Could I have a John x fem reader where the reader reacts to John winning (but still beat tf up) in a bar fight?
Thanks bestie <3
Eyyy of COURSE you can bestie?! I have been practicing writing John, and I may not be the best, but I think I'm confident in my abilities. I think. But here, have a fun, flirty little brawl with your man~
"Trouble" ||
John Marston x f!Reader
Length: 2.1k
Rating: Mature: Mentions of blood, fighting, language
How John ended up in this situation was honestly beyond him, it was just an innocent outing with you and him running some errands for the ranch, and yet he was getting fist after fist pounded into his face.Â
After a long day of working, you could tell he was going stir-crazy. His old life was all about freedom and running around, doing things to bring in money or just getting to do as he pleased, but now? He was on a ranch, pretending to be someone he wasnât to get by, and his trigger finger was beginning to itch. But to make you happy, to keep your heads low, and to survive, John had to behave and live as his persona for the time being.Â
âSo, Jim,â you said with a smirk, âmaybe we should stop at a saloon since itâs getting dark, we could eat a decent meal, maybe stay in a hotel for the night. Iâm tired,â you sighed and leaned your head against the manâs shoulder.Â
John matched your sigh and flicked the reigns on the horses as he pulled them to the right, heading into Valentine's territory, which he hadnât expected to be back here so soon. âI mean, it is a long way back, we could use the rest. And I am starvinâ, could use something that isnât a stew for once.âÂ
You both pulled the wagon off and made sure the horses were comfortable, hitched to a nearby post, and then John helped you down to the ground and smiled wide with his arm wrapped around your waist. âWell, letâs get inside, maybe we can get a bath before bed, too,â he said softly with a smirk. He pulled you along and walked beside you, looking around the town that felt so different from when he was last here.Â
As you both entered the saloon, you definitely could tell that the environment was more lively, but you both tried to keep your wits about you as you ordered some food and sat in the corner, away from the rowdy group of people. The food was delicious and the conversation you shared was pleasant, as usual, but John couldn't shake the feeling that eyes kept falling on you both. He'd look away from you as he stopped mid-sentence to see one of the men staring at the both of you, but he tried to pay no mind, you were taking his attention.Â
The food was finished and you both were feeling content, the party of people in the saloon only grew larger in number and louder in volume, so you both figured it was time to head out to the hotel for the evening. John allowed you to walk out first so he could follow behind you, but you had barely gotten several steps toward the door when one of the men stepped in front of your path, blocking you from the exit.
âHey there now, y'all ain't planninâ on cominâ over to celebrate with us?âÂ
âSorry, friend, but we have other plans to attend to,â John answered firmly.Â
The man just scoffed, the reek of booze was strong on his breath, it was a wonder he was still standing. âAww c'mon, my friend over there is gettinâ married, you could have one drink to congratulate him!â
âSorry sir, but we don't even know you,â you said sharply, stepping back from him, and bumping into John. You felt a bit more at ease since he was here.
âAnd? You ain't heard of makinâ friends?â The man chuckled and grabbed your arm, pulling you along toward the table. He then decided to yank your arm and attempt to pull you over toward the table, but John stepped up and grabbed his wrist hard.Â
âWe ain't interested, sir. My woman and I are heading out for the eveninâ, so maybe next time you should use your brain and not touch a lady when she says no.âÂ
John pushed the man away so you both had room to leave, but some of the drunkâs friends decided to get involved.Â
John stepped up protectively, his spine stiffened as his hand hovered over the knife that was holstered, hidden beneath his jacket. âSir, you got till the count of three to back off and leave us alone,â he warned.Â
There had been a taller man who stood up from the table and interjected, pushing his friend gently off to the side. âAre you threateninâ us?â He snapped.Â
âI âspose I am,â John retorted, holding his ground as he pushed you further behind him to shield you.Â
Another of the man's friends stepped up and tried to land a surprise swing on John, but he pushed you out of the way and took the hook to his shoulder. After that, John was brawling with several of the men who ganged up on you both. The one in the red shirt had tried to grab John to put him in a headlock so his friends could take their turns wailing on him, but your John was fast. He elbowed Red and kicked his leg in, causing the man to fall flat on his face.
That was one downâthree more to go.
âI ainât been in a bar fight in a long time,â John commented as he had both arms up, ready to block any attacks if needed, âbut Iâd rather continue my night with my lady if you gentlemen donât mind.â
The three other men all ignored him and each one tried to punch him at different intervals to throw him off, but somehow, John managed to throw one man into the other and watched as the two tumbled straight into a table. The others who occupied the saloon were standing back and vacating the building. The bartender just sighed and walked off, not wanting to be part of yet another brawl. That left you, standing on the stairs away from the tussle.Â
The gunslinger looked back and you, making sure you were out of harm's way, then he got back to it. The two men who collided with the table were too drunk to stand, and all they did was stumble over one another. There was one left standing, and he was a little larger than the others.Â
âLook, I can just leave, no reason you gotta get involved,â John said nonchalantly, his stance easing up a little.
