#shade!gaster

Othertale 2026 Masterpost.

Othertale 2016 Masterpost.

Analysis + some hcs. (Feel free to take or leave anything.)

Undertale: Something New.

Epic Sanses.

Abyss Team.

I’m still struck by this entire interaction. The way he was obviously waiting to hear what gaster had to say, but the second he actually started talking bro just rolls his eye with his entire full body behind it?? The fucking frowning, down turn of his mouth. Scrunching up his “nose” in his annoyance. Walking away mid conversation.

He’s so expressive and sassy it’s hilarious.

And Gaster holding up his fucking finger like “erm actually ☝️😌”. You can tell this isn’t the first time Gaster has lectured Color like that, nor the first time Color just walked away mid sentence.

MISC:

The Tale Starts Here. (Appears to be an old animated comic.)

Forget Meme.

In watch order, according to superyoumna, but not chronological order:

Caring Short.

Before the Hack (part 1, animation.)

Experiment Short.

Comic then starts here.

IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER:

Experiment Short. (Before the events of Othertale or Undertale.)

Trailer. (Has some stuff from the moment Color absorbed the souls.)

In the Void, unclear when:

Brother & Sister.

Sneeze comic. (Dubious canon.)

Caring Short. (Possibly happens before or during the events of BtH pt1, uncertain.)

Need to be patient.

Not in the Void:

Before the Hack pt 1. (Animation.)

Before the Hack, 2. (Comic. Takes place after the animation.)

*What’s a Star? (Tagged ATH, appears to take place after BtH.)

DUBIOUS CANON: (must be drawn by superyoumna)

In a Relationship? (Color Spectrum Duo.)

The ‘-‘ Virus. (Color Spectrum Duo.)

A Sans Hazard page. / Another one.

Color, Cross & Epic (pt1). / Color, Cross, & Epic (pt2).

Uncle C.

The Stars (pt). / The Stars (pt 2).

Othertale meets Undertale Undyne.

A fake screenshot.

He is right there, right?

Color & Gaster meet Abyss. (In the Void!)

My Good Hotman. (Not canon at all, just here because of Mecha and Color interactions.)

COLOR SPECTRUM DUO/COLORKILLER: (by both superyoumna & rahafwabas.)

SAVE ME.

I won’t kill you.

“Where you go, I go” head ahh.

Something New Happened.

That Was a Real Pain in the Grass.

Killer trying to stab Abyss. / Almost killed Abyss.

Why not?

Nightmare destroying Colorkiller. / NM corrupting Color.

Meme.

Teach me to be a Good Person.

F3 Color Spectrum Duo.

E3 Color Spectrum Duo.

C2 Color Spectrum Duo.

Is Colorkiller canon? // Part 2. // Platonic Colorkiller is canon.

Stream Doodles.

Bruh <3~

Ship them.

Colorkiller ship kids.

Does Rahafwabas ship Killer with Sanses? / Does youmna ship CK?

More pain! <3

Another doodle. (Cross is here too.)

Color wouldn’t like it.

Killer leaves the Gang with Color.

The Killer on the somethingnew blog.

Killer’s new name?

Color & Nightmare.

another shipkid. // ship kid mentioned.

- 😏 👍

Killer & Color mention. // Part 2. // Part 3.

Color vs Killer & Murder & Error.

Further support for the ship.

Used for askblog?

Color & Killer as Finn & Jake.

Bromantic than romantic.

How they first met. (Is up to interpretation.)

Sitting with Cross.

Dividers here, here, and here.

Regarding Othertale.

Cold one with the bois.

Something Great.

Rahaf and Youmna celebrating canon ColorKiller.

Recharging Sleep.

ASKS

| This is NOT meant to be read as strictly canon. It is analysis and personal interpretation based on what’s in the actual canon and based off my own perspectives—sometimes with add ons from others and headcanons as well. Feel free to disagree, agree, reinterpret, or question at will.||

This is a WIP.

OTHERTALE:

My Othertale Rewatch.

Part 1 and Part 2 of the [experiment] analysis.

Wingdings Translation for [experiment].

Caring short analysis.

Nicknames.

Why I think Othertale Asgore and Toriel should have stayed together.

Misc on MTT, Amber, Ivory, alphyne, etc.

Fan decided birthdays.

Nicknames for the rest of the crew.

COLOR!SANS:

Color’s Name: 1 and 2.

Real Life Equivalents for Color’s psychical fragility.

His sass.

Color in the Sans Hazard comic.

Why does he keep living?

Wouldn’t he help Horror and Dust too?

Color’s boundaries and his violence.

Do I think Color struggles to adjust to change?

Color and joining the Star Sanses.

