Snape and the Muggle Therapist
Therapist: "So tell me more about your school experience Professor, you teached in a school ,where you were a student yourself, correct?"
Snape:"Precisely, but I don't want to dwell in memories, being surrounded by simple minded people".
Therapist:" Oh? I thought you spent most of your time in that school with Lily? I doubt you mean her. Why don't you tell me more of her."
Snape:" Why? So that you could dissect her? Pick her apart? Tell me what I should think about her?"
Therapist:" No, but you were best friends for years, who else should her know better ? I want to know the real Lily."
Snape:"She...was kind. Brilliant.The only light in my world. Always knew what's right and what's wrong"
Therapist:"And.. were there moments where she was unkind? Maybe judgemental?"
Snape:" No, no she always did.. well she laughed when other students made sloppy mistakes in class. Especially people from my....dorm. But that's not that bad."
Therapist:"So...even a kind girl can have her...moments."
Snape:"...She hated being wrong and always demanded being right.Never listened to me. Overreacted over the smallest things.But she was there for me, when no one else was."
Therapist:" Was she ever unkind...to you?"
Snape:"Not on purpose..She turned her back on me. Said she couldn't do it anymore."
Therapist:"Did you ever hurt her?"
Snape:" I made mistakes. I regretted it so much. She knew me. She knew, I didn't mean it."
Therapist:" Even kind people can walk away when they're hurt. Even bright girls with kind hearts."
Snape:" She had her flaws, like every person. She was self-righteous,such a ridiculously quick temper. She once mocked a girl for her secondhand books,telling me how it looked like her stuff survived a war. I thought I was special at that time, for telling me that. But I didn't want to remember that"
Therapist:" That's ...oddly specific."
Snape:" I spent years only to remember the good things. It was easier than to forgive myself or her, for just leaving me...or myself for being an idiot. I refused to just...let it go. I wanted to bathe in that pain... I thought I deserved it.And I still..do."
Therapist:"You loved a girl who wasn't perfect. That's okay. She didn't save you. She didn't owe you anything.".
Snape:"No. But it felt like she did. Since no one else tried."
Therapist:" Doesn't mean she was bad. It means she was just Lily. A normal teenage girl."
Snape:" A girl I pinned all my hopes on, because I had nothing else."
Therapist:" We grieve people as they were, not how we needed them."