Dialogue with Gemini (20) Causes of turmoil in Thailand
Prime Minister of Thai:Â PaetongtamďźThaksin's daughterďź
My Question:
Thailand has been in political turmoil for over 10 years. The root of the problem seems to be Thaksin, a Hakka Chinese outsider. The fact that the Thai royal family is also of Chinese descent makes the situation even more complicated, but what is the balance of power between Chinese and non-Chinese residents in Thailand?
Here's a breakdown of the balance of power between Chinese and non-Chinese residents in Thailand, incorporating insights from the provided information:
Historical Context:
Chinese Immigration: Chinese migration to Thailand dates back centuries, with significant influxes occurring during the 19th and 20th centuries. This established a substantial Chinese presence in the country.
Economic Influence: Over time, Thai Chinese have become prominent in the Thai economy, particularly in commerce and business. Their economic influence is considered substantial.
Current Situation:
Population: Thai Chinese constitute approximately 14% of Thailand's population, numbering around 10 million people.
Economic Power: Thai Chinese continue to hold significant economic influence, with a strong presence in various sectors.
Political Participation: While Thai Chinese have historically been active in politics, their direct political power is not proportional to their economic influence. There are both Chinese-Thai politicians and those of non-Chinese descent.
Nuances and Considerations:
Assimilation: Many Thai Chinese have assimilated into Thai society, adopting Thai customs and language while maintaining some cultural ties to their Chinese heritage.
Diversity: The term "Thai Chinese" encompasses individuals with varying degrees of cultural connection to China. Some may have stronger ties than others.
Generational Differences: The political and social views of Thai Chinese can vary across generations, with younger generations often having a stronger sense of Thai national identity.
Additional Insights:
The issue of political turmoil in Thailand is complex and multifaceted. While the role of Thaksin and his Chinese heritage is a factor, it's important to avoid oversimplifying the situation by solely attributing it to ethnic tensions.
The relationship between the Thai royal family and the Chinese community is nuanced. While the royal family has Chinese ancestry, it has also actively promoted Thai nationalism and sought to unify the country.
In Conclusion:
The balance of power between Chinese and non-Chinese residents in Thailand is complex and ever-evolving. While Thai Chinese hold significant economic influence, their political power is not proportional. The relationship between the two groups is multifaceted, with varying degrees of assimilation, cultural connection, and political views. It's crucial to avoid generalizations and recognize the diversity within both groups.
Impression:
While much of the unrest in many Southeast Asian countries stems from conflict between Chinese and non-Chinese residents, Thailand's political turmoil does not appear to be due to that single factor.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
The enduring tension between civilian governments and the military in both Thailand and Pakistan creates a cycle of instability, hindering d
The recent political developments orchestrated by Thaksin Shinawatra in Thailand, including his return from exile, strategic alliances, and the election of a Prime Minister from his party, pose a significant threat to Thai constitutional law and the rule of law. Thaksinâs strategic alliances with former military rivals, and the subsequent election of a Prime Minister from his party, the Pheu Thai Party, have ignited debates about the fragility of democratic institutions in Thailand. Â Drawing parallels with Pakistanâs historical challenges, particularly in military intervention and constitutional manipulation, highlights the gravity of the situation. Both nations share a history of recurrent military interventions, underscoring the need for international engagement to safeguard democratic values globally.
Thaksinâs Machiavellian Moves
Thaksin Shinawatraâs return to Thailand after more than 15 years in exile marked a pivotal moment in the countryâs political landscape. His immediate arrest and subsequent sentencing by the Supreme Court for past offences indicated a contentious relationship between the political elite and the judiciary. However, the real intrigue unfolded in the subsequent political events.
In light of these events, the coalition between the Pheu Thai Party and its former military rivals and Pro-royalists, including the Palang Pracharath Party and United Thai Nation Party, raised eyebrows and fuelled suspicions of a behind-the-scenes deal. This coalition, however, excluded the reformist Move Forward Party, indicating a strategic move by Thaksin to secure power by aligning with forces that had previously seized power from him. The election of Srettha Thavisin as Prime Minister, despite his party finishing second in the May elections, further underscored the complexity of the political manoeuvring orchestrated by Thaksin.
