Thursday Thoughts: Structure, Flexibility, and Torah
(I wrote this dâvar for tomorrowâs Shabbat evening services. Turns out I wonât be leading services tomorrow after all - so Iâm sharing it here instead!)
I love being a Jew. I see it as an active thing â BEING a Jew. Living a Jewish life, making Jewish choices, taking part in our rich, meaningful traditions and fulfilling the mitzvot of the Torah.
However, if I said that I was living a Jewish life in every possible way â making all Jewish choices, taking part in all our traditions, and fulfilling all mitzvot â that would be a lie.
Those of you who come to Shabbat services regularly on Friday nights know that you will nearly always find me here, now. However, if you also come on Saturday morning, then you know that you will almost never find me there, then. I bake challah, but I do not light Shabbat candles. I take time off from my day job on Jewish holidays when I can, but Iâm not always able to. I eat kosher foods, but I do not have kosher dishes, since I share my kitchen with three people who do not keep kosher.
I do what I can. Sometimes, I feel like Iâm not doing enough.
Itâs easy to imagine that G-d might also think that Iâm not doing enough. After all, there are 613 mitzvot in the Torah. If your boss gave you an employee handbook with 613 rules for employee conduct, then you would assume that this is a strict boss with a very structured work environment, someone who wants you to obey their instructions without fail or flexibility.
But this weekâs parsha makes it clear that âobey without fail or flexibilityâ is not an entirely accurate description of G-dâs expectations for Jewish people.
This week we read Parshat Vayikra â the beginning of the book of Leviticus. Incidentally, Leviticus has 243 of the 613 mitzvot â more than any other book in the Torah.
(If youâre curious, second place goes to Deuteronomy at 203 mitzvot, Exodus comes in third at 109, Numbers is fourth at 56, and Genesis has only two.)
So, Leviticus is the Big Book of Rules, right? In Vayikra, the start of this book, there are a lot of rules about making offerings at the temple. These are sin offerings. A person would admit wrongdoing and atone for their sin by making the offering. In Leviticus chapter 5 verse 6, the Torah explains, âhe shall bring his guilt offering to the Lord for his sin which he had committed, a female from the flock, either a sheep or a goat, for a sin offering.â
But it doesnât end there. The next verse, verse 7, reads âBut if he cannot afford a sheep, he shall bring as his guilt offering for that [sin] that he had committed, two turtle doves or two young doves before the Lord.â
And then if we jump ahead a couple verses, to verse 11, the Torah reads, âBut if he cannot afford two turtle doves or two young doves, then he shall bring as his sacrifice for his sin one tenth of an ephah of fine flour for a sin offering.â
(An ephah is a unit of measurement here, and according to Google, itâs about the size of a bushel. So you would bring a tenth of a bushel of flour. Iâm not sure exactly how big that is, but it doesnât sound like much. Certainly it sounds less than a whole sheep.)
So â the commandment here, the mitzvah, is to make a sin offering. And through the Torah, G-d gives specific instructions about what to bring and what to do with it â you bring a sheep, and this is how you kill it. Itâs a structure for atonement. But the Torah also provides exceptions or alternate options for this sin offering. If you canât bring a sheep, bring two doves, and if you canât bring two doves, bring some flour. The Torah provides structure, and it also provides different structures depending on your individual means.
In doing so, the Torah takes a behavior that could be very limited â something that only rich people could do, the people who could afford to give up an animal because they had plenty more to eat or breed â and turns it into something that anyone could do, within their means, in the way that works best for them. Itâs flexible. Itâs also encouraging in a way â having these different options for how to participate in the mitzvah makes the whole idea of making sin offerings feel more accessible for anyone.
And this ties in well with how I see and experience Judaism. Itâs accessible for all of us. Yes, thereâs structure. Judaism includes instructions for every part of our lives. And like I said before, itâs an active thing. I donât think that you can really BE a Jew if you arenât doing ANYTHING thatâs Jewish.
But you donât need to do EVERYTHING.
You donât need to obey EVERY commandment in exactly the same way as everyone else in order to live a Jewish life, make Jewish choices, and participate in the Jewish community. G-d empowers all of us to show up when we can, and how we can, in the way that works best for us, to create a meaningful life as Jews. For me, tonight, that means standing up here in front of you, delivering this dâvar. Last week, it meant sitting in the back row with my friends, and next week, it will mean traveling home to spend Passover with my family. And every week, every day, we get to make those Jewish choices, to create our Jewish life. Shabbat shalom.