「 I’ll never be good enough. 」
•─────────────•°•❀•°•─────────────•
Pairings: Carmen Berzatto x Gender Neutral Reader
Summary / A/N: I had a crappy dream, so now I’m posting an angsty, unedited story that may or may not be added onto. Idk. Here’s some ambience I listened to on loop to keep me the mood in case you wanted to listen to it while reading.
Warnings: Pity party, angst, love for outer space, unedited (I wrote this almost nonstop for about three or four hours), gender of reader not specified, just a smidge of fluff if that
AO3
Masterlist
Ko-Fi
•─────────────•°•❀•°•─────────────•
You remembered when you believed the lies told by people who had their pick of people yet choice to remain single, all better looking and taking a break from the supposedly full dating pool.
Be yourself, they’d say, there’s someone for everyone.
You believed that once , when you were still young and naive and desperate. You were technically still young, thirty five, but your lack of intimate knowledge suggested otherwise. Those were the days you’d thought about just hiring someone to be with. If others couldn’t see how great you were, you would make them see. But your pride and nerves got the better of you before you could send the message.
A little longer, you’d said that night. You were only twenty three at the time. Yeah it was a little later than most people expected one to be untouched, but some guys were into that. With the new job you were moving to a new city, one with plenty of people and opportunities to meet them.
You wrote articles about things you actually cared about with a company that hadn’t been persuaded to put out what’s trending for more money. You met some great people who happened to have a couple of the same interests as you, one man standing out in particular.
He was nice and respectful and incredibly handsome. It wasn’t long before you grew something of a schoolgirl crush on him. You did what those people said all that time ago in the videos and online. You were your same nerdy yet curious self, talking to him about your favorite things—outer space being the main one. You couldn’t help it.
Space felt like the only thing more misunderstood than you. It was seen as mysterious and dangous but it’s beautiful despite it all. Once one got past the gravity and distance which protected it from ruin, it welcomed exploration with open arms. Its true beauty was revealed.
Hours and hours you both would spend talking about any and everything. He loved nature untouched by man. He invited you to go hiking to his favorite spot every other weekend. He was more nerdy than he let on, pointing out a few species of plants to avoid touching even though their looks suggested otherwise. You were one of those plants but vice versa. You were left for so many years avoided because a few leaves were withered and misshapen, but your fruit was still the same. You still desired what everyone else wanted, water, sunlight, and careful attention.
You thought he was the one.
The day you worked up the nerve to talk to him was one of the scariest days of your life. You couldn’t sit still for anything, you heart was pounding in your ears, and you kept writing what to say in your journal so you wouldn’t mess up.
Just tell him that you like him, you thought. Just be honest. It’s not like he’ll laugh at you. He IS your friend.
You waited until you both were in the depths of nature one weekend to come clean.
“Are you okay? You kinda went quiet there for a second,” he asked.
You wrung your hands together, an uncomfortable feeling bubbling in your stomach.
“Yeah, I’m fine,” you started but sighed instead.
He stopped in his tracks, turning to you with a watchful gaze you’d longed for for so long. This was it. The moment where your life would either begin or collapse.
“What’s wrong?”
“I-I have something to tell you but I don’t know how you’ll take it.”
“You can tell me anything, you know that.”
You looked into his kind eyes, all worried yet beautiful that you wanted to get lost in. That you believed wouldn’t hurt you. You believed him.
“Ok, well, I, we’ve-we’ve known each other for a while and—“ you wrung your hands together, “and since then I-I think I have feelings for you. Like, romantically.”
You took a deep breath, the weight slipping off your shoulders gradually as your confession settled between you.
He muttered your name and from the way he said it, your heart sunk in your chest. You were already calling yourself everything under the sun. Stupid, idiot, hideous—
“I didn’t know you felt that way.”
He chuckled awkwardly, adjusting the pack on his back.
“You’re a great person and an even better friend, but I don’t feel that way about you.”
The pain was immense, the anxiety even worse. Though there was no one or nothing around, it felt like a thousand eyes were on you, mocking you from the shadows. Laughing.
But you pushed back the eager tears burning your eyes and nodded, attempting a little smile.
“Hey, it was worth a shot,” you said. You had no idea how your voice came out steady, much less how you hadn’t broken down immediately.
“No hard feelings?” He asked.
“Course not,” you bumped his shoulder with your own.
The hike was a bit tense for a while before the incident slipped away as you both continued to get up to your usual shenanigans, as if it not your feelings had never been real.
He drove you home like usual and, with a smile and wave, you slipped into your house. You leaned against the door, sliding down to the floor where you stayed for an hour or so, trying and failing to contain your tears and thoughts of inadequacy.
You didn’t know what you did wrong, why you had been born with something you needed, why you couldn’t have what everyone else did. Was it because of some sick deity or a case of genetic coincidence? You didn’t know. All you knew was heartache, constant pain and anxiety at the fact that no one would love you the way you wanted.
Work was no different the following Monday. You pushed your pain aside like normal to maintain what care you did have. But it did hurt, to hear your coworkers and friends talk about relationships as if it were some casual and natural thing. While you were laughing and joking as if you understood, as if you didn’t have to come to terms with the fact that you would never be able to fulfill a big desire you’d had since you were younger.
The years passed by in a blink. That day was your thirty fifth birthday. You were still friends with the handful of people you met at work, including him, but this time most of them were married with children or ones on the way. The only thing you had was a backlog of chats from various internet dating sites, all left unfinished as you or the other party couldn’t be bothered to pretend something was there.
