The Creel house is creepy as fuck and Eddie is not a fucking fan. They leave their shoes on the porch, creeping slowly, quietly on socked feet to the front window so theyāll be able to see Ericaās light signal from the park. Steveās got his walkman on, Gloria Gaynor singing in his ears. From the front pocket of Eddieās new utility vest, he pulls the two small notebooks and pencils they grabbed for communication.
He writes āHiā and flips it around to Steve who smiles and rolls his eyes fondly before writing āHiā back.Ā
Then Steve scribbles on the next page, āYouāre different than I thought.ā
Eddie shrugs and writes, āYou too.ā
āCan I tell you a secret?ā Eddie writes, hands trembling a little.
Steve pretends to be thinking hard and then smiles and nods.
Swallowing around the fear in his throat, Eddie puts his pencil to paper. He canāt believe heās going to do this but heās facing down a murderer in the murdererās own house and he walked through a Hell dimension. And thereās just something about Steve. A peaceful acceptance. Eddie thinks it might be okay. To tell him.Ā
If Steve can be brave enough to put himself in danger again and again, Eddie can be brave enough to do this.Ā
āIām gay.ā He writes, letting out a long breath and staring at it for a few seconds before holding it up and showing Steve. Eddie probably looks as terrified as he feels. God, he hopes heās not fucking this up.
Steve blinks several times, expression dazed and Eddieās stomach clenches. Then Steve bends over his notepad, scribbling and brings it up to show Eddie, āThank you for trusting me with that.ā
Eddie lets out the breath heād been holding very slowly, his relief must be obvious because Steve smiles encouragingly and then flips the page quietly, writing on the next. Then he flips it and writes on the next as well. When he holds it up, he flips the first page back, āI like girls.ā
Nodding, Eddie doesnāt let his disappointment show. Of course Steve is straight. Heās the Hawkins High heartthrob. He was in love with Nancy Wheeler and whatever he has going on with Robin is obviously strong enough to pull him back from literal Hell.
Still holding up the notepad, Steve flips the second page, it reads, ā...and sometimes boys.ā
He looks nervous but also kind ofā¦hopeful, maybe? Eddie has to cover his mouth to keep silent but then he writes, āCoolā and shows Steve who rolls his eyes and shakes his head.
Eddieās just gathering the courage - or stupidity depending on how it was gonna go - to ask Steve on a date when Ericaās light flashes from across the street. He fumbles the flashlight for a moment and then flashes back.
Read Part One on Ao3Ā Read the Rest of Part Two