Niklet

That is such a good scene! I love it because they're clearly so happy, and also because we can see that they're comfortable enough with each other that they can have such teasing, silly moments.

Other funny SVU scenes that come to mind include when Amanda told Carisi the court sketch of him was good in 21x20 in an attempt to cheer him up (which reminds me, I would like to see that sketch one day!).

That episode in s16 when Cragen came back and Carisi introduced himself by saying "Call me Sonny" and Amanda chimes in with something like, "No-one else does" (the look on Carisi's face!).

Also when Carisi introduced Amanda by saying "Call her Sonny" to an out-of-state cop in either 17x01 or 02 (I think it was in the 2-part season opener). Revenge for Amanda's quip from that scene I mentioned above, perhaps? lol (And it also gave the out-of-state cop a reason to say "Sonny Rollins" which I reckon is a bit of a tribute to the actual musician of that name.)

I think in an AU where Carisi was the girls' biological father, Al would never have even had a chance with Amanda, so he wouldn't be around at all!