Radfems:Â âI think sex work should be illegal! That will stop rape and sex trafficking!â
What ACTUALLY happens when sex work is illegal:
âOne of [the police officers] put his hand up my skirt and ripped my underwear off. He slammed me down on the car, he injured me. Um, left me with some broken fingertips, broken toes, fractured cheekbone⌠I was bleeding, I had my skirt ripped⌠people were just mortified because theyâd seen a teenage girl get assaulted by a police officer..â.ââstudy respondent
âPrior to the DOJ investigation, an internal investigation by the BCPD found an officer receiving sex from a sex worker in exchange for money and immunity from arrest. The case was closed without any attempt to gather more evidence, interview the police officer, or prosecute the officer. Cases were opened for the same officer a second and third time for the same offense. The witness for the third case died before she could be interviewed, and only then did the BCPD review the officerâs phone records and discover that he had sent sexually explicit messages to a number of female sex workers. The officer was allowed to retire. The DOJ found similar cases involving other officers.â
âI was solicited by a police officer who said that if I had sex with him he wouldnât arrest me. So I did. Then afterwards he cuffed me and pressed charges anyway.â
âI was going to meet a new john, it turned out to be a sting set up by the cops. He got violent with me, handcuffed me and then raped me. He cleaned me up for the police station and I got sentenced to four months in jail for prostitution.â
âI keep being arrested in Rogers Park just for standing still. They keep taking me in for prostitution even though Iâm not doing anything at all. Itâs the same white cop doing it too.â
âWhen being held in protective custody [because they said I was a victim of human trafficking] they started withholding my sheets, then towels, then pillows, then food because they said I wasnât telling them everything I couldâwhen in fact I was.â
(Claiming non trafficking victims are actually trafficking victims as justification for abusing them - Hey, radfems, the police are stealing your tactics!)
âTwenty four percent of street-based sex workers had been raped by a police officer. Twenty percent had experienced other sexual assault from police officers. Women doing survival sex and women in drug houses experienced a lot of violence from police. Thirty percent of exotic dancers who had been raped were raped by police, and twenty percent of the sexual violence they experienced was committed by police. Twenty five percent of escorts had been robbed by a police officer. Eighteen percent of escorts had been forced to masturbate a police officer.â
âOne respondent was given the choice between arrest and doing something âdisgustingâ. She wouldnât tell the researcher what she was asked to do, but she told the other police officers at the station about it and they laughed at her.
A respondent was asked by an officer to show her breasts in order to avoid arrest. Another respondent had charges dropped because of police misconduct; the officer who arrested her had her perform oral sex on him.â
âOne respondent was arrested because she refused to have sex with the officers who arrested her. Another was asked by an officer for sex, but she was afraid it was a set up and said no.â
âSurvey respondents said that police profiled transgender people as sex workers and subjected them to verbal abuse and sexual misconduct, including demands for sex in exchange for leniency. Police were arresting people for solicitation if they carried condoms. Even trans sex workers who werenât arrested for carrying condoms saw it happen to others and where afraid to carry condoms. Some police officers used possession of condoms to coerce trans sex workers into providing free sexual services.
People who tested positive for HIV while in jail were visited by an HIV task force that scheduled appointments at a clinic. However, many people were rearrested before their scheduled appointment. One woman was arrested ten times in three years, preventing her from going to any scheduled appointments to receive care for her HIV infection during that period. Jail interrupts taking medication on a regular basis.â
(I know radfems donât care about trans people though. Yâall are definitely celebrating the New Orleans situation as a success.)
âExamples of police language:
bitch
ho
slut
youâre not dead yet?
we gotta go clean up the trash
why should we help you?â
(Again, I know radfems approve of this. This is how they talk to me.)
