research based

Mackenzie Lueck was tragically murdered at the age of 23 during the early morning hours of June 17th, 2019. 

Mackenzie was a student at the University of Utah, and she lived in Salt Lake City. She spent the final days of her life in her hometown of El Selgundo, California, as she was visiting family for a funeral. Mackenzie boarded a flight back to Utah on the evening of June 16th, which landed in Salt Lake during the early morning hours of the 17th. She texted her parents around 2am to let them know she had landed safely. After that final text, Mackenzie’s family never heard from her again.    Over the next few days, Mackenzie’s family and friends began to notice that something was off. When her father tried to message her on the 18th, he noticed that the messages were going through as text messages rather than iMessages-even though they both had iPhones. Her friends began to worry when Mackenzie did not show up to her shift at Millbrook medical lab, nor did she show up for an exam she was scheduled to take. Knowing this was uncharacteristic of her, Mackenzie’s worried parents contacted Utah officials to report her missing on June 20th, 2019. Throughout the investigation, detectives learned that Mackenzie left the airport on the morning of her disappearance in a Lyft car. Surveillance cameras at the airport captured her exiting the building at 2:40am. Detectives questioned the Lyft driver, who told them that he dropped Mackenzie off at Hatch Park and observed her getting into another vehicle. Both Lyft records and cell phone pings confirmed that Mackenzie exited the Lyft at the park at 2:59am. Mackenzie’s family and friends did not know why she asked the Lyft driver to take her to the park instead of taking her home, nor did they know about any plans for her to meet someone there. Detectives then worked to identify who she met up with at the park. 

Mackenzie’s cell phone records revealed that she was messaging with another person while in her Lyft. In fact, Mackenzie’s final text message was sent to this person at 2:58am–just one minute before she exited the Lyft at Hatch Park. Her phone was shut off shortly after 3:00am. Detectives later identified the person Mackenzie was messaging as 31 year-old man named Ayoola Ajayi. 

After learning that Ajayi was the last person to communicate with Mackenzie, detectives went to his house in Fairpark to question him. He initially denied knowing Mackenzie, but later admitted they had briefly messaged after meeting on a dating app. Both Ajayi and Mackenzie had a dating app called ‘Seeking Arrangements’ downloaded on their phone–which is an app designed for people seeking a 'sugar daddy/sugar baby’ type relationship.

On June 26th, 2019, authorities executed a search warrant at Ajayi’s house. Several items were seized during the search. His backyard was thoroughly searched as well. Two days later, on June 28th, 2019, Ayoola Ajayi was arrested and charged with aggravated murder, aggravated kidnapping, desecration of a body and obstructing justice in relation to the Mackenzie Lueck case. It was then confirmed that detectives had found tissue/DNA belonging to Mackenzie at Ajayi’s house. Additionally, it was revealed that on the morning of June 17th Ajayi’s cell phone pinged off the same tower Mackenzie’s phone pinged off of for the final time–and his ping occurred just a minute after hers.

Once Ajayi was behind bars, investigators continued to comb through evidence and build their case. The evidence they gathered eventually revealed a harrowing story about what happened to Mackenzie.

Kelcey Fike was 21 years old when she was brutally murdered inside her own home during the early morning hours of June 17th, 2008. 

At the time, Kelcey and her boyfriend Alex Young lived in a mobile home in Kearney, Nebraska. Alex was a reservist in the Nebraska National Guard, and was out of town the night of Kelcey’s murder. Kelcey usually stayed with her parents when Alex was out of town, but this time she decided to stay at her place as she was preparing for an upcoming trip to visit her best friend. Kelcey sent her final text message to Alex around 1am. 

Just a few hours later, at 4:30am, Kelcey’s home erupted into flames. The flames were so intense that first responders had to force the neighbors who wanted to help to stay back. The entire rear side of the trailer, where the back bedroom was located, was engulfed in fire. The firefighters were aware that a resident was inside the home, and they made their best efforts to extinguish the fire and potentially save a life. Unfortunately, when they finally were able to put out the flames, it was too late. Kelcey’s lifeless body was found on the floor outside of her bedroom. 

