Luther Wainwright: (The Mentalist) - Chapter 4
He thought for sure it would take longer, but youâd come back after two days completely neutral. You reported to him, spoke to him.
It was as if the whole thing didnât happen.
Thatâs when he realized it.
Your approach was to just put it behind you and move on.
He expected nothing less.
There was nothing he could do about the matter, so he decided to focus on his job. It was the only thing he had that could squash the bitter feelings in his chest.
~
âJane, I need your help.â
When you pulled him to the side, he could tell it was serious. Heâs not oblivious to the tension. For the last couple days you havenât so much as spared a glance in Wainwrightâs direction. Youâve also started to take the stairs every morning from the sound of your winded breathing when you come in sometimes.
Youâve become cautious, careful. Jane is positive he knows why.
âWhatâs wrong?â
âI..I need you to hypnotize me.â
Thereâs a subtle look of confusion, then recognition.
âYou want to forget about Wainwright.â
You nod, pulling at the bottom of your shirt.
âI have to do this job, I canât do that knowing what I do. I need to forget, I have too.â
âYou donât mean that.â
You stammer.
âW-What are you talking about of course I do!â
âYou think thatâs the right decision, but Iâm sure you realize thatâs wrong. If you didnât share those feelings you would have been able to easily look past it. If you forget, youâll regret it forever.â
âJane please.â
Youâre begging and he shakes his head, taking your hand.
âIâm sorry but I canât.â
It takes a lot for him to walk away, especially with you in that state. But he does, sending you a sympathetic smile.
You stand there, defeated. Jane was the only viable option.
What exactly are you supposed to do now?
Quit, change units?
No.
Wainwright is the one who started this mess. You shouldnât have to pay for it. You just need to work.
Work will keep you grounded.
It has too.
For the next couple days, thatâs what you do.
âRemember, just get him talking, we donât have much on him so we canât take him in. We just need to stall until Rigsby and Vanpelt find some evidence.â
Youâve done this more than once, so you donât get why sheâs being so overly cautious.
âI got it boss, Iâm going in.â
So you did.
For the most part you did have it under control. The problem was heâd been trying to grope you all evening. Towards the end Lisbon had given you the signal. They found the weapon, as well as the bloodied clothes. So you were about to leave. With a friendly smile you made an excuse about needing to go because you were getting tipsy. You left the bar, and heâd followed you out.
At this point he was holding your wrist.
âI really should get going, Vince.â
âCome on sweetheart, donât be like that, let's have some fun.â
His hand gropes your butt and that feels like the last straw. You spin around, landing a harsh blow. His head whips to the side, and you reach into your pocket, pulling out your cuffs.
âCBI, youâre under arrest.â
You shove him against a car just as Lisbon and Jane break the corner.
âShe punched me in the nose!â
âYou grabbed my butt, thatâs assault.â
Jane is smiling as you restrain Vince. Lisbon takes over, sending you a look.
âAre you sure youâre okay (L/N)?â
âYes, why wouldnât I be?â
She says nothing, just nods, taking the idiot away.
âNice hook.â Jane compliments.
Of course he would enjoy that.
After that, everything just falls in place. Heâs being booked and itâs not even 4pm yet.Â
Another win.
On to the next case.
âI think you should take the rest of the day off.â Lisbon says.
Thatâs not what you wanted to hear.
âWhat! Why? Because I sucker punched the guy? Heâs a moron and a killer.â
âYesterday you drop-kicked a suspect.â
âHe had a knife!â You defend.
âBe that as it may, it's obvious that you have some things to sort out. Iâll see you tomorrow.â
You canât believe it. Sheâs benching you for doing your job. With a grumble, you pull your jacket off the back of your chair as you walk away angrily.
The days just seem to go from bad to worse lately.
~~
Thereâs a soft knock on the door. For a moment you assume itâs Lisbon, coming to give you a pep talk or inquire about what has you so agitated.
When you open the door, the last person you expected to see at your door late that night is Wainwright.
Although given your behavior lately you arenât surprised.
âSir, is there something I can help you with?â
You should remain professional.
âIâm just doing a wellness check, can I come in?â
You should scream no and slam the door in his face, but that will surely cause you to get fired. Youâre on thin ice as it is.
âCome in.â
He enters, and you suddenly become aware that youâre not exactly sporting an outfit appropriate for company. Youâre just in a baggy t-shirt. Itâs long enough to hide the fact that youâre only wearing underwear.
âAgent Lisbon informed me of some incidents lately. Should I be concerned?â
You frown.
âNo sir, everything is under control.â
âReally, because usually I donât get complaints about my agents dropping kicking witnesses, or punching them in the nose.â
âHe came at me first, I just reacted.â
âA drop kick seems more than excessive.â
âWhat exactly would you suggest I do then? Just let him jump me with a knife!â
It didnât take a genius to see that you were annoyed. Wainwright stepped closer, eyes a bit worried.