Color on the topic of Siblings.

Color Yap Sesh.

What type of photography Color would be interested in.

THE VOID/POST VOID:

The Effects of His Captivity.

Sensory deprivation, severe sensory sensitivity, and cleithropohobia.

Arm wound.

Resource hoarding and sleeping on the floor.

Potential unhealthy coping mechanisms post-Void. (cw: unsafe sex, trauma, dissociation.)

How the Void translates to a human/humanoid body. (Was inspired by the real life of case of Blanche Monnier.)

Do I think Color would S/H Post-Void?

Immediately post Void.

How long he might’ve been in the Void.

Color, Gaster, and storytelling. / Add on.

More Color & Gaster.

Possible supernatural or magical effects of the Void.

Color and AAC.

Technophobia.

COLOR SPECTRUM DUO:

How Color challenges Killer in a way most don’t have the opportunity or means to do so.

Color and on “fixing” Killer. And how his grief, trauma, and memories could’ve affected his relationships with different Killers.

Emptiness. / More on Color, Killer, Dream and Swap.

On Killer, Nightmare, and Color.

Color & Killer, Kin & Beats + codependency.

Why?

How could Color react to the death & replacement of the first Killer?

IVORY!UNDYNE:

Character + personality analysis.

Ivory could be an ISTJ.

Royal Guard training.

Color and Ivory bonding, and possibly unknowingly to Ivory, with the souls, too.

Ivory Fashion and Hair thoughts.

FISHBONES SIBLINGS:

Ivory and Sage’s childhood speculations.

Ivory and Color magical whump.

On Color.

Ivory and Sage in Underverse.

Fraternal Twins.

THE SOULS:

How the Souls could communicate with Color.

Is it canon Color can communicate with the souls?

Can Color and the souls be read as a system?

Integrity and Color’s autism.

Patience’s knives.

Color feeling like a vehicle for the souls.

How Color could be affected by Perseverance’s potential bad eyesight and dysgraphia. / Part 2.

Kindness & shielding + fire.

Souls Nicknames.

The Souls & their Influence.

EPIC SANSES/CHROMATIC CREW/ABYSS TEAM:

Delta & Color’s apartment. (+ refeeding syndrome.)

Who would meet Epic first? Would Color ever be jealous, upset, or paranoid?

How do I think Color would act when afraid of being alone, forgotten, or abandoned? (Early Post-Void Color.)

Does Color miss the Void?

Handwriting.

Where the Crew could live in Omega Timeline. (Outdated OT map). + Good old days at Grillby’s.

Here is the full ao3 series.

Here is the script for Othertale: Before the Hack. {You can find the official, finished, animated version on this blog—and some of the content seems to be in the comics, which you can also find on this blog.}

Here is three scripts from Othertale Shorts, including pre-canon stuff.

Is Color Egyptian? Would he know Egyptian Arabic and/or have an accent? How old would Color be? How tall is he, is he or Killer taller? Would Color have any hobbies like art, music, etc?

Is Color saving Killer canon to Othertale too, or only Something New? If Color had a pet companion, what animal would he have? Can he travel universe to universe?

Will there be comics about how Color met the other sanses like Killer, Epic, and Delta?

(This is not all the asks, just the ones I thought were important, funny, or relevant. More could possibly be added if I find any.)

OTHERTALE:

English isn’t youmna’s first language, she’s from Egypt.

Is Othertale Youmna’s story, or did someone else write it?

Is Othertale a comic that’s already out, or is it just going to be videos?

Caring Short is an extra scene.

When are you going to update Othertale?

Othertale is an alternate timeline, NOT an alternate universe.

Othertale is an AT, not an AU. There is no 7th soul. Sans is forgotten but not in Gaster’s position. And what funeral?

What did pre-core Gaster look like?

Refs for Othertale Chara & Frisk?

What kind of personality does othertale Frisk have?

Frisk doesn’t exist anymore.

Frisk was supposed to have a great role even though they no longer exist like Sans doesn’t.

Does Flowey exist, if the six souls don’t?

Who created Flowey in this timeline, Gaster or Alphys?

Chara falling down and Asriel’s creation into Flowey still happened.

Othertale monsters can’t break the barrier, but they still have hope.

Does Papyrus know he has a brother, does anyone know about Sans?

Where did Youmna get the idea for Othertale?

Is there a swap AU to othertale?

Is Othertale an animation? Comic?

Differences in Othertale vs Undertale bc of Sans & the souls erasure.

Othertale focuses on everyone.

After the Hack means season 2.