At first, both investigators and Kelcey’s family members thought the fire was an accident. Kelcey lived in an old trailer with a faulty furnace, so it was initially believed that the furnace had caught fire. However, as investigators took a closer look, they noticed that both the front door and the back door of the trailer were unlocked; making it possible for an intruder to enter. Additionally, investigators noted that Kelcey’s body did not appear to be badly burned by the fire. Due to this, investigators initially thought that Kelcey died from smoke inhalation–but once again, as investigators took a closer look, they determined that was not true. Kelcey’s body was covered in bruises, were nose has broken, and she had suffered blunt-force trauma to the head. An autopsy determined was strangled by hand and by a ligature. It was then determined that Kelcey had been murdered, and her killer had set her house on fire afterwards as an attempt to cover it up. 

Jermain Charlo vanished during the early morning hours of June 16th, 2018. The 24 year-old was last seen that morning in Missoula, Montana around 1am. Jermain had been to a few bars in that area during the evening, and was captured on surveillance cameras walking through an alley behind a bar called the Barlander. The footage shows Jermain walking east towards the Orange Street Food Farm. Said footage is the last known sighting of Jermain, and she has never been seen or heard from again.

Jermain is considered missing under suspicious circumstances. Authorities have theorized that she might have fallen victim to sex trafficking or foul play. The detective assigned to Jermain’s case said that as of June 2020, the case is still active, but unfortunately all leads so far have not turned up any clues. In September 2019, an Facebook page with Jermain’s pictures appeared to be actively posting. After investigating the page, it was determined that it was set up by a random woman who was unaware that the pictures she was using were of a missing person. Since then, there has been very little news about Jermain’s case–although detectives have stated that they are continuing to receive leads. 

Jermain’s disappearance brings more awareness to the large number of unsolved cases involving murdered and missing indigenous people. A study funded by the Department of Justice found that in certain areas, Native American women are 10 times more likely to be murdered than the rest of the population (source). Still, cases involving missing and/or murdered Native Americans seem to be reported far less often than similar cases involving white women or men. 

Trevor Hamlyn (33) has been missing since June 16th, 2018. He was last seen at his home in Paradise, Newfoundland. Trevor, who sometimes goes by the nickname ‘Pepsi’, was reported missing by his sister three days later. 

There have been numerous searches for Trevor by family and friends, police, and search crews–but unfortunately they have found nothing that leads to Trevor’s whereabouts. About a month after his disappearance, friends and family conducted an independent ground search near Trevor’s home. During said search, they found a cell phone that was confirmed to belong to Trevor. The phone was sent for analysis, but unfortunately nothing on the phone provided any useful information about this disappearance.

Vanessa Romero had big aspirations for her life during June 2010. 

The 18-year-old was living in Tucson, Arizona and was raising an infant daughter. Vanessa had plans to finish both her GED and a teen parenting class she had been taking. Her long-term plan was to eventually join the Army to make a living for herself and her child. However, before doing that, Vanessa also hoped to donate a kidney to her mother, who was on full dialysis and needed a transplant.

Unfortunately, none of these aspirations would come to fruition, as Vanessa was found deceased at Lakeside Park on the morning of June 16th, 2010. Reports state that Vanessa was found with "obvious signs of trauma" to her body. Although her exact cause of death has never been released to the public, investigators quickly revealed that her manner of death was homicide. 

According to her mother, Vanessa received a phone call around 7:00 PM on June 15th, during which she reportedly argued with the person on the other end of the line. Vanessa's mother said she does not know who Vanessa was speaking with, but believes it was a man she had met a few weeks prior and had just began dating. About an hour and a half later, Vanessa told her mother she was going to go to Dairy Queen to get ice cream and then go to the park.

The following morning, Vanessa's mother was notified that Vanessa's body had been found at Lakeside Park. Vanessa's loved ones were immediately filled with both devastation and questions. Her mother stated that she does not know why Vanessa decided to go to Lakeside Park, located over 10 miles away from her home, when there are other parks much closer to the residence. 

