you’re the go to headcanon person and this has been keeping me up at night so i raise you this question: where do you think the academy is located? i know it’s filmed in canada, but the only indication of location is that they live in “the city”
Wow, thank you! I hadn’t expected I was doing much more than yelling into a void about my weird obsessions. It’s great to hear that you like my headcanons. Challenge accepted, come at me with your imaginary buildings and let’s make wild assumptions about them:
Let’s first point out that, from a narrative standpoint, not specifying a true location allows the audience to project their own subjective experience onto the places and spaces we see in a show, allowing us to flesh out the worldbuilding through our own assumptions. It also allows the authors and co-creators to amalgamate their own memorable places and spaces together, to create a city of memory and associations personal to them and the message they want to convey.
Coincidental then, but apt, is the fact that all American cities just merge into one generic urbanscape in my head - probably because I’m British and the American dramas I watch don’t go out of their way to diversify their geography not that I’m paying much attention, my bad. So if TUA has specified a city, I missed it completely. I am aware this is very narrow-minded of me and highly inaccurate, so take the following breakdown with a large pinch of salt.
That said, after analysing some screenshots to death and some Googling of historical context - which is the extent to my American socio-historical knowledge - I’ve decided that I headcanon Boston to be the city in question. Or there abouts.
Why? Well, my favourite way to complicate things work out locales is by taking clues from the spaces and buildings themselves, as well as their surroundings. So, let’s do that:
I’d love to go into the Neocolonial (Georgian Revivalist) architecture of the main Academy façade, which places it at about the turn of the 19th/early 20th century, but to be honest my main clues come from the surroundings we see in TUA 1x10, The White Violin:
Reginald Hargreeves arrives off a ship, the Carol Ann, from (we assume by his accent) Victorian England in 1928. See the stamp? “Pier 7 1928″.
We can therefore assume that this ship has arrived at a port in the Northeast. Already I’m drawn towards the New England area. The rest of the immigration card is frustratingly blank, but we can see from the next shot of D.S. Umbrella, the factory that will become the Academy, that the city is a hive of industrial activity – to be expected from a country in the throes of an industrial revolution.
A quick internet search later, and I discover that not only was Massachusetts the cradle for a lot of fundamental infrastructure in the United States at this time, but one of its main industries was textiles – not a big jump to umbrellas from there. Things are coming together.
I then looked at this for a while. This image is, I assume, totally fabricated. Everything in this shot is intended to be there. Looking for more clues – we’ve got corroborating dates, plus fashion and a car that look about right: The grocer’s signage has the date “Est. 1893″, and D.S. Umbrella will in the next shot give its establishment date as 1898. Is that gym advert a legit business? (It is not.) What about the sign for the printing press? That’s interesting - this tells me that not only is the city one of industry, but one of letters. Perhaps I’m picking facts to suit fiction but I know Cambridge, MA, in particular has a long history of literary revolution. Whilst I don’t see Reginald Hargreeves rubbing shoulders with the likes of Transcendentalist poets, I do see him as someone who wishes to surround himself with ingenuity, industry and an affluence that would help furnish his lifestyle: he is after all a jet-setting, Nobel prize scientist and inventor. Although I don’t know much about Boston culture, which would go a long way to helping prove or disprove this theory, I do feel he would fit well into the New England upper class and its preoccupations. What do you think? I’m really curious. Can anyone else shed some light on this? Am I completely off the mark? As always, the ask is open.