They’d been planning your birthday party since last month. It was an overseas trip on a cruise you’d always wanted to take. There were pg games, gambling, delicious food, and luxurious accommodations. You thought it was only fair to pick up the tabs on land since they’d bought the cruise tickets, but they were having none of it. It was the best birthday present you’d ever gotten, yet why did you feel so…sad, empty?
At dinner, you looked around the table at your friends, some with their spouses and kids, and felt the familiar welling of tears in your eyes. They fell before you could stop them.
“What’s wrong, hon?”
You brushed them away and painted on a watery smile, your excuse coming out as natural as breath.
“You guys didn’t have to do this for me. I’m just so lucky I met you all.”
A few aw’s went around, those nearest to you pulling you into a hug and patting your back. You excused yourself to the bathroom, claiming to want to fix your makeup. But after you checked to make sure the stalls were empty, you bawled your eyes out. You were thirty five. The amount of dates you’d been on could be counted with barely both hands. You were still a virgin and the fact that you’d turned thirty five meant that that would probably never change.
You got some tissue and dabbed at your eyes and nose with cold water, fanning your face to dry your eyes and regain your composure. You eventually do fix your makeup and return to your group, the joyful mask in place once more even though you were falling apart internally.
It started to hurt less after a while—three years. You had to accept what was meant to be, that you just weren’t meant to be cared for in that way. But you had your friends. They were the best that you could’ve asked for. They entertained your nerdy tangents about space and were a phone call away should you need them. They were practically family. If romance wasn’t in the cards for you, the least you could do was extend the same friendship that they’d offered to you to others who needed it.
It was a calm fall night in the city. Streetlamps glowed lazily around the park, lighting the open space with an almost eerie orange light. You were the only one there, sitting on a bench just off the paved path. A gentle cool breeze brushed against your cheeks which had started to numb a bit, but you remained sitting, your gaze turned to the stars. You couldn’t leave yet, not until the meteor shower started.
A repetitive clicking sound torn your attention from the sky to further down the path. A man was walking along the path in your direction, his head bowed to block out the wind. A cigarette hung from his lips, a trembling hand flicking the lighter in a silent plea to work. He stopped a few feet away from where you were sitting, shaking the cheap lighter to get any bit of fuel he could to light the cigarette he clearly needed.
You pulled out the one you kept in your pocket from a time before, taking it by habit rather than expecting to actually use it.
“Wanna use mine?” You asked.
His head shot up, startled by realizing that someone else was around. You extended it to him. He looked between it and you as if confirming something in his mind before reaching out to take it.
“Thanks,” he said.
The nearly full lighter flicked on the first time. He held it to the end of his cigarette, taking a huge drag before releasing it, his shoulders visibly deflating of the weight he carried around. You shook your head when he tried to offer the lighter back to you.
“You keep it. I don’t have much use for it now.”
He nodded, storing it away in his jacket pocket. You looked at your phone. 1:43am. You’d pay for staying up for so long, but you had the rest of your life to sleep. In a few minutes, you’d see something that most people wouldn’t see in their lifetime.
“Are you, uh, waiting for someone?”
The man shifted in place, stuffing his hands in his pockets.
“No, just a meteor shower.”
You kept a vigilant watch on the sky as you continued on, unable to help the eagerness in your tone.
“It’s the last one of the year that I’ll be able to see from here.”
“Oh, that’s pretty cool.”
You held back a hum of disbelief. You’d heard those words plenty of times before the other person changed the subject or found some excuse to leave the conversation. There weren’t many people interested in stargazing or “daydreaming” as you had been accused of. Though when you spared him a glance, he was now looking at the sky, turning his head in different directions as if trying to spot out a hint of when it would start.
“I’m guessing you haven’t seen one before,” you said.
“No, uh, I haven’t. Just whatever’s in the movies, I guess.”
You looked down at your phone. 1:49.
“Well lucky for you that you’re out at the right time to watch the real thing. Just watch.”
In a matter of moments, bright streaks began to trail sporadically across the night. Some were short. Others had long tails that drew a line that remained for a few seconds after the meteor disappeared. He cursed under his breath, taking in the ethereal sight. You laid back on the bench to give your neck a rest, the world opening up more to reveal meteors further away. You sighed, longing to reach out and touch the sky, to ride away on the meteors and away from the responsibilities that life on earth brought. You’d make sure to explore everything so it didn’t feel left out.
“Can I…?”
His voice brought you back to the ground. He nodded to the empty spot beside you. You gestured to it. He sat there, mimicking your relaxed stance and goes back to watching the sky. His cigarette burned idly between his fingers, the acrid smoke mingling with his cologne, the scent of flour, and the fresh yet subtly sweet smell of the surrounding plants.
Time seemed to slow to a crawl as you both took in the mystique of space and a tiny portion of what it had to offer.
“This is definitely better than the movies.”
“Every time.”
It was nearly 2:30am when you decided to head home. You sighed, your limbs heavy and your joints popping when you stood up. You would’ve stayed out there all night if you weren’t fighting a losing battle with sleep. You used to be able to stay up for two days at a time when you were in your twenties. Nowadays, you were lucky if you lasted a day before succumbing to your warm, plush, welcoming bed.
You rubbed your half lidded eyes, covering a yawn with your other hand.
“I’m gonna call it a night. I’m well past my bedtime.”
“I probably should too. I have to work in the morning, well in a few hours.”
“Damn, I’m sorry to hear that.”
He chuckled.
“Yeah, me too.”
There was a moment of stillness, neither making a move to leave. You looked up at the sky once more, getting your fill of the shower which had slowed down before you turned back to him.
“Well, I’m off. Have a good rest of your night, morning, whatever.”
“Thanks, you too.”
You left the park and began the walk home, still spying glimpses of the shower between the lights of the city.












