More possibly unpopular opinions that I've been dying to get off my chest...
If what looks like's going to happen actually does tonight, then I have a couple of thoughts.
First, if it is absolutely certain that George Eads never plans on coming back to the show, then I think giving Jack a proper (if not utterly heart-rending) send off is ultimately better than this silenced limbo on the matter. I am the kind of person who can't stand the will they/won't they for very long. I do understand if there are people who prefer to have that suspension of hope, but I'd rather have some kind of resolution, one way or the other.
Also, I feel like this course of action (again, only if they are 100% certain Eads will never want to come back) is so much more respectful to his character than just going on like he doesn't exist.
Think of it this way: The characters would now be *forced* to acknowledge him and what he means to them again. This might be the best way for Jack to get the proper goodbye and recognition that he deserves.
And if he does die, I feel like the show can continue to go on much in the same way it did before, except now (hopefully) with a little bit more mention of and angst surrounding him.
I know I'm probably in the minority here, but I still love the show just as much as I did when he was on it (though I do miss him very much). Perhaps that's because Mac is my favorite character and I never really watched exclusively for Jack. I don't know.
But even though I miss the crap out of him and am really frustrated that he wasn't even mentioned in S4, the fourth season is actually my favorite storywise. I love the overarching story, the darker tones, the emotional turmoil Mac goes through, the conflict and loss and watching him deal with it.
Again, let me reiterate that I love Jack and never wanted him to leave.
But I do think that some of what came out of his departure was good for Mac's character. He was forced to face this darkness without his partner by his side, and the lack of this dependency on Jack gave him no choice but to develop emotionally as a character in a way he wouldn't have been able to with Jack as support.
I actually really like Russ. I don't think he's supposed to be a replacement for Jack at all, and that's not how I see him. I think he's an interesting and fun character in his own right, completely separate from my feelings for Jack.
Similarly, I think Desi is a total badass and I love her. I'm not crazy about her and Mac as a couple just because I feel like until they learn individually how to accept themselves and one another for who they are and actually connect emotionally, the relationship can only be toxic. But I can honestly see myself shipping them (in the right circumstances). That being said, I think Mac/Riley, Desi/Russ, and Desi/Riley are all fun ships that I would love to see.
I don't like Eli at all. I think it's dumb in any fandom to add a character that can do what your supposedly unique main character can. The only person who came close to this in the original was Murdoc, and that was because he was the Moriarty to MacGyver's Sherlock.
I do think that the writers are spending far too much time on side characters this season. I did love to see Desi's family dynamic and Matty and Russ out in the field together, but the show is called MacGyver. Maybe I'm biased because he's my favorite character, but he's also the main one, and I would actually like to see that applied in the show.
My favorite episode of the show is the Tesla one. I loved the depth, the symbolism, the emotional trauma. I wish they'd do more like it. I did think it was incredibly dumb for the writers not to reference Jack at any point in Mac's psyche. He's such a huge part of Mac's life, and that bit of erasure really stopped that episode from being at it's full potential. However, my head canon is that Mac is so upset by Jack leaving that he's locked him away into the back of his mind because he's too painful to think about.
Ultimately, I love this show. Do I think that the writers have always made the right decisions? Absolutely not. Do I think that CBS has handled promotional material well? HECK. NAH. Do I wish Jack would come back? Yes, 100%. But this show still brings me so much joy. I love the characters and the actors and the love that is poured into it by the people who truly care.
And I hope so hard that if even if Jack doesn't make it, that the show will. I want the story to continue because the sad truth of it all is one that we so adamantly try to deny: People die. Shit happens. But just because one person is gone doesn't mean that we can't find a way to move on, even if a part of us will never quite be the same. Jack was a very important part of the show, and he always will be. But the show, like life, can move on, and if they play it right, then his memory will live on. Just like in life.
Anyway, that's my Ted Talk for the day. I'm not at all trying to offend anyone or start an argument, but I've been needing to articulate these thoughts for a very long time and it feels so good to do so. If you disagree with me on any point, that's totally fine.
All this sure feels good to say though.