The paradox of technology....or something.
I came up with the idea for Take Space one afternoon last year when I heard Sherry Turkle, a professor at MIT who studies the psychology of human relationships with technology say, “I embody the central paradox. I'm a woman who loves getting texts who's going to tell you that too many of them can be a problem.”
I was home alone, watching TedTalks on Instant Netflix that bounced from an app on my iPhone and streamed though my new Chromecast so that I could simultaneously search Linkedin for start-up jobs that offered unlimited vacation time and a take-your-pet to-work policy.
Despite my new found verve for the tech scene and the endlessly amazing perks that came with getting a job in it, I was feeling unenthused about my prospects. I had just decided to temporarily table my dream to be an actor so that I could get a job in an industry that would offer healthcare, pay more, and align better with my values. #firstworldproblems.
Living in San Francisco made tech the obvious choice because who wouldn’t want an endless supply of free snacks while working at a company that is disrupting an industry and saving the world? Yet as I got down to it, something felt just as wrong about joining Silicon Valley as it did joining the obviously fake and harsh world of Hollywood.
Luckily, I had a TedTalk to save the day (as they always do), and it was with Sherry Turkle’s seemingly inane statement on cell phone use that I realized why simply turning to technology wasn’t going to bring me the fulfillment that I’d hoped for in a career.
Silicon Valley is overrun with companies that make our lives easier, connect us more quickly, and find our soulmates, housemates, and workout partners so that we can live more productive and fulfilling lives. It’s a truly invigorating place, perhaps similar to what it would have been like to be in Britain at the start of the Industrial Revolution (if you could replace coal dust with kale chips). It’s an infectious community. It’s impossible to live in San Francisco and not be enticed by it.
Yet each big change brings setbacks. It’s impossible to mention the Bay Area tech scene without discussing soaring house prices and the strain on neighborhood locals.
On a global level, the rise of Smart technology is forcing everyone to keep their heads down both figuratively and literally—I actually walked into someone while crossing the street because we were both texting. According to Turkle, the problem is that technology now lets us chose a “an evening on the social network instead of going to the pub with friends.”
From the beginning of time, technology has evolved to make our lives better. But with this revolution, we often forget one key thing—technology is a tool and not an outcome. It’s as if we’re stuck before the final step. We’ve created the new wheel but we’re so amazed by how it spins that we forget why we made it spin in the first place.
We’re all guilty of it. Turkle, herself, first came to the Ted stage in 1996 to praise the internet’s use in our social life, only to return for this 2012 speech to say that too much technology is actually damaging to our psyche.
We all know the studies that say spending too much time on Facebook leads to depression. So why do we do it?
Because it’s easier. It’s easier to seem connected to the 1,287 friends I have on Facebook than call the twenty I actually want to connect with. And it’s easier to hide behind the online curated version of myself than show who I really am. It’s no wonder that I feel just as skeptical about the tech scene as I do Hollywood. At least when we see images of celebrities we know they’ve been airbrushed to death. We don’t expect the same deception from our friends. And yet we all do it without realizing it.
Turkle best summarizes this paradox by saying, “human relationships are rich and they're messy and they're demanding. And we clean them up with technology. And when we do, one of the things that can happen is that we sacrifice conversation for mere connection. We short-change ourselves. And over time, we seem to forget this, or we seem to stop caring.”
So why join the tech world if it’s not much better than the film industry? And why start a blog? By turning to the internet to speak out, to take space, am I not curating a new version of myself that is equally deceitful?
But at least with technology there’s a glimmer of hope. While we’re definitely still guilty of letting technology get in between our actual relationships, the popularity of companies like Meetup prove that we want to connect with one another in a real way. Chat rooms aren’t cutting it. And Facebook won’t either.
It’s time to use technology as it was meant for. With Take Space I hope to connect to people who I wouldn’t have found otherwise, to encourage others to take space in the real world, and to build the strength to do the same in my own life. We can’t blame technology. We need to see the pitfalls and then fight against them. As Turkle said,
Now we all need to focus on the many, many ways technology can lead us back to our real lives, our own bodies, our own communities, our own politics, our own planet. They need us. Let's talk about how we can use digital technology, the technology of our dreams, to make this life the life we can love.
And so that is why I’m here—to take space in a real way. I’m writing a blog, now, because I can. And maybe I should.
Besides dedicating this week’s post to Sherry Turtle and her 2012 Ted Talk, “Connected, but alone,” I want to give a shout out to a new start-up called Bumble. Think Tinder but with girls in charge. Started by Whitney Wolfe, a former Tinder employee who left after being sexually harassed by the founders, Bumble is a dating app that allows women to make the first move. Men are not allowed to message first and if a girl doesn’t say anything in 24 hours, the match disappears. My roommate went on her first Bumble date last night and said that not only was he the most attractive guy she’s met in SF but he was extremely considerate, intelligent, and funny. Haven’t we always wondered where those men are hiding? Try Bumble and Take Space.