Movie Rant #1 - Star Wars Thoughts, Part 1
With the release of the trailer for Episode 8, I thought Iâd share some thoughts about the sequel trilogy so far.
Now this might be an unpopular opinion but Iâll open this right away and say that I prefer the Prequels to Episode 7. Now it could be argued that I first saw the Prequels when I was young and I am just bitter about Disney owning Star Wars now and that I am going to just hate anything different. But I donât believe this is true. I watched The Clone Wars series for the first time months before Episode 7 came out and I loved it. And on top of this while I did not enjoy Episode 7 very much, I thought Rogue One was one of the greatest Star Wars movies that has ever been released. I would go so far as to say itâs tied with A New Hope as my second favourite. (Empire obviously being the best.)
And donât mistake it, as a movie by itself Episode 7 is way better than the prequels. Acting, shots, editing and dialogue were way better. When considered with the rest of the series, I think it just doesnât fit in properly. That being said, I do believe all the movies are worth watching.
But why did I love Rogue One beyond belief but only felt an empty hole for The Force Awakens? Well here is my main reason:
SPOILER WARNINGS FOR EPISODES 1-7, THE CLONE WARS AND ROGUE ONE
It Builds On Instead of Taking Away:
In the prequels (and especially in the Clone Wars) you get a sense that the Jedi have become complacent. They are weak because it had been over a thousand years since the Sith disappeared into the shadows and they did not believe the Sith could ever return. Mace Windu dismisses Maul as a Sith when Qui-Gon suggests the possibility. And Obi-Wan and Yoda flat out refuse to believe that a member of the Sith is controlling the senate when Count Dooku flat out says so. If you get passed some of the poor dialogue choices and cringey romance, we see that the fall of the Republic and Anakinâs belief that the Jedi are corrupt actually comes together quite nice.
In the Clone Wars it just goes even further. We see Anakin discuss with Tarkin how the Jedi aren'tâ willing to take the steps necessary to end the war and that the war only highlights their incompetence and failures as a group and so called âkeepers of the peace.â As well we get how much affected Anakin is when Ahsoka is abandoned by the Jedi and how willing they are to let her get executed for a crime she didnât commit.
So why is all of that important? Because it gives us motivation and insight into characters we didnât actually know that much about. We see how shamed Yoda is by his failure to prevent the atrocities that occur to the Jedi and we see how Obi-Wan feels he failed Anakin so completely. And most importantly we see the human that is behind Darth Vader, and we see how broken and twisted heâs become.
On top of this we see where being all âhigh and mightyâ got the Jedi. The pompous Jedi were destroyed because they didnât believe anything could ever touch them. The characters we sympathise with are the Grey Jedi. Qui-Gon Jinn is caring, willing to use tricks, gamble, disobey the council and in the end heâs the only one who truly sees Anakinâs potential and actually believes that Maul could be a Sith. And to an extent Obi-Wan follows in his footsteps. We are led to understand that true power in the force should come from balance.
When Obi-Wan and Yoda train Luke, they teach him the Jedi ways but try to teach him to be more mindful. They donât want him to make the mistakes they made. By Return of the Jedi, we see Luke use force choke, force manipulation, intimidation and is walking this fine line of good and evil. In the end he chooses good, but his good isnât the 'goodâ of the old republic. He has family and friends, he doesnât believe in the cold blooded approach of the Republic era Jedi, his is much more of a Grey Path.
So we assume that he is going to be the best Jedi ever. That he learned to be one with the force and really walk that middle road of balance. He wonât make the same mistakes the Republic Era Jedi madeâŚ.
âŚâŚExcept he does. According to Episode 7, he trains some people to use the force but instead of being the awesome Jedi we believed he was at the end of Episode 6, it turns out heâs just as bad as the Republic Jedi. Kylo Ren pulls an Anakin and kills all the other Jedi and turns evil.
And this is where the problem lies. Where the prequels gave us a universe that was designed to strengthen and give more meaning to the original trilogy, Episode 7 throws anything learned aside in order to ensure that the story continues.
Anything accomplished in Episode 6 means nothing from the start of Episode 7. The Empire is not defeated, the good guys are still a tiny rebellion. The only good government is conveniently destroyed so that itâs still the story of a small group of ragtag rebels fighting the big scary Empire. Sure, the empire would not be completely destroyed at the end Return of the Jedi. But their leader is gone, he had no real contingent, no heir. Most groups seemed to support that the Rebellion won. So why is the First Order more powerful than the original Empire? Why was there no one to try to wipe out the empire remnants in over 30 years? It felt like they wanted to have a story to reflect A New Hope so in order to do so they had to dismiss any progress at the end of the original trilogy. It makes it feel as if the original trilogy just shouldn'tâ have happened because it turns out nothing was accomplished.