The man just glared down at him and he scoffed at the offer. âYou ruined my engagement celebration, mister, I donât take so kind to that.â
John just sighed and lifted his hands again, balling them into fists. âAlright then, have it your way,â he replied.
The man took a fast step forward and swung his fist straight at Johnâs jaw, and if it werenât for the speed, maybe John would have dodged it, instead, he got nicked against his chin, which still caught him enough to cause some pain. That was all the distraction the man needed to step in and lunge at John, his larger body barreled into him and tackled him to the floor.
You let out a yelp, terrified that the man was going to have a one-up on John, and all you could do was watch in fear as your hands gripped the railing in fear.Â
The gunslinger was pinned onto the floor as the man above him threw punch after punch, landing a blow on his cheek, and almost breaking his nose at one point. John held up his arms to block and tried his best to use the strength from his legs to somehow get him to slip off, and he managed to throw the man off of him for a split second. He scrambled to find some balance, then rolled off to the side as the man recovered.Â
âGive up yet?â John asked with a smirk on his face as he licked the blood from his split lip, the bruises on his face forming fast.
The man just yelled out in frustration and then John had him in a blind frenzy, which made any man messy in a fight. John ducked from the swing and swung his right arm quickly, the blow landed in the side of the manâs temple, stunning him momentarily. Then it was over, John was finally standing over him and landing punch after punch in the manâs face until he fell unconscious. The gunslinger released the manâs collar, allowing his body to fall slack onto the wooden floor.Â
He looked up at you, panting to catch his breath as he straightened his posture. The people who occupied the saloon had all either hidden somewhere or run off, and there were just the two of you left with the pile of unconscious men scattered about on the floor. You waited a moment before hesitantly walking down the stairs to run into his arms, thankful he was alright despite being a little black and blue.Â
âAs always youâre my hero,â you chuckled and reached up to touch his face, wiping away a smear of blood from his lip.Â
âAnd as always, weâre both gettinâ into trouble,â he replied gruffly.
You just scoffed. âWe?âÂ
âWell yeah, youâre my accomplice, partner in crime, ainât you?â He asked as if it was the most obvious thing in the world. âPlus youâre the one always gettinâ the attention,â John teased as he slipped his arm through yours. He pulled you along and threw a couple of bills onto the countertop, then escorted you outside and across the muddly way, leading you straight to the hotel.Â
You both walked inside, the environment a complete flip from the saloon, and you were more at ease now, and even more thankful when you saw the list of services. The gentleman behind the counter stopped sweeping the floor and greeted you both with a kind smile.
âHowdy, how can I help yâall this eveninâ?â He looked between the both of you with concern but didnât voice them.Â
Your eyes looked over at John with a smile and then back at the desk man. âOne bath and one room, please.â
The man smiled and got everything situated for you both, you thanked him and paid, then pulled John up the stairs to the bath. He followed obediently and cracked his neck as he ascended the stairs with you, groaning.
âSleepinâ is gonna be a bitch, I just know it,â he complained.
âWell if you behaved for five minutes you wouldnât have to worry about it, would you?â You scolded playfully as you looked over your shoulder at him. âHe got some good hits in, but not gonna lie, Mister Marston, you looked really good kickinâ his ass.â You flashed him a cheeky smile and continued to lead him to the bath. âYou go get cleaned up, Iâll get the room ready.âÂ
You almost walked away, leaving him in front of the bath door, but his hand grabbed your wrist, and then he pulled you back toward him, falling into him as his arms wrapped around you. âYeah? You think I looked good, huh?â He asked flirtatiously, pulling you close so his face was mere inches from yours. âThen why do you think you can just leave me here alone?â âJohn Marston, are you implyinâ Iâm gonna join you in your bath?â You gasped, faux shock crossed your features.Â
All he could do was smile, the raised edges of the scars across his face made his face look extra handsome, and the dim lighting in the hall only made you admire his face even more. âNah, Iâm declarinâ that you are, unless you donât wanna?â His hands cupped your cheeks, pulling you into the most tender kiss he could manage.Â
When he pulled away, your eyes fluttered open and you just stared up at him with a lovestruck smile. âWell, when you put it that wayâŚâ
That was all the confirmation he needed, so he opened the door to the readied hot bath, pulling you in after him, and you couldnât help but giggle as he closed the door behind you both. You sighed as he leaned your hands against his chest, just smiling up at him with that look.
âI know that look, what is it?âÂ
âNothinâ, youâre just trouble, John Marston,â you said softly, your hand cupped his cheek again, mindful of how gentle you had to be. âBut I wouldnât change it for the world, you know that, right?â
The man looked down at you and pulled you into another kiss, pulling away a moment later with that charming smile you were unable to resist, his hand reached up to brush your hair away from your face so he could see the light in those pretty eyes of yours. Just a minor setback to your shared evening, but John always had ways to make it up to you.Â









