I think Vampire smp x Life series could work really well for a reincarnation au. Say Scott Goldsmith dies in Oakhurts and then reincarnates into life series Scott( using all series). He could get flash backs to his his past life, and you could have the survivors of Oakhurts(maybe 200-400 years after Oakhurst) could run into him. I think the would freak out and try to figure out why “Scott” was alive. But then figure out that Scott reincarnated. I think it might work better if it’s one other life series/vampire smp people so the build up grows till the camp/life series meme bet introduces the vampire smp cas to the cast of the life series, them seeing Scott could lead to very dramatic scene. For continuity reasons you could have Martyn, Ren and Pearl having also reincarnatied. It could add to the potential conficts with the vampire smp cast, who are seeing people like Scott and Ren, who hated each other being friendsI also think Esmp2 Scott could work well with this, he’s already awares of the mystical and very charismatic. I think this might work even better because you wouldn’t have to figure out the coming back to life part. Actually you could have all the lifers being some sort of paranormal creature( Scott not being a vampire preferably, for the drama) so they could easily come back as long as they weren’t hit with something specific. I saw another idea that could work here, Ls Scott was either a hula or an elf but after last life he was turned into something by the watchers. Pearl as a either a harpy or a werewolf, Martyn I think should be kinda like. Vampire thrall bit for water or a listener, and Ren maybe as a wolf kitsune or a werewolf. Or maybe a vampire for the drama.