Why are some people so opposed to Rhaenyra having a sword in S3? (And blaming Emma D’arcy for wanting one?)
We’ve seen Rhaenyra use a weapon to defend herself against a boar in S1.
We saw in S2 how she was left defenceless during an assassination attempt, so it’s understandable she’d want a weapon to make her feel safer. Also, she was concerned that the men on her council saw her as more of a daughter or a mother saying; “They will see me as a ruler, and my symbols of authority won't be jewels and gowns but the shield and sword.” During the same scene she says she tires of being protected by others and not being able to do it herself. We saw her briefly holding a sword and lamenting that if she were born a boy she’d have been trained to use it as soon as she could walk. Rhaenyra is also an admirer of Visenya, who had Darksister. Although Aegon has it currently, the catspaw dagger should be Rhaenyra’s and it has significance to her character with the prince that was promised prophecy.
Emma did suggest they wanted a weapon so they had somewhere to put their hands (and it seemed like they were kind of joking and not adamantly demanding one), but it’s seems like the build up to Rhaenyra having one was already laid. It’s entirely possible they were going to get one whether they suggested it or not.
It’s not even a horrible, huge storyline changing thing to have the Queen carry around protection during a civil war. Sure, Rhaenyra isn’t said to have one in the book, but like come on, it’s just a sword, is it really that deep? Out of all the other changes and writing blunders a sword is the hill people want to die on?