Sam and Dean meet Sam and Colby
Supernatural Masterlist // Full Masterlist
A/N: @princessmermaid1289 I'll be honest, I'm not entirely sure if this is along the lines of what you were expecting, but it's what has came into existence. So I can only hope it fills some kind of void. Enjoy (hopefully) x
Sister!Reader x Sam and Dean
Why did you agree to this? Oh, right, you donât want two of your closest friends to accidentally get themselves killed. How they managed to make it out of this place alive the last time they were here, youâre clueless on; then again, half the places Sam and Colby have been in have had a capability of never letting them see the light of day again and yet, here they are.
Youâre attempting to take shelter under a tree on this wet Texas night. Itâs not torrential but its wet enough to be uncomfortable. If it was dry, youâd probably be able to hear the conversation occurring in the car parked a few feet away from you, instead you pay attention to the animated expressions being performed between car seats. The conversation comes to an end eventually as the three bodies in the car exit to join you on the sidewalk.
The three of you exchange hugs and âhelloâs before quickly setting yourselves up to film. Once itâs agreed that everything is being captured the way Sam and Colby need it to be, they begin to introduce you to their audience. Youâre ran through the situation they were in the last time they were here. Yorktown Memorial Hospital truly sounded like a place they shouldnât have made it out of, their description wasnât veering you away from that conclusion, if anything it was making you more certain that they defied death that day.
âSo, the last time we were here, we interacted with Stacy.â Colby explains to you as the three of you make your way through the threshold of the hospital.
âRight, and Stacyâs a little girl?â You questioned, swivelling your head to look at both boys.
âYes, Stacyâs mum worked here, and Stacy would come to work with her.â Sam expanded.
Theyâd given you a small run down before youâd organised a date with each other, youâd pushed for more information at the time, but theyâd wanted to capture your reaction on camera. Its not that you didnât trust them to be safe either, but you didnât want to willingly walk them into danger; your family had taught you better than that, hell, youâve seen it happen enough to know better than that. From what you were told youâd arrived expecting a low key haunting, just a little girl with a tragic backstory, nothing too taxing. Sure, thereâs enough rumours about this place going around, but as far as you were concerned, until there was a legitimate report severe enough to warrant a hunt, they remained rumours.
Sam and Colby continued to narrate your journey through hospital, stopping you once you arrive at Stacyâs corridor. As the camera gets passed between people, a bag gets dropped off Samâs shoulder and you watch for a second to see a small ball and what looks like a childrenâs book be pulled from inside. A glance at your face gives away your confusion and Sam is quick to explain the itemsâ uses: the ball to ask Stacy to roll; and the book to read to Stacy to get her to trust you. You nod in response, slightly unused to communicating with the supernatural in this way, but willing to try it, nonetheless.
The ball gets handed to you, along with the phrase âdo the honoursâ, and you gently roll it down the corridor. Slightly too much force leaves it slowly rolling into the gloom of the space the three of you stand facing. A minute passes with nothing happening, triggering a conversation among you over what was meant to happen and what it would mean in context.
While you werenât talking particularly loudly, it was enough to mask the sound of two grown men opening a door on the other side of the darkness. Heavy boots sound their way down the corridor as your talking volume lowers to silence, three heads turning to see the ball roll its way back out of the gloom, stopping at your feet. The three members of your party almost look to each other, mouth agape in shock, until two very alive bodies emerge from the darkness moments later. Your eyes scan up from their familiar feet to their faces.
âWhat are you doing here?â
âWe could say the same to you.â Your older brother, Sam, retorts back.
Sam and Colby look between you and the two men stood in front of you, having no idea who they are or why youâre talking to them so casually. You turn to face them, working out in your head the best way to explain this to both pairs.
âSam and Colby,â you gesture to them, then swing your arms towards your brothers, âmeet Sam and Dean. My brothers.â
Looks of recognition pass over your friendsâ faces as your brothersâ scrunch in confusion. Sam and Colby donât have any reason to recognise your brother by appearance, but the placement of names and your relation to them inserts faces into stories that youâve told them over time. You approach your brothers beginning to explain who Sam and Colby are and why youâre here. Dean beats you to speaking.
âIs that a camera? Why is there a camera?â he pauses before something clicks, âNo! God, no! You know better than that!â
Your face falls, confused at what would have him so defensive before heâs even gotten to know your company, a slight seething tone slips into your voice, âKnow better than what, Dean?â.
âHanging around with those stupid⌠Ghostfacer idiots.â
âOh, Dean.â You sigh, âTheyâre nothing to do with those imbeciles. Yes, they go filming in haunted spaces. No, they donât go trying to exorcise spirits with no training. Well⌠apart from now, maybe.â
âYou brought them here to exorcise spirits?â Sam â your brother, Sam â interjects.
You turn to face him, not really wanting to see Deans face as he processes the suggestion. You want to object, because the idea is as irresponsible as it seems. Technically, no you hadnât brought them to exorcise spirits, they only told you about one, only Stacy; you werenât feeling like you were going to win the argument. Until your friends step in.
âNo.â Colby steps in to defend you. âShe didnât. We asked her to come, and weâve been here before. We arenât here to specifically exorcise anything either.â
You turn to him, sending a small smile of appreciation his way.
âRight. So why are you here?â Dean questions.
Between you, Sam â not your brother â and Colby, you explain that your there to consult on the little girl they think they interacted with the last time they visited Yorktown Memorial Hospital. They make sure to include something about you being experienced, just to make sure they come across as responsible; theyâre not looking to be throttled by your older, much bigger brothers.
Once everyone is filled in, you take the opportunity to interrogate your brothers as to their presence. They explain to you how Sam saw a report on a group of teens who entered the premises only to be terrorised by something and come away with physical injuries. Dean explains how he almost brushed off the whole thing as an internet hoax. Then Sam had shown him the photos attached to the post, well, the evidence was too plain to leave it. So here they are.