Constitutional Quagmire
Delving into the constitutional implications, both Thailand and Pakistan grapple with recurring challenges, notably military interventions disrupting constitutional norms. Thaksinâs adeptness in striking deals with former military rivals to secure political power mirrors instances in Pakistanâs history where military influence has shaped constitutional trajectories. The Thai Constitution of 2017, akin to its counterpart in Pakistan, has provisions allowing Senators to be appointed without the direct mandate of the people, creating potential loopholes for political manoeuvring. This was evident in the recent coalition formation where strategic alliances with military-backed parties played a crucial role, reflecting a hesitancy to challenge existing power structures.
Thailandâs constitutional order has faced repeated challenges, with military interventions becoming a recurring theme. Thaksinâs ability to strike deals with former military rivals and secure the premiership for his party highlights a concerning trend â the erosion of constitutional norms in favour of political expediency.
Tipping into Authoritarian Shadows
Thaksinâs exclusion of the Move Forward Party and alignment with military-backed forces raises concerns about the autonomy of democratic institutions, mirroring episodes in Pakistan where strategic alliances have tilted the balance towards authoritarian shadows. The international communityâs role in discouraging such manipulations finds resonance in global responses to similar challenges faced by Pakistan.
By scrutinising these specific parallels, we uncover a shared narrative of constitutional challenges, illuminating the intricate similarities between Thailand and Pakistanâs political landscapes. Thaksinâs manoeuvres, seemingly unique to Thailand, find echoes in the historical pages of Pakistanâs constitutional struggles, emphasising the universal relevance of safeguarding democratic values.
Thaksinâs actions, while ostensibly aimed at securing power for his party, pose a significant threat to the democratic fabric of Thailand. The exclusion of the Move Forward Party, which won the most votes and seats in the May general election, from the coalition indicates a disregard for the will of the people. Moreover, the willingness to align with military-backed parties raises questions about the autonomy of democratic institutions.
The international community has a crucial role to play in discouraging such manipulations of democracy. Diplomatic pressure, sanctions, and international condemnation should be employed when democratic processes are subverted. The global commitment to democratic values necessitates a unified stance against actions that undermine the principles of democracy.
To reinforce the connection between Thaksinâs actions and the erosion of democratic values, strengthen the concluding sentence of this section by explicitly highlighting the potential consequences. Emphasise how these actions not only threaten the immediate democratic process but also have long-term implications for the overall health and resilience of democratic institutions in Thailand.
Shared Script of Political Turmoil
Thaksin Shinawatraâs return to Thailand after over 15 years in exile mirrors the return of political figures in Pakistan amid periods of constitutional uncertainty. His immediate clash with the judiciary, symbolised by his arrest and sentencing by the Supreme Court, echoes historical tensions between political elites and the judiciary in Pakistan.
The parallels between Thailand and Pakistan unfold as a shared script of political turmoil, echoing through the corridors of constitutional challenges. Thaksin Shinawatraâs strategic moves in Thailand bear an uncanny resemblance to chapters in Pakistanâs history marked by military interventions and constitutional upheavals. It is potent to dissect these parallels to unravel the constitutional threads that tie these nations together.
The engagement of the international community is crucial for encouraging positive change in both countries. The use of diplomatic pressure, sanctions, and international condemnation can serve as a cheque on the actions of military rulers and reinforce the global commitment to democratic values. By drawing parallels between Thailand and Pakistan, it becomes evident that the erosion of democratic institutions has far-reaching consequences that extend beyond national borders.
Thaksinâs strategic moves may have secured short-term political gains, but the long-term implications for Thai democracy are alarming. The consolidation of power within a network of political elites, including military figures, threatens the principles of democracy, transparency, and accountability. The exclusion of reformist parties like Move Forward from the coalition raises concerns about the governmentâs commitment to bold reforms and the push to remove military influence from politics.
The enduring tension between civilian governments and the military, as seen in both Thailand and Pakistan, creates a cycle of instability that hinders democratic consolidation. The perpetual turmoil not only erodes democratic institutions but also inflicts severe economic setbacks, hinders human rights, and tarnishes international reputations.