Investigators soon learned that a man had seen Vanessa at the park on the evening June 15th. Said man shared this information with a clerk at a convenience store located less than a mile away from Lakeside Park. The man told the clerk that Vanessa was "having an argument with somebody in the park." The clerk later shared this information with investigators; they subsequently made a public appeal for this customer to come forward. Investigators have never actually revealed if this man ever spoke with them and/or provided any information that brought them any closer to finding Vanessa's killer(s). 

Two years after Vanessa's murder, it was reported that police had questioned the man Vanessa was dating at the time of her death, but reportedly "nothing resulted from that." This man has never been publicly identified, nor has he ever been labeled a suspect. Since that 2012 report, there has been minimal reporting on Vanessa's case.

Jasmine Earl has been missing since June 14th, 2005. The then-18-year-old was last seen in DeKalb County, Georgia. Jasmine was driving a blue 1989 Chevrolet Astro van at the time of her disappearance. She has never been seen or heard from again. 

Several months later, in February 2006, the van that Jasmine was driving was found abandoned in 4600 block of Dawson Road. No further sign of Jasmine was found on the scene. According to family members, the van did not provide any additional clues about Jasmine's disappearance.

There has been very little news reporting about Jasmine's case. However, in late 2005, a thread about her disappearance was created on Websleuths. A cousin of Jasmine's posted to the thread and provided additional details that have not been provided by police or the media. 

The cousin wrote, in part, "What we know so far is that she was last seen at the Washington Mutual bank on Chamblee-Tucker Rd."  According to the cousin, Jasmine's family was told that the bank does not have cameras outside their location. Her whereabouts and actions after leaving the bank remain unknown. 

Jasmine's cousin also posted that it is out of character for Jasmine to be out of touch with her loved ones. Police initially thought that she left on her own accord; however, there does not appear to be any evidence to suggest that she planned to leave to stay out of contact with her family. 

The Websleuths thread has been inactive since 2006/2007. The information provided by the cousin has not been confirmed by authorities, who have overall remained quiet about the investigation into Jasmine's disappearance. As such, there are many unanswered questions. 

The discovery of Jasmine's van is a source of some of those unanswered questions. The vehicle was found in a location approximately 5-6 miles away from Chamblee-Tucker Road. How did it end up in that area? How long had the van been there? Did Jasmine herself park it in the spot where it was found? At this time, all of this information still remains unknown. 

Shannon McClure has been missing since June 15th, 2013. The then-23-year-old was last seen in Sheridan, Wyoming. According to various reports, Shannon’s husband and father-in-law dropped her off at the local Walmart at 3:00 AM. She has never been seen or heard from again. Shannon left behind a one-year-old son and three stepdaughters. Very little other information about her case has been reported about in the news. Various sources containing information about Shannon’s disappearance do not provide an explanation as to why her husband and father-in-law dropped her off at three in the morning and then seemingly left her behind. While it seems likely that the husband and father-in-law were investigated, police have never publicly confirmed it. No arrests have been made in the case, nor have any persons of interest been identified.

19-year old Adrienne Salinas disappeared in the early morning hours on June 15th, 2013, while she and her roommates were hosting a party at their apartment in Phoenix, Arizona. Adrienne is believed to have left her apartment to drive to her boyfriend’s house at approximately 3:40am. About one block from her apartment, she crashed her car into median and blew out two of her tires. A witness to the wreck called 911 to report it at around 3:45am.

Adrienne herself did not report the crash—instead she abandoned her car and returned to her apartment on foot. Her roommates and friends were still partying. Between 4:10am and 4:50am, Adrienne made 32 unanswered calls to her boyfriend. At 4:32am, she called a cab to drive her to her boyfriend’s house and asked the driver to meet her at a nearby convenience store. At 4:53am, her cab driver called her to tell her that he was at the store. She answered and told him she was on her way. However, Adrienne never showed up at the convenience store and the cab driver left after calling her phone one final time at 5:07am. That call went straight to voicemail.

