Untitled

I know it's a common theory that in the Betty trio, Taylor = James, Karlie = Betty because of their names, but I have been listening to the songs and thinking about how they connect to their people and I actually believe that Taylor = Betty, Karlie = James, and Josh = Augustine. To explain why, I will talk about how each song relates to each person/relationship.

August: This is a song about a relationship that ruined a more prominent/lasting relationship. It makes the least amount of sense in my love triangle, but think of it as Karlie marrying Josh. Josh would have probably wanted to have Karlie for a while, and Taylor was in the way. Kaylor probably has some sort of problem in their relationship. Karlie chose Josh, and because of that, Taylor can never go back to their relationship.

Betty: The whole worst thing that I did part was talking about how Taylor probably pushed Karlie away and blamed her for something she didn't do. This is Karlie apologizing to Taylor about marrying Josh.

Cardigan: This was the song that got me thinking about all of this. The original lyrics are so gay and so Kaylor coded from Taylor's perspective. Gold age, sneak into my bird cage. Chase two girls lose the one. Karlie was trying to be with two people, and ended up having to lose her relationship with one of them. There are so many lyrics that relate to Taylor being Betty.

I can't keep thinking of all of the gayness of The Great War.

Violets-gay flower.

Maybe it was her- the other person is a woman

Crimson clover-crimson and clover is gay

Tears on the letter- reference to Closure??

So I justified it all that bloodshed- This lyric makes me think that she justified all of the bloodshed for this lover. Swfties and gaylors attacked Karlie after their breakup and Taylor didn't do anything to stop it

Hairpin triggers- hairpin drop reference

icy ground- reference to hoax, the Kaylor breakup

broken and blue- blue=karlie

Taylor might not have betrayed us!!! Like first of all, she said my 6 year relationship. Not relationship with Joe. I doubt that she would be with anyone else, but the fact that she did not specifically mention Joe could help the theory that she and Karlie are still together.

Secondly, she said all of the rumors around her relationship. There have been so many are they engaged articles, is Taylor pregnant, the abusive rumors. While many of us believed she was talking about gaylor, our speculation are not as harmful as some of those. And the amount of articles on gaylor vs. the amount of other problems, gaylor is 100% outnumbered.