Say what you will about the old Expanded Universe bit at least the Thrawn Trilogy was only a few years after Endor, and even then Thrawn is only barely keeping together a shattered force. As well, the villain wasnât even a force user. He didnât compete with Vader like Kylo Ren, he was so different and yet just as intimidating a foe. If anything Thrawn only strengthened what Darth Vader was and contrasted with him in a lot of ways. But I digress, my love of Thrawn aside Iâll go back to Episode 7.
On top of Luke turning out to be the exact same as Yoda, we get the fact that Han and Leia arenât even happy together after all this time. Thatâs not really a big deal and doesnât actually take away from the story, itâs just that itâs another thing that was just destroyed for the sake of making Episode 7 more interesting. Nothing from Episode 6 is shown to have made any lasting effect on the universe.
We get to the biggest culprits now: the fact that everything had to be taken up a notch from the original trilogy.
The Death Star was a monumental thing that shook the universe and took the funds of an entire empire to build. It could blow up worlds and it seemed like an impossible task for the rebels to take it down. But thatâs nothingâ now, who cares about the Death Star? It has to move to a world to blow it up. No, now we have the Star Killer Base. It can shoot across the universe and eats suns. The Death Star was the size of a small moon? So what? The Star Killer Base is a literal planet!
How did the first order afford this? Where did it come from? Why did they have to 'outdoâ the original trilogy just for the sake of having bigger and better? It makes anything that happened before seem silly because the empire is just bigger and badder, so why did the death of the emperor even matter? Why did blowing up the Death Star matter? It all ended up being pointless after a few years anyways.
And then there is Rey. Ugh. Iâll get to her in a second.
I may not be overly thrilled by Kylo Ren but there are some things I genuinely thought were great about his character. The fact that he wore that helmet to mimic Darth Vader, the fact that he obsesses over Vader are great. They show how important and long lasting the terror of Vader was and that after more than 30 years, Vader is the epitome of villains. On top of that, I love that he loses his temper in a more childlike fashion just smashing stuff at random instead of the cool hatred Vader has when he chokes those who fail him. As well the fact that his lightsaber is imperfect and shows that he is obviously somewhat self taught and not a real Sith or even fully trained Jedi. He shows a Dark Jedi that did not have a mentor like Darth Sidious and never completed his training like Anakin and I actually enjoyed that.
But then thereâs Rey. I think she was the worst part of Episode 7. Out of everything they did, she is what ruined the movie for me. She feels more like a fanfiction character than someone that should actually exist in the movies. In A New Hope, Luke doesnât use force powers, he doesnât even really use a lightsaber despite him holding it on the poster. He proves his connection to the force by making a 1 in a million shot to blow up the Death Star. Anakin Skywalker, the most powerful Jedi in the universe, is able to Pod Race and is a pretty good pilot but he doesnât use force powers until after years of training.
Rey does all of this in one movie. Sheâs just better than every character thatâs been in a Star Wars movie for no reason other than to make her cool. She is an exceptional pilot, despite being relatively segregated from most of her home planet. When did she learn? How did she have the time? Whoâs ship did she practice on?
She uses force pull more powerfully than Kylo Ren despite never having any training and Kylo Ren actually having training from Luke. She uses force manipulation despite only masters being shown to use this power (even Luke only uses it in Jedi after a few years of practice). How did she even know this was a power? Why was she able to use it so effectively? Why didnât she have to move her hand like every other Jedi that uses it?
They make every other Jedi look like an idiot because she could figure everything out in a matter of days while it took others years. The Prequels show how powerful Luke is because he is learning to use the force at an older age in a matter of days. He can lift stones and jump around all because of Yodaâs training and his innate abilities. But even he has nothing on Rey because she just instantly knows how to use every force power the plot needs her to learn.
Whatâs wrong is that Episode 7 doesnât follow the same rules that the other movies have established. It was like they wanted to have a bunch of nostalgia moments but didnât care that putting them in made no sense or just made Rey feel way to overpowered.
This went a lot longer than I expected to go, so Iâm going to talk about Rogue One (and why I fanboyed so hard the first time I watched it) in a second part.
If you have any comments, agree or disagree let me know why! I would love to hear it! Thanks!