Your brothers linger with you and your friends, watching you film some content, Sam and Colby actively keeping both brothers out of the camera shot. Youâre handed the childrenâs book that was pulled out of the bag earlier.
âWhy am I doing everything?â You ask, the smallest hint of annoyance worming its way into your voice.
âBecauseâŚâ Colby starts and loses any sense of reasoning he was grasping at, Sam rolls his eyes from beside him.
âBecause you werenât here last time, and youâre a female presence; you might be more likely to get a response. Youâre probably more comforting than us.â
You have no further argument to that logic, so you sit yourself on the floor, leaning your back against the wall, legs crossed beneath you. If youâre reading Stacy a book, you might as well offer her the option of sitting with you to look at the pictures. You read the story, making sure to leave the book where you would if you were reading to a living child. While doing so, youâre oblivious to the reaction of the people stood around you, looking on in bewilderment as you act so casually about reading a ghost a storybook.
Youâre standing up from reading as something grabs your arm. A sharp stinging pain rips across your skin with a curse from your lips. Four sets of eyes shoot to you, each of their bodies approaching from their places in the corridor. You hold your arm out in front of you, the light catching your arm enough to show a deep scratch, bleeding a little, in the shape of a human hand clawing its way into your skin, and then down your arm.
Sam and Colby look at each other, worried looks on their faces, as Sam and Dean carry on in their approach to gain a better look at your arm. Sam gently grasps your arm between his hands as he twists it to get a thorough look at the damage. Dean glares at his two new acquaintances as you raise your eyes to look at him, cringing in anticipation of the hellfire about to fall from him.
âWhat the hell was that?â
âThe nuns.â Sam (not your brother) says, taking a visible gulp at Deanâs facial expression and stance.
âThe what, now?â Dean responds, along with a face screaming âexplain now, and explain fastâ.
âThe nuns that used to run the hospital. Theyâre⌠aggressive. At least they are when theyâre present.â Colby contributes.
âWell, well done you! Youâve gotten my sister attacked by nun ghosts!â
Sam and Colby both look to each other, terrified. You pull your arm out of (your brother) Samâs grip and put yourself between Dean, Sam and Colby. Youâd rather stop this physical altercation before it can begin; you love Sam and Colby, but they werenât going to be able to take Dean on, not in this situation.
âCan you just⌠not.â You turn your body to Dean, his stance dropping when he catches another glimpse at your arm. Its an alarming image to say the least, its not that its fatal, but its not a light scratch.
Sam and Dean herd the three of you outside the building and to the impala, delivering the conclusion that you were going to be exorcising something tonight, and itâs not going to be the little girl you just read a bedtime story to. Dean opens the trunk, instantly rifling through for all the salt they have, while Sam reaches for the med kit to tend to your arm.
Sam and Colby wait on their assumed side lines, not wanting to complicate the processes happening at the rear of the car. Their effort to stay out of the situation is ignored, however, when Dean thrusts salt guns and pellets into their arms. Youâre personally too busy wincing at Sam disinfecting your arm âbefore it requires amputationâ in his words.
A whole conversation goes on between your two brothers as this is going down. They go through the options of how to go about expelling these nun ghosts.
âSalt and burn, Sammy? Where are the bones, man?â
âRight. So, haunted object?â
âSam, thatâs the entire building. Weâre not getting away with arson.â
âWell, we canât resolve their issues.â
âTheyâre their own issue. If they canât resolve that then how can we.â
âFair. Last rites⌠something tells me they arenât going to be willing to move on. Even if we could find a priest.â
âIsnât going to help us.â
You furrow your brow at Deanâs tone in that last sentence, concerned about the tension between him and his favourite angel. Nowâs not the time to ask. Itâs eventually decided that thereâs no best way to go about expelling however many nuns there are from the hospital. Youâll just have to hope for the best. Which is how youâve ended up in this situation.
Colby dragged across the room from where you were standing, being held against his best efforts to move, salt pellets being shot left right and centre, and you being held by your throat as your gun clatters to the ground at your feet. Hoping for the best, turns out, was not enough. The hand around your throat tightens slightly as you claw at air trying to loosen the grip. Everyone around you is far too distracted with trying to not get themselves killed to notice anything happening in your vicinity. Like the little girl gliding her way into the space before you. Until she screams.
The room stops. Movement and sound ceasing. The four head of the people you know whip to your direction as your neck gets released and your body drops as a subsequent reaction. You make the most of the air you can get into your lungs now, oblivious to the foggy cloud of nun floating around and away from you.
The room around you stays frozen as the girl makes her way around the room, sending each nun into a cloudy existence. You only notice the lack of nuns in the room when you have four men at your sides checking that youâre alive and okay. You donât care about them, though, as you look up to the girlâs face. You furrow your eyebrows as you try to work out why her face seems familiar to you. She simply smiles at you on her way back through the door she entered. The others only look away from you when the noise of a ball bouncing across the floor begs for their attention.
They take this as the moment to leave before anything else can attack you. Your brothers send you, Sam and Colby out on your own first. The two of them stay behind and collect any of their gear that they can still get use out of.
You stand outside of the hospital with Sam and Colby, leaning against their car, sipping at a bottle of water theyâve handed you from their trunk.
âTell me you guys at least got a good video out of me almost dying in there?â
âIâll be honest, the camera was off as soon as you finished reading.â
âSam! Really! I almost died and you didnât get it on camera?â You glared at both of them, giving them each a solid few seconds of rage until they looked apologetic.
âIn Samâs defence, we didnât really feel like getting murdered by either of your brothers.â