Conclusion
In a nutshell, the recent political developments in Thailand orchestrated by Thaksin Shinawatra indeed cast a shadow over the nationâs democratic foundations. The intricate parallels drawn between Thailand and Pakistan, both grappling with historical challenges of military intervention and constitutional manipulation, underscore the fragility of democratic institutions in the face of political expediency. Thaksinâs Machiavellian moves, including strategic alliances with former military rivals and the exclusion of reformist parties, pose a significant threat to Thai constitutional law and the rule of law, echoing episodes in Pakistanâs tumultuous political history.
Furthermore, the constitutional quagmire in both nations reveals shared patterns of erosion, with Thaksinâs adeptness in securing political power through alliances mirroring instances in Pakistan where military influence shaped constitutional trajectories. The autonomy of democratic institutions, crucial for the sustainability of democracy, is compromised when strategic alliances tilt the balance towards authoritarian shadows. The international communityâs engagement is imperative in encouraging positive change, as demonstrated by the need for diplomatic pressure, sanctions, and condemnation to counteract manipulations of democracy.
The enduring tension between civilian governments and the military in both Thailand and Pakistan creates a cycle of instability, hindering democratic consolidation and causing far-reaching consequences. The exclusion of reformist parties raises concerns about the commitment to bold reforms, transparency, and accountability. As the erosion of democratic institutions transcends borders, a collective commitment to safeguarding democratic values globally becomes paramount for fostering stability, economic progress, human rights, and international reputation. Thaksinâs short-term political gains should not overshadow the imperative of preserving the long-term health and resilience of Thai democracy. This commentary underscores the urgent call for the international community to actively participate in safeguarding democratic principles, promoting stability, and fostering a global commitment to democratic values.
Prem Singh Gill
Prem Singh Gill is a visiting scholar at Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta, Indonesia, and a scholar in Thailand.
Bekas Perdana Menteri Thailand, Thaksin Shinawatra dibebaskan dari penjara di Bangkok selepas menghabiskan lapan bulan hukuman penjara satu tahun di sana atas tuduhan berkaitan rasuah, lapor berita Al Jazeera.
Beratus-ratus orang, termasuk keluarga dan sekutu politik jutawan berusia 76 tahun itu dilapor menyambutnya pada Isnin, sambil melaungkan, âKami sayang Thakisnâ ketika dia meninggalkanâŚ
SHAH ALAM â PAS has criticised Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahimâs decision to appoint former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra as a personal adviser for Malaysiaâs ASEAN Chairmanship in 2025. Of course, PAS, a political opponent, will ask and criticise. But the internet is filled with comments and questions. Why Thaksin? They are asking. One X user said Thak sin was PM when twoâŚ
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Filha de Thaksin assume como nova primeira-ministra da Tailândia
Bangkok, Tailândia, 19 de agosto de 2024 (AgĂŞncia de NotĂcias Reuters) â Paetongtarn Shinawatra, filha do ex-primeiro-ministro tailandĂŞs Thaksin Shinawatra, recebeu hoje a carta real de endosso, tornando-se oficialmente a mais jovem primeira-ministra da Tailândia aos 37 anos.
LĂder do maior partido governista, o Pheu Thai, Paetongtarn foi eleita pela câmara baixa tailandesa na sexta-feira (16)âŚ
Filha de Thaksin ĂŠ indicada para substituir premiĂŞ tailandĂŞs
Bangkok, Tailândia, 17 de agosto de 2024 (AgĂŞncia de NotĂcias Thai PBS) â Os partidos da coalizĂŁo governante da Tailândia indicaram Paetongtarn Shinawatra, filha do ex-primeiro-ministro Thaksin Shinawatra, para suceder o premiĂŞ Srettha Thavisin, destituĂdo na quarta-feira (14) pela Corte Constitucional.
Paetongtarn, de 37 anos, deve ser aprovada como nova primeira-ministra em votação parlamentarâŚ
Thaksin Shinawatra moved to hospital on first night in jail - Times of India
BANGKOK: Thailandâs billionaire former leader Thaksin Shinawatra was hospitalised on his first night in prison after his historic return from self-exile, officials said on Wednesday, citing concern about his heart and blood pressure. The influential founder of Thailandâs populist Pheu Thai Party was transferred to a police hospital overnight, 15 hours after a vaunted homecoming from 15 yearsâŚ