On August 6th, 2013, Adrienne’s partial remains were found in a creek bed 30 miles from where she disappeared. An autopsy was unable to confirm a cause of death and police have not publicly named any suspects or persons of interest in her case. Both Adrienne’s boyfriend and the cab driver who was supposed to pick her up that morning have been cleared of any involvement in her disappearance. The FBI is continuing to investigate the case.

Ryan Esparza has been missing since June 14th, 2007. The then-17-year-old left his home in Pasadena, Texas that day after receiving a phone call from a friend, asking him to meet up at a basketball court at Highlands Park. Ryan was expected back home that evening, but he never returned. He has never been seen or heard from again.

Ryan's mother reported him missing on June 15th. She also reached out to the friend Ryan was meeting at the park that day. Said friend told Ryan's mother that he and Ryan met up and shot hoops at the basketball court for about 20 minutes. Then, according to the friend, Ryan walked away to take a phone call and never returned. 

Investigators searched a five-mile radius around the park but did not find any sign of Ryan. There also did not appear to be any evidence that Ryan ran away. He did not have a history of running away, nor did he have a history of mental illness. Ryan's loved ones do not believe he would walk away from his life. He had a girlfriend who was approximately six months pregnant with his child at the time of his disappearance. The baby, born a few months later, was named Ryan Jr. after his father. 

As the months grew into years without any sign of Ryan, his disappearance grew into a cold case. His mother stated that she had heard rumors over the years that Ryan was accused of stealing marijuana from a childhood friend prior to his disappearance. However, it was reportedly not a large amount of marijuana. Ryan's mother also stated that investigators said they did not find any evidence that these rumors are linked to Ryan's disappearance.

Still, Ryan's mother has grown skeptical of the story told by the other friend with whom Ryan planned to meet at the park that day. In 2023, when asked if she believed the friend's story, Ryan's mother replied, "No, not anymore, because nobody else said he was at that park, so I don't know if he even made it there." This friend has never been publicly identified, and he has not been labeled a suspect.

Jim ‘Anthony’ Hall (23) was brutally murdered by his on-again, off-again girlfriend Samantha Stansifer (20) on June 14th, 2015. Anthony and Samantha had been together on-and-off for about 3 years at the time of the murder. According to Anthony’s family members, their relationship was toxic—however they never imagined it would escalate to murder, as it did that tragic evening in June 2015.

At that point, Anthony and Samantha had broken up yet again, but Samantha was still living with Anthony at his Henryetta, Oklahoma residence. The two of them attended a party together on the evening of June 14th, and while at the party, Samantha noticed that Anthony had text messages from another girl on his phone. The two then began to argue and ended up returning to Anthony’s house. 

Once there, things appeared to calm down briefly. In fact, Samantha and Anthony had almost fallen asleep when Samantha noticed more text messages from the same girl on Anthony’s phone. Samantha then told Anthony she was going to the kitchen to get a drink of water, but instead she grabbed two knives. She then returned and began to stab and mutilate Anthony’s body until he died. 

Afterwards, Samantha seemingly confessed on Facebook, posting, “I did it. He deserved it.” Then, Samantha called the police and told them, “I killed my boyfriend and now I can’t kill myself.” Officers quickly showed up on the scene and Samantha was arrested shortly thereafter.

Jenna Nielsen (22) was weeks away from giving birth to her third child when she was brutally murdered on June 14th, 2007. The young woman was killed while delivering newspapers in Raleigh, North Carolina—a job she did every single morning. Jenna’s body was found shortly after she had been killed, behind the AmeriKing Food Mart on Lake Wheeler Road. Her car was still running nearby, with all of her personal belongings inside. Jenna had been stabbed in the neck.

Police called Jenna’s death ‘completely random’. They have followed numerous leads in the case, but they have not been able to charge anyone for Jenna’s murder. The lead detective on the case told reporters, “every single lead starts to become a dead end and that’s why the case has gone for as long as it has. We just keep having to dig.” The same detective also confirmed that they do have DNA evidence from the crime scene, and they think that it will one day help them solve the case. Still, over a decade has passed since Jenna’s murder and police do not appear to have any suspects.

