Needed more space for my thoughts than replies allow and didn't wanna bog down the thread, this is related to my last reblog (about South Park being terrible and people shitting on its fans).
I genuinely love watching South Park.
If I need something on in the background or just something to watch and turn my brain off to, I will always choose it.
Does that mean its any good? No.
Does it have good rep for minorities? No.
Does it have any good messages directly stated literally ever? No!
Some episodes are pure satire on modern society while others are just intentionally mean, either to a group or only one person, and I feel like both routes are pretty clearly done in each episode. It's fairly rare (though not impossible, obviously) to find an episode of SP in the recent seasons that isn't an identifiable satire on a situation or political climate or pop cultural /thing/ going on. Also rare to watch an episode and not understand exactly what they're making fun of: racists, homophobia, religion, politics, health fads, rich people, bad parenting, poor government oversight, failing education systems, the list goes on.
Keep in mind, even when they're making fun of something objectively bad, like racists and homophobes, they usually only have one (1) voice of reason MAXIMUM in the episode. If any, at all.
The rest of the town, or some one-off characters, are usually going to perpetuate some terrible thing related to the plot that day. They may even make it look like the town agrees with the bad take, potentially even making it true for the rest of the series. Canonically, the entire town is extremely judgemental and xenophobic, there is literally no argument for them not being that way. It's shown multiple times.
The reason I don't mind any of this is because zero characters in South Park are inherently good, non-flawed people.
Even the "good guys" in the show are very openly displayed as pieces of shit multiple times throughout the series.
Whether it's from the earlier seasons and all the kids are just snot-nosed kids who don't know any better or in the later seasons where the adults, who are supposed to be the good examples for them, make horrific and baffling decisions on how to handle even minor inconveniences in the town.
EVERY person in South Park is a flawed, usually downright terrible, human being.
And. That. Is. The. Point.
If South Park wanted to be Family Guy and have "good" protagonists, they would keep all of the flaws in their main cast but back-fill each one of them with relatable and well-meaning traits also. They would be normal, classic, non-malicious but still very flawed and destructive people, just like in Family Guy and American Dad and every rip-off of them ever made.
Some characters have that, sure, but sparingly.
Most don't even get a single good quality about them, or if they do they somehow take it to such an extreme that it's almost worse than the bad qualities entirely.
They don't want to make a show with a great message every episode (despite also parodying that in some earlier seasons, when the kids acted more like kids), they wanted to make a comedy show that depicts the absolute worst, hell-spawned, unjustifiable, batshit insane town of people that still clearly represent everything wrong in our modern society.
Yes, they have racism directly in the show. They WANT you to see that it's racist and bad.
Yes, they have ableism directly in the show. They WANT you to see that it's ableist and bad.
Yes, they have "insert-literally-any-ism-you-can-think-of" in the show and very proudly display it for all to see and critique and shit on.
Because they want you to see it and shit on it and know it's bad.
That is the intention of each and every minute of every episode.
Even in the episodes where it ends with a message that should be encouraging, "just be yourself" "treat others how you want to be treated" "despite our differences we're all the same inside" etc, it's usually undermined by the context being so warped and otherwordly that it basically can't be applied to a normal scenario anymore.
The characters learned something but they and the town didn't improve as people or a collective. They are too flawed to ever be redeemed, because they are only ever going to be our worst aspects.
Again, does that make the show inherently good? Absolutely not!
You can hate the show, you can get sick of its bad jokes and bad representation, you can wish it stopped airing by now and you can wish that it was never made in the first place.
But shitting on people who even passively enjoy the show is just not a good take. People like things for different reasons.
If someone loves South Park because they feel joy from seeing someone be a racist bigot, yes absolutely call out that person.
But liking South Park at all is not a sign of this.
If someone loves South Park because even the worst jokes still point out how insane it is to think that day's -isms are justified somehow, in a lighter tone than we currently get while doom-scrolling, I see nothing wrong with that.
Every day for at least the last decade has seemed like a parade of terrible news and horrific people rising to power or enacting some terrible law/getting out of justice for violating the law. It's mind-numbing and terrifying to think about for extended periods.
And sure, we can't avoid the bad shit going on, but at least digesting it in a lighter tone for a short time makes it more bearable while you're still thinking about it.
Aside from literally all of that... It's just a show.
It's not trying to be something great and important, it's there to entertain people. LET people be entertained by it and give the people having to sit down and animate it a paycheck.
If you don't like it, just ignore it.
Don't watch it.
Don't follow people who watch it/post about it.
Don't seek it out just to shit on it more.
Just. Ignore it.
Even me, someone who likes the show, knows that inevitably it will have to stop being made at one point. There will be a last episode and no more channels/streaming services running it one day.
Just wait it out and you'll have one less thing to be mad about.
In the meantime, let people who can find a spark of joy in the bleak void just... have it for a moment. It's not a big deal.