âIs there something I should know about? Is everything alright (L/N)?â
The soft way he was now speaking just added to your frustration. Itâs unfair. He has no right to look at you like that. Like heâd face the most awful criminal just to protect you.
âThis is all your fault, why the hell did you have to tell me about your feelings! I even tried to get Jane to hypnotize me so Iâd forget about it. All I can think about now is you and itâs driving me crazy. How am I supposed to do my job like this?!â
Confessing all of this was the last thing you should be doing, especially to your boss.
âSlow down, did you say you tried to get Jane to hypnotize you?â
You felt stupid.
Taking a step back you wrapped your arms around yourself protectively.
âI was fine when you were just this mean superior face we had to report to. Why the hell did you have to say anything to make that change..â
You look defeated, and he feels guilty.
âIâm sorry.â
âSorry isnât good enough.â
He knows that nothing he can say will make up for what has already been said. He sees the tears and it adds to his turmoil.
âPlease, please donât cry, I can't..â
He canât deal with it, seeing you so hurt. Against his better judgment he moves in and youâre caught off guard when he hugs you. You should offer some resistance, but his hands wrapped so protectively around your body is heavenly. Youâve always prided yourself on being strong, independent. When he holds you, you feel like you can lower that guard. His hand slides down your back and you return the embrace.
âIâm sorry, Iâm so sorry (Y/N).â
He keeps apologizing and you feel like youâre going to fall apart all over again.
This is his fault, so why are you feeling sorry for him? Youâre the one in a shitty position. The one whoâll be judged if anyone found out. Youâve worked hard to get where you are. He more than anyone should understand that.
You should hate him for putting you in this situation.
Yet..
As you pull away, you look at him. Truly look at him.
His eyes hold such tenderness that warms you. Janeâs words are engraved in your mind. You know deep down heâs right. If you didnât return those feelings this would have easily been brushed aside. Some part of you must feel this attraction, thatâs why itâs so hard for you.
When you look at him, he almost forgets about it all. The fact that the last thing he should be doing is touching you so softly. Thereâs too much temptation standing here in your home. He should leave. You look calmer. Heâs done his job.
âI should leave.â
You seem to collect yourself, and you nod.
Heâs still awfully close.
âOf course, have a safe trip back home sir.â
Sir.
Why does that suddenly irritate him? Itâs the distance, it has to be. That word is built on professionalism. Something that heâd very much like to get rid of right now. His hand brushes your cheek and you look up.
âSir..?â
âStop calling me that.â
He doesnât voice those words. He wouldnât dare too, but he wishes at that moment that he was someone else. He wishes he could get you to indulge his fantasy, but it would be wrong. Youâre still vulnerable. You rely on him, he shouldnât.
âLuther.â
That name surprises him, and heâs about to say something, but you pull him in. Eyebrows rising he nearly jumps out of his skin. It must be an illusion. Thereâs no way that youâre actually kissing him.
Not a second after he registers it, heâs kissing you back. His hands tighten on your waist and you gasp when he backs you into the wall. Everything about him exudes strength and youâre shocked yourself when you grab his free hand and press it against your chest. He squeezes and you moan, opening your mouth for him to explore. He takes the invitation happily. Youâre both barely apart long enough to catch a proper breath. Heâs touching everything, exploring everything. You barely process it when his hand finds its way under your shirt.
Another hand slides between your legs and you finally get yourself to pull away to level your breathing. He still has you against the wall and youâre looking at him with a hint of awe and lust. He takes it in. He knows itâs wrong, but he loves the fact that youâre so rattled by him. So responsive. You're gripping at his shoulder.
âL-Luther..â
You sound so desperate. He never thought it would sound this good, coming from your lips.
âIâm sorry.â
Heâs still apologizing, because heâs the one that should have walked away. Heâd accept any hateful words you would have right now.
When you look at him, hate is the last emotion you feel. Youâre just so lost on how you never realized before. His eyes emit an attraction that was more than just physical. How have you been around him for this long and never once suspected it? Better yet, how has he been able to function with these feelings all this time. Any other person would have broken down much sooner. But heâd probably talked himself into it everyday. Maintaining the mask. Keeping a front. Protecting himself. The same way you were determined to shelter yourself from any pain.
Right now, thereâs only one thing you both need more than anything.
âDonât stop Luther.â
He shakes his head.
âYou donât mean that.â
âI do.â
He presses his hand to the wall as he finally releases you, burying his face into your shoulder.
âPlease donât say it..if you donât mean it."
Youâve never seen this man vulnerable.
Taking his cheeks in your hands, you lift his head. His eyes search for it, that fear, or maybe even disgust. All you do is smile.
You really were blind.
âIf you stop now I wonât forgive you.â
An empty threat that brings him comfort.
You squeal when he picks you up, and you hold on, staring at him.
âPlease donât let this be a dream.â
His words seem to have become more honest. You just kiss him, and he responds, heading straight for your room.Â

