23 year-old Cynthia Orsborn has been missing since June 14th, 2017. She was last seen at a house in Calvin, Louisiana that she had rented with her boyfriend, Jack “JD” Noble (41). JD told Cynthia’s family members that on the day she went missing, Cynthia got into a car with an unidentified driver and simply rode off. She has never been seen or heard from again.

Both authorities and Cynthia’s family members have doubted JD’s story from the beginning. Cynthia left behind two children, which is uncharacteristic of her. Additionally, JD has a long criminal history dating back to 1997, and many of his crimes involve violence against women. In 2014, JD was charged with rape, assault, and false imprisonment after he attacked a previous girlfriend. Unfortunately, those charges were eventually dropped after the victim never showed up for the trial.

JD and Cynthia began dating the following year, and their relationship had their fair share of issues as well. In November 2016, Cynthia filed an order of protection against JD after multiple reports of domestic disturbances between the two of them. However, the two reconciled a few months later and ended up moving in together while the restraining order was still in effect. 10 days after Cynthia’s disappearance, JD was arrested for violating the protective order. Still, JD has never been charged with anything related to Cynthia’s disappearance—but he remains the only person of interest to this day. Authorities are hoping to get in contact with the victim of the 2014 assault so they can pursue those charges against JD as well.

Cynthia is unfortunately not the only member of her family to go missing. In 2006, Cynthia’s father Michael Orsborn vanished from Provencal, Louisiana and he remains missing today. His car and wallet were located after his disappearance, just a mile away from where he lived. That was the last known trace of him, and he has not been seen or heard from again. There is no indication that Cynthia’s disappearance is related to her father’s disappearance, but their family members are hoping to eventually gain closure in both cases.

Brittany Shante Robinson was only 14 years old when she vanished on June 14th, 2012. She was last seen in Mobile, Alabama, after her aunt dropped her off at the home of her father, Demetric Hooper. Brittany was only supposed to be with her father for a two-day visit, but she never returned home and has never been seen or heard from again. Demetric fled Mobile immediately following Brittany’s disappearance. A warrant for his arrest was issued six weeks later.

Investigators were finally able to track Demetric down in September 2012, at a mental health facility in Arkansas. He suffered from both schizophrenia and drug addiction and had previously been in-and-out of treatment centers in Alabama for years. During September 2012, Demetric reportedly was seeking treatment for his schizophrenia. Once police tracked him down, they confirmed that Brittany was not with Demetric in Arkansas. He was then arrested and charged with felony custodial interference.

After Demetric’s arrest, investigators determined that he had been in Arkansas since July. However, in the weeks following Brittany’s disappearance, he traveled to multiple different locations throughout the southeastern United States. On July 7th, 2012, Demetric took a bus from Memphis, Tennessee to Arkansas, and it was determined that Brittany was not with him during said trip. 

When police finally tracked Demetric down, they found Brittany’s iPod, knives, and a rope in his possession. However, Brittany herself still remained missing.

Marvayah Darby was only 12 years-old when her life was tragically taken during the early-morning hours of June 13th, 2025. The young girl lived with her family in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. She was shot to death at her residence on 5000 block of N. 73rd Street.

The shooting occurred at approximately 1:20 AM. At that time, according to reports, a vehicle pulled up in front of the Darby’s home.Then, a person or persons inside the vehicle fired several rounds at the residence. Some of the bullets traveled into the home and struck Marvayah as she slept in her bedroom. She did not survive and was pronounced deceased by first responders.

The Milwaukee Police Department and the FBI have been searching for Marvayah’s killer(s) since the onset of the investigation. Unfortunately, the case has quickly grown cold; as detectives have been unable to identify any suspects. Investigators have shared that they believe “a silver or gray SUV may have been involved” in the shooting. Other than that, there is no further information about a potential suspect or suspects.

Reports state that the Darby family had moved into the home just a few weeks prior to the shooting. One particular report on the case states that “detectives believe the house itself may have been the target, not Marvayah.” Relatives of the family have stated that they do not know why anyone would want to harm Marvayah or anyone in her family.