Police raped me a couple of times in Queens. The last time that happened was a couple of months ago. But you donât tell anybody. You just deal wit it.âânineteen year old female
âPolice officers propositioned underage youth and made lewd comments. Most female youth in the study reported trading sex to avoid arrest. Pimps were not arrested or received less jail time than the youth that worked with them, even when one of the youths was identified as fourteen years old.â
Thirty percent of the respondents reported threats of violence from the police, and twenty seven percent reported experiencing violence. One respondent said âIâve seen cops get out of a car and beat a girl, and then get back in the car and leave.â Another said that her greatest fear during arrest was ânot coming home at all.â The white woman from the Bronx said â⌠they throw you on the floor and they step on youâŚâ
Another respondent reported seeing officers injure a women in the pelvic area to prevent her from working. â⌠it was like he was squeezing a handball or something, but really really hard⌠it was two guys in a car and they drove up on the sidewalk. He pushed her against the wall and then he pushed her against the wall after he finished that and then he said ânow get off the streetââŚ-respondent
âOne likes to beat me now and then, or he wants me to suck his dick. I mean, itâs crazy. He hits me with his gun and gives me these marks on my legs and my back. I donât know what to doâŚI canât call the other cops. I did that once and they asked this guy to stop beating me. But he got so mad that he came around and beat me up even worse. So I really have to get out of here. Now he wants me to give him 25% of what I makeâŚI had to go to the hospital because I got beat so bad. âârespondent
â4% of respondents described being threatened with arrest unless they had sex with a police officer. 8% said they were arrested after having sex with a police officer. 5% said they were arrested after refusing to have sex with a police officer. 40% of interactions with police officers during the previous three months were bad or very bad.â
38.5% of survey respondents reported being humiliated or verbally abused by police during relatively minor interactions such as checking ID. One respondent said the officer called her a whore, prostitute, and trick. During 8.6% of these interactions, officers confiscated or destroyed safe sex supplies, including condoms. 17.3% of respondents said that police-initiated interactions involved the officer asking for sexual services, or demanding sexual services to avoid arrest. 9.1% of respondents reported being assaulted by police officers. 3 respondents reported strip searches.
Seventy eight respondents were profiled as sex workers and ordered to âmove along.â The most common result of this was that they ended up in an area where they felt less safe.
75% of trans people and 82.4% of Latinos said they were treated worse than others when they were in lock up.
When the survey respondents initiated contact with the police, usually to report a crime, in a number of cases the police tried to have sex with them. This seemed to be particularly true of trans Latinas.
Studies not limited to certain areas
âPolice abuse of sex workers includes verbal insults, coerced sex, brutal beatings, and rape. When police know that a woman is a sex worker, they may harass her when she is not working.The most common abuses are verbal abuse and threats to arrest sex workers if the police donât receive sexual services. Police often assume that sex workers donât care who they will have sex with and will do anything to avoid arrest. But experienced street-based sex workers often refuse to provide free services. They are resigned to frequent arrests, including arrests for questionable charges. What they want to avoid are fear and indignity forced on them by bad officers.â
âDuring arrest or taking someone into custody, police often degrade or humiliate sex workers, including removing wigs or clothing, confiscating or destroying property, making homophobic, anti-transgender, and racists slurs, and engaging on sexual harassment. Organizations working with sex workers have documented a pattern of police practice that includes assault, sexual harassment, public strip searches for the purpose of viewing genitalia, and rape. This pattern of practice is supported by the difficulty or impossibility of obtaining justice in these cases.â
âWhen sex workers try to report crimes against them, officers donât take their complaints seriously, refuse to file a report, and may arrest them, physically assault them, or pressure them for sex. When a sex worker tried to bring charges against a security guard who handcuffed and raped her, the police referred to the guard as âa big teddy bearâ, and added exculpatory statements to her report that she didnât make. This refusal to deal with crimes against sex workers leads serial killers to target sex workers and people profiled as sex workers.â
âSix of the twelve women who had been trafficking victims left their trafficking situation without help from law enforcement, through the help of a coworker or an attorney they met through a coworker or friend. Nationwide, it appears that the majority of trafficking victims escape without the involvement of law enforcement. One supervisor in a national organization said that 90% of their cases were not produced by raids or identified by law enforcement.â
Of the six trafficking victims picked up in law enforcement raids, one would have left her situation in a few days if she had not been picked up in a raid and arrested. As a result of the raid, she was pistol-whipped by a police officer and incarcerated.Â
Her conclusion: âA better way to help leave my situation would be anything that didnât involve the police.â