips to your breast. His tongue circled one nipple, the piercing cold and sharp against your skin, while his other hand groped your other tit. You arched into him, grinding down—feeling how hard he was beneath you.
Eren exhaled through his mouth, hands resting on his jeans, watching both of you. “y/n, keep your miniskirt on,” he said.
You whined at the command, your body aching for their attention.
Armin’s voice dropped to a whisper. “Turn around. Face him, and bend over. alright?”
You complied eagerly, barely registering the command.
“Mmph fuck,” he murmured, sliding your panties down. You gasped when you felt his dainty fingers tease your soaking cunt—rubbing slow, deliberate circles before finally sinking them in.
You buried your head into the sheets as you cried out. “Oh my god—Armin…”
Looking up, you catch a glimpse of Eren’s eyes, lying right onto yours
“That’s it. Just like that,” Eren said, palming himself through his pants erotically slow, his voice hoarse. “You love being watched, don’t you?”
You tried to answer—but all that came out were loud, incoherent moans. Armin’s fingers fucked into you with deep, aching strokes, filling you up perfectly. Each thrust makes you clench harder, driving you crazy.
“You’re being so good for us,” Eren rasped, getting up to stand right in front of you as he unzipped his pants, watching you fall apart between them. “She deserves it, doesn’t she, Armin?”
“So fucking badly,” Armin muttered, grabbing your waist tighter, fingers rubbing against that perfect spot.
Eren slowly opens your mouth by pressing his thumb to your lips. You part your lips slowly, inching deeper, sucking and swirling your tongue around his thumb, letting out slow, sensual moans— showing him how good you would take it.
Without hesitating, he slips his fingers out of your mouth, using your spit as lube to stroke his erection right in front of you before slipping it right into your warm mouth. You’re practically drooling at this point.
You do your best to get air before opening your mouth, making deep eye contact before he’s lining the head of his cock up with your lips.
“Let it go all the way down your throat. You can take it,” Eren coos, making you take him all at once
All you can make out are pathetic, choked, and dirty wet noises with each thrust into your mouth, unable to control anything anymore, as your holes get fucked endlessly by the two of them.
On queue, Armin decides to take his fingers out, making you ache for more.
He slowly starts teasing your entrance again, but not with his fingers this time..
It’s Armin tracing your slit with his cock, slowly slipping it inside you raw, no condom on, just feeling every inch of you.
“Shitt..” Armin groans out, grabbing your hips, making his fingers dig into your skin. His pace is getting faster by the minute.
The bedroom was filled with the sounds of loud slamming and muffled moans.
obscene amounts of drool and messy tears trickling down your face, not knowing how long you can last
You open your watery eyelids only to freeze at the way Eren is holding his phone now…
Is Eren filming this? Feeling your heart racing even faster than ever, yet so aroused.
“I think everyone should see how slutty you really are, right, Armin?” he says while biting back a moan.
“Don’t scare her like that, Eren,” letting out a slight laugh under his breath.
Eren can’t help but crack a smile, looking down at you, recording the way your throat was being so roughly used as nothing but a hole to him.
Your moans continue growing louder, your body getting tense, you’re gonna cum. fuck.
He takes the hint, pulling your hips down harder, making you feel every inch of him.
making your vision fade to black, letting out desperate whines as you’re coming down from your high
feeling exhausted yet so intoxicated, they both pull out, making sure you can catch a breather
…
“We aren’t done yet, y/n, you haven’t made us finish yet.” Eren is letting out a smile, still having his phone out, facing you
The intoxication still lingering, you look up at the camera—your hair sticking to your face, makeup smudged from crying, still looking pretty as ever.
Ruin me.
Before you know it, you're bent over on top of Armin again as Eren stands right behind you, observing you two…
Armin pulls you in for a deep yet messy kiss, slowly slipping himself in again, making you bite his lip from the friction.
“God, I love seeing both of you like this.” Eren clenches his jaw, trying to get ahead of himself just yet..
He firmly grabs the miniskirt you still have on, making it get your attention as you see him holding his phone once again.
“We’re just getting to the good part.” Eren winks at Armin, pointing the camera at the two of you, watching how you sink down onto Armin
Seeing how wet you are, Eren can’t help but tease you by pressing his thumb against your other entrance.
Your sweet ass
You moaned against Armin’s lips at how much you enjoyed the feeling
You can't help but want more... and Eren can give you exactly what you need.
He's always known you had a thing for both of them, especially those countless times you crossed paths with one another.
Brushing those thoughts away, Eren notices the way you give in so easily
“y/n you take it so fucking good” exhaling slowly, watching how his dick enters your ass
You gasp, feeling how your holes are getting completely filled at the same time.
“Mmph yes that’s the spot eren-“ you plead out, feeling him touching that sweet spot of yours.
Armin continues to let everything unfold right in front of his eyes. He pushes your hair back, making sure to check if you’re okay.
You lock eyes with one another, seeing how he stares at you with such lust, yet so much love.
“You’re too pretty to be a dirty whore y/n,” he grunted out, making his pace go faster yet sloppy.
Eren continues recording, seeing how intimate you and Armin are, he can’t help but feel some jealousy, making him grab your hair to get your sweet attention.
You’re a bit stunned yet, so turned on from the way you’re being manhandled..
Him having a firm grip on your hair as you’re getting fucked out of your mind, every last drop of dignity you had was gone.
“fuckk- rough me up even more,” moaning louder, be the second, slurring your words, you barely manage to get out
Eren can feel himself getting closer, making it hard to control his deep yet needy moans.
This makes Armin and Eren lock eyes with each other, giving each other a certain signal…
“I’m so close— fuck, you’re so tight.” Eren, inhaling sharply, his pace gets messier
bucking his hips down one last time before he releases, Armin feeling the way you clench around him so intensely, making him cum at the same time
The sight of them finishing inside you makes you cry out for them as you reach your peak. All you can hear is Armin’s heart beating out of his chest.
Eren slowly pulls out, then Armin follows right after, Eren just admiring you as you leak out so much cum
Prettiest view I’ve seen all night
He tilts his back from exhaustion, sinking into the mattress, dropping his phone beside him.
You can also feel the exhaustion hit you, feeling Armin stroking your hair while lying on his chest.
“Let’s get you cleaned up, yeah?."
…
notes: this lowkey took me WAY too long to finish life has been kicking my ass but i hope you all enjoyed lmk if i should write more more fratboy eren..
(crossposted on ao3)