Investigators have reportedly interviewed neighbors of the Darby family, classmates of Marvayah, and “anyone listed in gang databases.” Unfortunately, nothing has led detectives to any substantial leads. The FBI has offered a $10,000 reward in exchange for information that leads to the arrest/conviction of Marvayah’s killer(s).

LaKisha Taylor has been missing since June 13th, 2008. The then-27-year-old woman was last seen at the residence she shared with her cousin Sandy Stevenson in Lake Charles, Louisiana. On the morning of LaKisha's disappearance, Sandy went out for breakfast, while LaKisha stayed behind. When Sandy returned, LaKisha was gone. She has never been seen or heard from again.

There are many suspicious circumstances surrounding LaKisha's disappearance. There were no signs of forced entry or a struggle at the home. Additionally, it appeared as if LaKisha vanished while in the midst of getting ready for her day. Her freshly ironed clothes were found lying on her bed; the clothes iron was still on and hot. LaKisha's bathtub was also full of water, as if she planned to take a bath. Her personal items - including her wallet, identification, cell phone, and cash were all left behind. 

Foul play has been suspected in LaKisha's disappearance since the onset of the investigation. At one point, her estranged husband was labeled a person of interest, but he has never been arrested or charged with anything related to her disappearance. Years have passed without any real updates in LaKisha's case.

Ashley Loring Heavyrunner (20) has been missing from Browning, Montana since June 13th, 2017. According to her sister Kimberly Loring, Ashley was last seen that day at Native American Bank, located on Blackfeet Reservation where she lived. Kimberly was on a trip to Africa at the time, and had last spoken to Ashley a week earlier on June 6th. The two sisters spoke about Kimberly’s impending return to her home in Missoula, Montana—located about an hour away from Blackfeet Reservation. Ashley had plans to move out to Missoula once Kimberly returned. However, when Kimberly returned a few weeks later, she was unable to get in touch with Ashley at all. After reaching out to Ashley’s friends, Kimberly learned that nobody had heard from Ashley since early June. After learning this, Ashley’s family members filed a missing persons report with tribal police.

Since Ashley’s disappearance, Kimberly has moved back to the reservation to help search for her sister. She and other family members often spend free time organizing searches in the Rocky Mountains. Kimberly said that law enforcement officials were helpful in the first weeks following Ashley’s disappearance, but now rarely show up when she calls for assistance. This has apparently been an ongoing issue on the reservation; according Blackfeet Tribal Business Council member Carl Kipp, there is a history of unsolved violent crimes on the reservation. Carl said that this is largely in part due to the lack of resources and officers available to investigate.

Genelle Princess Bradford vanished in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania on April 27th, 1999. The then-17-year-old was a senior in high school at the time of her disappearance. Like many seniors in high school, Genelle seemed excited about the upcoming events in her life: her 18th birthday, senior prom, and graduation. However, she vanished before she could experience any of these milestones with her friends and family. 

The day of Genelle's disappearance began as what appeared to be a regular day for the teen. She attended school at Wilkinsburg High, where she was an honor student. Afterwards, Genelle went to her job at the local YWCA on Ross Avenue. The last known sighting of her occurred that evening as she was leaving the YWCA to walk home. Genelle never made it and was never seen alive by her loved ones again.

Genelle's grandparents reported her missing the following day. Shortly after the case was opened, investigators theorized that Genelle had run away from home. Her grandmother, Princess Bradford, seemed to support this theory. 

Princess reportedly noticed that Genelle had changed in the months leading up to her disappearance; her grades were slipping, and she had stopped studying. Princess also told police that, although it was unlikely, Genelle might have run away with a boyfriend. She also mentioned the possibility that Genelle could have been pregnant, which may have motivated her to run away. 

Friends of Genelle, on the other hand, have never believed that she ran away. They shared that she had always been consistent about doing homework and was "obsessed" with having good grades. Her friends also stated that Genelle had been discussing their plans for prom and graduation; there was no indication that she planned to miss those events. 

Decades passed without any sign of Genelle. Throughout that time, she remained classified as a runaway. The differing accounts between her family and friends brought about more questions than answers. It would take 27 years before any major updates in the case.