Who’s stronger: Othertale or Undertale Toriel, Asgore, and Flowey? Othertale MTT is stronger than Undertale MTT because he got his body earlier, Alphys main research was to turn monster souls into weapons since the human souls don’t exist, meaning MTT is more of a weapon than a famous star.

Corrupted!Chara.

Amalgamates don’t exist in Othertale.

Do Gaster, Chara, and Frisk exist?

Are there royal guards in Othertale?

Alphyne is canon, Soriel is not, Chara and Asriel happen as usual though youmna cannot say what happened after Chara and Asriel died.

Are Asgore and Toriel still married?

Is it okay to create an alternative version of Othertale?:

Dreemurr’s designs never changed from Undertale.

COLOR & THE SOULS:

Are the souls like MPD/DID for Color?

Color is stronger than Killer and Murder, Error will cause him problems.

Color’s views on canon NM according to rahafwabas: he hurt a lot of people, innocent people and aus, he hurt Killer the most, nightmare doesn’t deserve mercy.

Color is sure Killer will choose a new name someday, but thinks he just needs time. (Also canonically calls him buddy. :] )

Both Gaster and Sans are forgotten.

Are there hints in the Underground that Sans existed?

Like a mysterious sock?

Anyone can do what they want with Color.

Sans only has control over the game from the Void, which is how Undyne got out.

Did he die?

Color gets his name. (+ possible old peek of his soul.)

Color doesn’t like the idea of being shipped with someone he doesn’t know.

Bro doesn’t like the joke.

Explosive flames when he sneezes.

Color, Geno, & Seraphim as Pokemon evolution.

Flames take on longer colors when he has a characteristic trait.

Color’s okay with being a 2nd favorite.

Heya Color!

Is Gaster with you, C? (First use of C as a nickname)

C still loves ketchup.

Color prefers the Patience trait/soul because he cannot control his feelings and Patience calms him down.

Color is sad and looks sad all the time because Papyrus doesn’t remember him.

After absorbing the souls, does Sans feel different? He regrets what he did, and wishes he hadn’t, he misses the good old days at Grillby’s. He can still eat and sleep, but there is no time in the Void, no food, but hunger cues seem to have been taken away as well. He can’t really do anything but sleep anymore. Color has the ability to heal just about anything, except for the dead.

Does Color get headaches when looking at himself too long in the mirror?

Can I get a hug from Color!Sans?

Color!Sans 2C.

Why didn’t Sans get Gaster out? Why isn’t Gaster out yet?

UNDYNE & PAPYRUS:

How did she get the ability to teleport?

Undyne & Papyrus are siblings, Sans in the Void.

Undyne is Paps’ sister, is more responsible, and did not join the royal guard.

In the Royal Guard armor in trailer, didn’t join the Royal Guard.

Undyne would not be stronger than Color, though she has a portion of his powers.

Who is the big sibling?

How did Undyne get Determination?

Undyne can use Gaster Blasters.

Undyne’s “f” heart locket.

Does Papyrus have a necklace that says “best”?

Drawing of Undyne saying thank you.

Undyne drawing.

Are After the Hack Undyne’s stats the same, weaker than, or stronger than Undyne the Undying’s?

After the Hack Undyne is 3x stronger than Undyne the Undying.

Undyne has an important role in Othertale.

Undyne 1A.

Othertale Papyrus is weaker than Undertale Papyrus, he doesn’t have royal guard training and never aspired to join. Sage is nice and kind, but he works as a math teacher as he likes problem solving and children.

Since Papyrus doesn’t want to join the Royal Guard, what does he do? Does he have a job?

Undyne is youmna’s fav character.

Undyne reminds of the Underfell AU itself.

ATH Undyne looks like Underfell Undyne’s design.

How old are Undyne and Papyrus?

Undyne & Papyrus animation short sneak peek.

Undyne still likes anime and manga. She spends every weekend at home with Papyrus, waiting for Alphys to come over with a new anime.

Are the Gaster Blasters a special attack, or just a slightly more powerful regular attack?

1C Undyne.

Othertale meets Undertale Undyne. Ivory thinks lifting rocks is irresponsible and would never do that, is highly protective of Papyrus and describes him as the only person she cares about in this world. She can play piano, she cooks for her and Papyrus, and she and Papyrus watch the MTT show together.

Ivory would not like Undertale Undyne or troublemakers. Ivory is a lot more careful and cautious with new people.

Papyrus & Undyne live in the same house, in Snowdin.

What happened to Undyne’s parents? Did she have parents? Did they die?

HER:

Smiley face can be attributed to anyone, not just Chara.

Error!Undyne?

Have we met her in classic Undertale?

Is she Core!Frisk?

She could be the Player.

She is not Undyne or Chara.

She just wants fun.

Is she a specific person with a name?