Feedback Needed on a thingy!
Hi everyone, this is Penwrythe and I would like to get some feedback on something!
Over the past three years, I have been working on my worldbuilding project, World of Relics! This setting has sub-worldbuilding projects: Rise of Relics and the Mundane Realm. World of Relics features living objects in a high fantasy setting. They are kind of like the classic fantasy mimics from RPG games and stories, just without the flesh-eating part, lol.
Anyway, while I enjoy working on my stories set in this world, there's a question that popped up in my head regarding a certain trope. The baleful polymorph trope. The baleful polymorph trope is where a character is turned from their human form into something inhuman like an object, monster, or animal to be taught a lesson in humility. It's a classic trope often used in fantasy and even appeared in myths and legends. The trope still exists nowadays, usually appearing in animation. My concern with this trope however is how often BIPOC characters were used for this trope.
Without making things too long here, some people are concerned about how this trope is often used to erase the humanity of BIPOC characters. Like we had to earn our humanity again while the rest of the world stays the same. So there's pushback against the trope to try to get more BIPOC characters to be and stay human. I'm concerned about this too, as a Black person who grew up in the 90s and 2000s seeing little representation of Black characters in children/teens/adult animated media. Representation is important because it can show people who look like me having adventures or taking up responsibilities in their world, making these experiences relatable to me and not something that's out of reach.
It's a personal thing, but I remember not "seeing" myself as Black. I feel like a broken mirror, where my self-reflection of my Blackness is not represented in the way I handle my art or in my imagination. I see myself as a variety of things but not myself. And yet it is me. I am a paradox, lol.
I do represent my Blackness more often now in my art, but that feeling is still there. And I want to explore it. Kind of like a micro-representation thingy? Like, I see my Blackness but I also want to reconcile with my feelings over certain tropes and so on. I want to see my take on this.
So to my point, what do you guys think about me reclaiming the Baleful Polymorph trope for World of Relics. It is the backbone of a certain event that kicks-off Rise of Relics' story and is part of the backstory of the Mundane Realm. My use of this trope will be different from the way it's normally used:
It's not just one character who is turned, it's almost everyone. Plus the transformation is permanent and represents the drastic changes in our lives that force us into a new reality. There is no normal anymore.
Transformed objects/relics still keep their powers and agency. I don't want the characters to keep chasing their humanity. In this new reality they are in, it's gone and they must redefine themselves in this new form to survive.
Agency beyond the physical human form. Humans have great tenacity and perseverance. We see to preserve ourselves in any way possible, even beyond death. I want the same for my object characters.
The Rule of Cool trope. I want my object characters to be cool! Who wants to be a giant laser sword?!
I elaborated on my points here in the FAQ in my World of Relics pitch carrd site. Give it a look and share if you like!
World of Relics Project
I like reclaiming things that once hurt or erased us, but I also want to make sure that I am respectful in using this reclaimed trope. So, as I continue sharing my developments for World of Relics, let me know what you think of my worldbuilding, character design, and stories. I can also share a sample script of how the story of RFR issue #1 kicks off (Maybe chapters 1-3). Thank you for reading!












